Fast-moving invisibility cloaks become visible

January 28, 2016 by Lisa Zyga report
A cylindrical invisibility cloak is perfectly invisible when not in motion (top left) because the incoming light rays have the same frequency as the cloak’s operational frequency. As the cloak’s velocity increases, the frequency of the light changes so that it no longer matches the operational frequency, creating image distortions that cause the cloak to become visible. (Colors correspond to the light’s frequency.) Credit: Halimeh, et al. ©2016 American Physical Society

(—Physicists have found that invisibility cloaks that can achieve perfect invisibility when not in motion will become visible when moving at speeds of around thousands of meters per second. This is because invisibility cloaks appear invisible only to light at a certain frequency called the cloak's "operational frequency." When the cloak is moving at high speeds with respect to an observer, relativistic effects shift the frequency of the light arriving at the cloak so that the light is no longer at the operational frequency. In addition, the light emerging from the cloak undergoes a change in direction that produces a further frequency shift, causing further image distortions for a stationary observer watching the cloak zoom by.

The scientists, Jad C. Halimeh, et al., have published a paper on invisibility cloaks moving at relativistic velocities in a recent issue of Physical Review A.

Although the work shows that high speeds can be detrimental for invisibility cloaks, the physicists also showed that, for light with the right frequency moving in the right direction, the harmful will cancel out, and perfect cloaking can still be achieved. However, this cloaking is now inherently "non-reciprocal," meaning an observer inside the invisibility cloak would be able to see people on the outside.

"The non-reciprocal cloaking is actually quite an interesting feature, as people have been investigating it for quite some time in the context of transformation optics. Here, this effect just came about from the physics – we didn't really design it," Halimeh, a physicist at the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, told

This is the first time that relativistic invisibility cloaks have been investigated, although there has been a great deal of research on other objects moving at relativistic velocities. In general, two unusual phenomena occur in these situations: length contraction (the moving object appears compressed to a stationary observer) and (time slows down for the moving object compared to a stationary observer). These effects have been well-documented for fast-moving particles, and time dilation has even been measured for astronauts, who age a fraction of a second slower aboard the fast-orbiting International Space Station than they would on Earth.

In the new study, the scientists found that length contraction and time dilation also contribute to making an invisibility cloak visible when moving at relativistic speeds. Length contraction and time dilation help create a relativistic Doppler effect, which is similar to the regular Doppler effect that causes a siren to sound higher-pitched (wavelengths are compressed) as it comes closer and lower-pitched (wavelengths are extended) as it moves away. Although the relativistic Doppler effect is more complicated than the regular Doppler effect, in both cases the frequency shift is caused by the relative motion of the source and the observer. Even small frequency shifts as perceived by the cloak cause distortions, technically called "aberrations," that can interfere with the cloak's invisibility. As the cloak's velocity increases, the aberrations become more pronounced.

Yet no matter how fast the cloak is moving, the researchers showed that it's always possible to find a way to restore invisibility at that specific velocity.

"This is achieved by giving light of some frequency the right direction such that the Doppler shift is canceled," Halimeh said. "The relativistic Doppler shift can be seen as an admixture of a longitudinal Doppler red-shift and a transverse Doppler-blue shift. For a given frequency, you can tune the direction such that these two shifts cancel each other out and the cloak ends up seeing the light as having its operational frequency, thereby cloaking it."

Using this strategy, the researchers show that there are infinitely many combinations of light and direction that can be cloaked at any given relativistic velocity. The results will help scientists better understand the abilities and limitations of invisibility cloaks.

"We are interested in such research for two reasons," Halimeh said. "First, it allows us to further investigate whether or not these are electromagnetically equivalent to vacuum. Second, it allows us to better understand the limitations of these cloaks when it comes to a relativistic world, where we have fast-moving objects that we need to cloak or cloak ourselves from, or in case we are in a strong gravitational field, for example, and we wish to have a cloak that works there as well."

As coauthor Dr. Robert Thompson at the University of Otago in New Zealand added, the results go beyond cloaking.

"Scientists around the world are using cloaking as a testbed for the design and construction of new light-controlling technologies that could have a big impact on everything from communications to medical devices, and fully understanding the kinds of effects we're studying is crucial for making the most of these new technologies," Thompson said.

Explore further: Magnetic invisibility cloak shields magnets from magnetic fields

More information: Jad C. Halimeh, et al. "Invisibility cloaks in relativistic motion." Physical Review A. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.93.013850 . Also at arXiv:1510.06144 [physics.optics]

Related Stories

Video: Are invisibility cloaks possible?

July 23, 2015

Have you ever wished you could hide under an invisibility cloak like Harry Potter or conceal your car with a Klingon cloaking device like in Star Trek? In a special Thursday bonus episode of Reactions, we celebrate the International ...

One size cloaks all

November 21, 2012

A metamaterial invisibility cloak that can adapt to hide different sized objects is demonstrated by in Nature Communications this week. The findings represent a useful advance for more practical applications of metamaterial ...

New invisibility cloak hides objects from human view

July 27, 2011

For the first time, scientists have devised an invisibility cloak material that hides objects from detection using light that is visible to humans. The new device is a leap forward in cloaking materials, according to a report ...

Engineers give invisibility cloaks a slimmer design

July 7, 2015

Researchers have developed a new design for a cloaking device that overcomes some of the limitations of existing "invisibility cloaks." In a new study, electrical engineers at the University of California, San Diego have ...

Recommended for you

Probe for nanofibers has atom-scale sensitivity

January 20, 2017

Optical fibers are the backbone of modern communications, shuttling information from A to B through thin glass filaments as pulses of light. They are used extensively in telecommunications, allowing information to travel ...

Magnetic recording with light and no heat on garnet

January 19, 2017

A strong, short light pulse can record data on a magnetic layer of yttrium iron garnet doped with Co-ions. This was discovered by researchers from Radboud University in the Netherlands and Bialystok University in Poland. ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

4.7 / 5 (3) Jan 28, 2016
But then again: If I moved kilometers per second, nobody would see me anyway. Just give us the cloaks already.
5 / 5 (1) Jan 28, 2016
This may not be useful for those of us on the planet, but it seems quite worthwhile for cloaking satellites from ground observatories.
2 / 5 (4) Jan 28, 2016
This is at relativistic velocities. What object did they cloak and get to that speed? This is pure theoretical gibberish if no actual experiment was conducted.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.