Researchers offer 'proof' that oxygen is the only light element in the Earth's core

Earth's core
Diagram of the Earth. Credit: Kelvinsong/Wikipeida

( —A trio of planetary scientists from France, Switzerland and the U.K. has used seismic data, lab experiment results and theoretical calculations as a means to offer proof that oxygen is present in the Earth's outer core. In their paper published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the team describes how they used experimentation in the lab to exclude all other light elements existing in the outer core, leaving oxygen as the sole remainder.

Scientists have believed that the Earth's core is made up mainly of iron—subsequent analysis of readings after earthquakes, volcano eruptions, etc. along with measurements of the Earth's moment of inertia, and the composition of meteorites, has led most to agree that mixed in with the iron is a small amount of nickel. But as the core meets with the mantle, other elements creep in, some of which scientists have suspected are , such as carbon, silicon, sulfur and . Seismic data alone has not been able to reveal which of them might be present, though many have suspected that the most likely is oxygen.

To "prove" which element is present, the researchers simulated conditions in the Earth's core (adding heat and pressure to a piece of iron and nickel) in their lab and then added suspected light elements. One by one they eliminated (using ) all the light elements they tested until settling on oxygen as the sole survivor. Their calculations suggest it makes up 3.7 percent of the outer core. Their testing also indicated that the is also 1.9 percent silicon and that there is no carbon or sulfur.

The researchers acknowledge that their ideas regarding oxygen in the core are not new, and instead suggest their work serves as more of a proof of what has been previously suspected. What they've done, they say, is constrain the number of possible elements and the likely conditions under which the Earth's core was and is different from the mantle.

Oxygen as an ingredient in the core would suggest a warmer early Earth than has been previously theorized, the team notes, one with an oxygen rich magma ocean. More work will have to be done, though, as not all scientists will agree with the results, especially the lack of sulfur, an element present in most meteorites and suspected to make up a sizable portion of Mar's core.

Explore further

Earth's outer core deprived of oxygen: study

More information: A seismologically consistent compositional model of Earth's core, James Badro, et al PNAS, DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1316708111

Earth's core is less dense than iron, and therefore it must contain "light elements," such as S, Si, O, or C. We use ab initio molecular dynamics to calculate the density and bulk sound velocity in liquid metal alloys at the pressure and temperature conditions of Earth's outer core. We compare the velocity and density for any composition in the (Fe–Ni, C, O, Si, S) system to radial seismological models and find a range of compositional models that fit the seismological data. We find no oxygen-free composition that fits the seismological data, and therefore our results indicate that oxygen is always required in the outer core. An oxygen-rich core is a strong indication of high-pressure and high-temperature conditions of core differentiation in a deep magma ocean with an FeO concentration (oxygen fugacity) higher than that of the present-day mantle.

© 2014

Citation: Researchers offer 'proof' that oxygen is the only light element in the Earth's core (2014, May 13) retrieved 22 July 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

May 13, 2014
Neat. Perhaps the collision that created the mood had a bit to do with this too.

May 13, 2014
"Proof"? I guess expecting a science oriented web site to get the facts right is too much. Or perhaps Bob Yirka thinks the word "evidence" is beyond the reading level of most of us and so must use "proof" incorrectly. I DO wonder how well DFT has been adapted for extremely high pressure/high density/high temperature work. As a semi-empirical computational tool, one has to first carefully establish that it matches reality as one moves from well established (and testable) situations/environments. Calibration would seem an enormous challenge.What 'they' claim:"We find that oxygen is required as a major light element in the core, whereas silicon, sulfur, and carbon are not required. We also find that silicon concentration in the core cannot be higher than 4.5%, and sulfur concentration cannot be higher than 2.4%" [using their model]. I see nothing more about C in the abstract and ain't payin $10 to read the paper.

May 13, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

May 13, 2014
And I have proof they are wrong.

Earth's core contains radionuclides.

Certain radionuclides experience beta decay. Helium 4 is lighter than Oxygen.
Certain other radionuclides decay into H3, tritium. Hydrogen 3 is lighter than Oxygen
Tritium istself decays into Helium 3 which is also lighter than oxygen.

Proof certain that there are elements in the Earth's core lighter than oxygen.

May 14, 2014
And I have proof they are wrong.
As per your normal MO, you only *THINK* you know more than actual scientists specializing in the field. In reality, you only continue to indulge your raging case of hubris.

Per known empirical facts and rigorous theory, the inner core is made of iron(mostly)-nickel alloy, with a smattering of siderophiles.


The typical naturally radioactive elements, on the other hand, fall into the Lithophile group -- i.e. they're in the Mantle:


The mantle is liquid; any light elements (such as Helium) -- and particularly noble gases that don't bond to other elements -- generated there, tend to escape upward (and certainly not down into the core!)

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more