Atmosphere models seek clues for rocky exoplanets

March 3, 2014 by Elizabeth Howell,
Possible planets of the Gliese 581 system, superimposed on a picture of our own solar system to compare orbital distances. Credit: National Science Foundation/Zina Deretsky

When a distant planet appears as a point of light in a telescope, it's hard to imagine what things are like at the surface. Does rain fall? Is the atmosphere thick, or dissipating into space? How constant is the sunlight on its surface?

Telescopes today are only just beginning to answer that question and get us closer to understanding where extraterrestrial life might exist. As transit across the face of their , it's possible for astronomers to figure out what chemicals are contained in the planet atmospheres, and to make predictions. However, until now only hot giant planets are observable.

Francois Forget, a senior research scientist with the Meteorological Dynamics Laboratory of the Pierre Simon Laplace Institute in Paris, is part of a group trying to create a model for how planetary atmospheres behave on smaller, rocky planets like Earth, based upon observations in our own solar system. He acknowledges it is limited – we know little about such planets farther in the universe – but the model is a start to learning more about other planets.

"It's very ambitious," Forget said. "It's designed in a way so we can simulate, as much as we can, a planet with any kind of around any kind of star, and with this tool explore the range of planets we can have."

His latest work concerning climates on terrestrial exoplanets, carried out with his colleague Jeremy Leconte, is a synthesis of this experience, along with a survey of the research literature. The paper, called "Possible climates on terrestrial exoplanets", is available right now on the prepublishing site Arxiv, and in press with the Proceedings of the Royal Society.

The "punchline" of the research, as Forget put it, is what factors control the composition of a planet's atmosphere. Studying all sorts of planets will help scientists learn more about life and habitability in distant worlds.

Life in strange places

What is the climate on a planet – and in particular how life-friendly it is- depends on three factors: the atmospheric composition (including the presence or absence of an ocean), its parent star's variability, type and distance away from the planet, and the type of planetary rotation.

This can lead to life in unexpected places. Perhaps a star is smaller and weaker than our own sun, but the planet is at a shorter distance than the Earth is to its sun. Since that star's rays have a shorter distance to travel to the planet's surface, they could warm it to a similar extent as the sun does on the Earth.

View of the possible inner planets of the Gliese 581 system along with their star, a red dwarf. Credit: Lynette Cook

Or maybe a planet is roasting right next to a star, tidally locked so that the perpetual day-facing side is too hot to support life. On the night side, however, the atmosphere surrounding the planet could permit pockets of liquid water.

These are all scenarios that Forgetand Leconte are considering. A key figure in their paper looks at the different types of atmospheres that are possible depending on the mass of the planet, and its temperature.

"This is very highly speculative brainstorming on what kind of cocktail of atmosphere we can have on a terrestrial planet," Forget said."We don't know quantitatively where we should put the boundaries between the various types of atmospheres . Also, keep in mind the physical processes that actually control the composition of the atmosphere are extremely difficult to model and simulate and calculate."

The research, however, shows that different kinds of planets tend to have specific sorts of atmospheres.

A gas giant, for example, is so huge that its gravity can hold on to the light elements of hydrogen and helium, which were likely the original elements in the solar system when the sun and planets were just coming together from a gas cloud. Earth likely had these elements in abundance in its atmosphere at the beginning, but lost them over time as the planet's mass is much smaller. A recent Nature Geoscience paper also showed that Mars likely had hydrogen in its atmosphere when it was young.

By contrast, Earth- and Mars-like planets likely would have more carbon dioxide and nitrogen in their atmosphere, the graph shows. Oceans of liquid water are possible. If the planet receives a little too much starlight , however, there can be a runaway greenhouse effect. The star light heats up the water, putting more water vapor in the atmosphere, which enhances the greenhouse effect and amplifies the heating, Forget said. Eventually, all the oceans can be vaporized. Because the Sun's luminosity increases with time, this will eventually happen to the Earth. Fortunately, not for another billion years, according to another recent study by Leconte and Forget. Venus being closer to the Sun, received even more sunlight, causing the hydrogen and oxygen atoms contained in the water to escape and leaving carbon dioxide molecules behind; this created Venus' notoriously thick and stifling atmosphere

Planets farther away from a star similar to our sun (say, at Jupiter's distance) would see the freeze out and collapse on to the surface, although nitrogen can still remain until planets are beyond the equivalent distance of Neptune in our own solar system.

Glancing at Gliese 581

Artist's impression of sunrise over CoRoT-7b, a planet 70% larger than Earth. At the time of its discovery in 2010, it was the smallest known exoplanet. Today, rocky exoplanet finds are common in planetary searchers. Credit: ESO/L. Calçada

As Forget's team refines the model it is also applying the research to current exoplanet discoveries. One notable set was several planet candidates found in recent years around Gliese 581, which is about 20 light-years away.

Astronomers initially felt that Gliese 581c was potentially habitable, but changed their minds after follow-up research, Forget explained. "Initially, the astronomers were very excited about 581c, but very quickly they interacted with climatologists like me who said it cannot be habitable. It is way too close to the star and there will be a runaway greenhouse effect," he said.

A United States-led team discovered Gliese 581g in the center of the star's habitable region, but that planet has been called into dispute by others who said the discovery was a fluke in the data and not an actual planet. Another planet, Gliese 581d was thought to be too cold as it receives less than a third of the stellar energy Earth does while being so close to its dwarf star that it is likely tidally locked, with one side perpetually facing the star. (That's similar to how the moon's rotation behaves around Earth, Forget pointed out.)

"With another member of the team, Robin Wordsworth, we applied our model to the planet and found it was quite easy to show that, with a reasonably thick atmosphere, it still has warm enough temperatures for liquid water, so it's not impossible that it was habitable," he said.

As for Gliese 581c – the planet that initially excited astronomers – Forget and Leconte are not altogether ruling out habitability. There could be different climate regions on the planet, with a spot at the edge of the night side still cool enough for .

Two motivations drive Forget's team to learn more. The first one is to prepare for observations for a time when telescopes can pick out more about small exoplanet atmospheres, whatever they are: hot, temperate, or very cold. Also, they hope to "make progress on these never-ending questions on habitability, are we alone in the universe, and so on," he said.

"We have no observations at all about atmospheres on , yet we know there are a lot of terrestrial planets everywhere; a very high fraction of stars have these planets," he added. And when those results come in, Forget's team hopes to be ready to learn more about if life could exist in those places, and how.

Explore further: Life on other planets could be far more widespread, study finds

More information: "Possible climates on terrestrial exoplanets." Francois Forget, Jeremy Leconte. arXiv:1311.3101 [astro-ph.EP]

Related Stories

What are hot Jupiters?

February 13, 2014

When astronomers first discovered other planets, they were completely unlike anything we've ever found in the Solar System. These first planets were known as "hot Jupiters", because they're giant planets – even more massive ...

'Super-Earths' may be dead worlds

February 26, 2014

In the last 20 years the search for Earth-like planets around other stars has accelerated, with the launch of missions like the Kepler space telescope. Using these and observatories on the ground, astronomers have found numerous ...

Hunting for transits of Super-Earth GJ 581e

June 2, 2011

( -- An international team of astronomers has ruled out transits of a water-rich or hydrogen-helium atmosphere planet for Gliese 581e. The host star itself is relatively quiet which means good news for the potential ...

Greenhouse effect could extend habitable zone

August 26, 2011

The distant region beyond Saturn is too cold for liquid water, a necessity for life as we know it. But new research indicates that rocky planets far from their parent star could generate enough heat to keep water flowing ...

Recommended for you

How massive can neutron stars be?

January 16, 2018

Astrophysicists at Goethe University Frankfurt set a new limit for the maximum mass of neutron stars: They cannot exceed 2.16 solar masses.

Hubble weighs in on mass of three million billion suns

January 16, 2018

In 2014, astronomers using the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope found that this enormous galaxy cluster contains the mass of a staggering three million billion suns—so it's little wonder that it has earned the nickname of ...

Black hole spin cranks-up radio volume

January 12, 2018

Statistical analysis of supermassive black holes suggests that the spin of the black hole may play a role in the generation of powerful high-speed jets blasting radio waves and other radiation across the universe.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Mar 03, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
2 / 5 (2) Mar 03, 2014
I think this kind of simulation is beyond current computers AND the data points we have to feed them. Resources better spent elsewhere at this time IMO.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 04, 2014
So much surmising, and so little science ... The mathematical chances of it appearing spontaneously are equivalent to zero

That's rather ironic. You've accused them of speculation, but where did you get the mathematical chance for life?

I think I can effectively argue against your estimate of zero, with actual math. Since it appears that nearly every star has an entire system of planets, and a healthy portion of them are terrestrial, that adds up to an astronomical (litterally) number of terrestrial planets. With that many planets, nearly every possible combination of characteristics will happen in numerous places at various times. Therefore I argue that the chances of the 'right' conditions for the formation of life NOT happening over and over again are nearly zero. Even if life is extremely difficult to form, simple statistics still say it will happen many times in any given galaxy at various times.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 04, 2014
I think this kind of simulation is beyond current computers AND the data points we have to feed them. Resources better spent elsewhere at this time IMO

The computers are probably good enough, but I agree about the data points 100%. It doesn't matter how good your computer is, or even how detailed your simulation is, if you don't know what to plug in for the data, it's useless.

As for this being a waste of money, I wouldn't want NASA to spend much money on it at this point, but it might make a good topic for a competition amongst colleges. It's likely to be the students currently attending college who will compose the majority of researchers when we start to actually get the data they currently lack. I'm sure that someone has already thought of that though.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.