Japan's once-mighty tech industry has flagged

Oct 19, 2012 by John Boudreau

In the 1980s, Sony co-founder Akio Morita fired a verbal missile across the Pacific at Silicon Valley: Japan's supremacy in business and technology would overwhelm U.S. competitors and lead to America's decline.

"They were about to conquer the world," recalled Ta-lin Hsu, founder of Palo Alto, Calif.-based H&Q Asia Pacific.

Decades later, though, there is very little swagger in the Land of the Rising Sun, which once dominated the global tech industry, from memory chips to TVs. Many of Japan's consumer electronics giants are now has-beens. Its chips industry is struggling. And China, which surpassed Japan as the world's second-largest economy, now is the chief rival to the United States.

For a nation long proud of its engineering prowess - humanoid robots, high-tech toilets, superfast Internet, high-speed railways - the decline has "been shocking," said Martin Herlihy, a longtime Tokyo consultant and entrepreneur.

Industry experts on both sides of the Pacific, though, caution not to bet against Japan's ability to rebound - something that in the long run, they say, would be good for Silicon Valley and the United States.

"It's significantly in the United States' interest to have an economically strong Japan," U.S. Ambassador to Japan John Roos, former CEO of the powerhouse Palo Alto law firm Wilson Sonsini, told the San Jose Mercury News. "They are our most important ally in the Asia Pacific, and this is the Asia Pacific century."

But Japan's slide from tech titan to a virtual bystander in the new global market has revealed deep weaknesses in its technology culture.

Signs of the decline in the once-dominant Japanese companies that dazzled the world with everything from the Walkman music player to DVD players are everywhere in this fast-paced and sophisticated city. Subways and cafes are packed with young people clutching iPhones and iPads - not Japanese gadgets. And Japanese companies are no longer leaders in the global TV industry.

"You can sell Japanese TVs, but only in Japan," quipped Tokyo University student Masaaki Sugimoto, a 27-year-old in Gucci glasses, a black T-shirt and black pants who is dismayed with his country's corporate tech icons.

Japan's top consumer brands are battling red ink: , Panasonic and Sharp posted billions of dollars in losses last year. Meanwhile, the nation's semiconductor industry, which once instilled fear in Silicon Valley, is in a downward spiral. In 1990, six of the world's top 10 semiconductor companies were Japanese; Intel ranked fourth behind Japanese giants NEC, Toshiba and Hitachi, according to IC Insights. But by 2011, five U.S. chip companies dominated the top 10 and only two Japanese companies, Toshiba and Renesas, were on it. And their combined revenue last calendar year was less than half that of world leader Intel's $49.7 billion.

The pending sale of Elpida, Japan's last maker of DRAM memory chips, for the fire sale price of $2.5 billion to U.S.-based Micron Technology further underscores the demise of the nation's semiconductor industry.

In previous decades, Japan's conglomerates aggressively supported research in next-generation chips. But as some of their other business units struggled with slowing sales, funding for research also slowed, said IC Insights President Bill McClean.

Japan's previous strengths, including a strong local market, a disciplined focus on precision technology and expertise in hardware, have played a role in its undoing, observers say. With the rise of stronger foreign competitors and the shrinking of the Japanese market, Japanese companies need to compete more in the global market, where software expertise, not hardware, is increasingly vital. Furthermore, its traditional corporate culture, which relies on group consensus, once served the country well but now makes it difficult for companies to respond quickly to the fast-changing global economy.

"The Taiwanese make 14 decisions in one phone call: 'Yes, we will deliver.' The Japanese just can't do that," said Hsu, who has deep ties to Japan's technology sector.

Japan's lack of cultural diversity and the high value it places on social conformity prevent the kind of independent thinking that has led to world-changing companies common in , said Sung Won Sohn, a professor of economics at California State University-Channel Islands. "In Japan, you get rewarded for being an organization man, not an independent like Steve Jobs," he said.

That helps explains why Japan, a pioneer in mobile technology, missed out on the hottest global gadget sector - smartphones. Apple and Korea-based Samsung controlled 55 percent of the market in the first quarter of 2012 and more than 90 percent of the smartphone segment's profits, according to ABI Research.

"They completely missed the smartphone phenomenon that started with the iPhone," said Chetan Sharma, an independent wireless industry analyst. "Then they ignored it."

It is part of a larger problem plaguing companies here: converting its smart technology, from digital music players to e-book readers, into products consumers want. "Sony had MP3 players on the market long before Apple had them," said Gartner Director of Research Michael Gartenberg. "But they were really hard to use."

's technology industry has also been hurt by forces outside its control, such as a strong Japanese currency that makes its products pricey in overseas markets and last year's devastating earthquake and tsunami.

There are signs of change.

Panasonic's new president, Kazuhiro Tsuga, has vowed to overhaul his company's business and is instilling a new, faster corporate decision-making process. Sharp is setting up operations around the world to create a more global corporate culture, vowing to create "new essential products," including electronic textbooks. Gaming companies Gree and DeNA and e-commerce giant Rakuten, an investor in the San Francisco-based online bulletin board Pinterest, are examples of a new generation of Japanese enterprises that have the potential to be major global players.

"I am confident the Japanese companies can respond," said startup consultant Herlihy. "If you look at their history, they have dealt with a lot of upheaval - natural disasters, the Warring States period, complete destruction (during World War II). They've gone through a lot. They are a very resilient culture."

Explore further: Line says no IPO this year

5 /5 (1 vote)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Japanese firms in talks on microchip merger

Apr 16, 2009

Renesas Technology Corp. and NEC Electronics Corp. are in merger talks to create Japan's top chipmaker as they seek to survive the global recession, reports said Thursday.

Japan falls behind in chip manufacturing

May 16, 2006

A university study suggests Japan is falling behind other nations in the production of Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) chips for personal computers.

Japan electronic giants eye chip merger: reports

Feb 08, 2012

Three of Japan's biggest electronics companies are to join forces in a chip-making venture, according to reports, days after a swathe of dire results from a sector struggling to compete globally.

Nokia abandons Japan market

Jul 06, 2011

Nokia Corp., battered by the popularity of smartphones, is abandoning the Japanese market, after a brief foray with luxury cell phones costing as much as 20 million yen ($250,000).

Recommended for you

Line says no IPO this year

10 hours ago

The Japan-based operator of popular mobile messaging app Line said Monday it has decided not to go ahead with an initial public offering in Japan or overseas this year.

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Argiod
1 / 5 (2) Oct 20, 2012
Typical result of a greedy nation/industry... eventually the market is saturated and nobody trusts you anymore; especially when you keep reducing the quality and increasing the price.
Argiod
1 / 5 (2) Oct 20, 2012
Anyone surprised? Japan is still trying to recover from the Fukushima disaster. I'm surprised they've lasted this long.
kochevnik
1 / 5 (1) Oct 20, 2012
In USA I would drive Japanese car. But in Moscow I will not even though the Toy dealer is only 3km from my place. Russian roads will destroy most automobiles and I'm not convinced the Toy, developed on smooth Japanese highways, can ever withstand the punishment. Autovaz has the edge because despite overall deficiencies and parts distribution resembling a Caucasian vegetable market, they understand what it is like to drive in Russia.