Wikipedia's 'Goan war' unmasked as elaborate hoax

Wikipedia is open for anyone to edit and therefore "can be abused to create hoaxes", according to the site
It went undetected for five years on Wikipedia, but now a seemingly meticulous entry about a 17th century conflict between colonial Portugal and India's Maratha empire has been outed as a hoax.

It went undetected for five years on Wikipedia, but now a seemingly meticulous entry about a 17th century conflict between colonial Portugal and India's Maratha empire has been outed as a hoax.

"The Bicholim Conflict" of 1640-41, described in detail in the online piece assessed as a "good article", has been unearthed not as an episode of Goan history, but a tale by a mischievous user.

Added to the site in July 2007, the entry was only uncovered as a lie by another eagle-eyed user in December.

"After careful consideration and some research, I have come to the conclusion that this article is a —a clever and elaborate hoax," wrote user "ShelfSkewed", who found the sources cited also did not exist.

The fantasy conflict has been added to Wikipedia's list of hoaxes that have dogged the site since it was founded in 2001, such as non-existent Bunaka and Gaius Flavius Antoninus, supposed assassin of .

"Fictitious war between the Portuguese rulers of Goa and the Maratha Empire which supposedly took place from mid-1640 to early 1641," says the new reference.

Wikipedia, which has editions in 285 languages, is open for anyone to edit and therefore "can be abused to create hoaxes", according to the site.

"Hoaxes in are considered vandalism, and persistent perpetrators of hoaxes are subject to blocking and banning."


Explore further

English Wikipedia hosts three millionth article

(c) 2013 AFP

Citation: Wikipedia's 'Goan war' unmasked as elaborate hoax (2013, January 8) retrieved 2 April 2020 from https://phys.org/news/2013-01-wikipedia-goan-war-unmasked-elaborate.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
0 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments