One step closer to commercial edamame production in the US

February 4, 2016
Despite a long history of growing grain soybean, most edamame consumed in the US is imported from Asia. Edamame production in the US is limited by a lack of well-developed weed management practices, due largely to an earlier lack of herbicides registered for the crop. A combination of S-metolachlor with a follow-up application of imazamox was most effective in suppressing weeds and maintaining yield. Credit: ACES News and Public Affairs

Edamame, touted as a healthy snack for its high protein content, is becoming increasingly popular in the United States. The soybean seeds are consumed at an immature stage, giving a sweet and slightly nutty flavor. Yet, despite the fact that grain soybean is grown on approximately 74 million acres in the U.S., the majority of edamame consumed here is imported from Asia. Part of the problem is that production practices, including weed control options, have not been well researched. A new University of Illinois study sheds light on weed management in edamame, bringing the crop one step closer to domestic cultivation.

"Vegetable processors identify interference as a major limitation to domestic edamame production on a commercial scale," says U of I crop scientist and USDA-ARS ecologist Martin Williams.

Hand weeding is an expensive option, as labor costs can approach $500 per acre. And until recently, very few chemical weed control applications were available for use with edamame. An earlier study examining the effects of several registered for grain soybean confirmed that edamame lines were no more susceptible to injury from those herbicides than grain soybean. That study provided evidence that led to the EPA registering new chemicals yearly since 2012.

As Williams notes, "Effective isn't about applying one herbicide, and saying 'problem solved.' It requires a multitude of integrated tactics, including a combination of herbicide active ingredients."

The study examined the effects of eight treatments using herbicides applied both pre- and post-emergence, plus a weed-free control and a non-treated control. Registered herbicides clethodim, imazamox, linuron, trifluralin, and S-metolachlor were tested, along with two additional herbicides, imazethapyr and saflufenacil. The researchers measured weed biomass and edamame yield in all treatments, using three different edamame cultivars: IA1010, Butterbean, and Gardensoy 43, which was developed at U of I.

"All weed management treatments increased marketable pod yield relative to the non-treated control, but S-metolachlor with a follow-up application of imazamox had among the highest yield and lowest weed biomass without crop injury."

Since these experiments were initiated, two additional herbicides have been registered (bentazon and fomesafen) and more are being considered.

The three edamame cultivars differed in their ability to compete with weeds. Gardensoy 43, which had the greatest pod yield of the three, also appeared to be the most competitive. In fact, weed biomass was 29 percent lower with Gardensoy 43 than the other cultivars.

The difference in cultivars is promising for all farmers, particularly those interested in using fewer chemicals. In the future, breeders could potentially develop cultivars with even greater tolerance to weed interference. But cultivar improvement is just one piece of the puzzle.

"As part of an integrated system including inter-row cultivation, using cultivars that are more competitive, and using some of the more effective chemical treatments as a package, we are removing weed interference as a barrier to domestic edamame production," Williams says.

Explore further: Left uncontrolled, weeds would cost billions in economic losses every year

More information: Martin M. Williams. Managing Weeds in Commercial Edamame Production: Current Options and Implications, Weed Science (2015). DOI: 10.1614/WS-D-15-00027.1

Related Stories

Making fish farming more sustainable

April 14, 2016

The American Heart Association recommends that we eat fish at least twice a week, since fish are high in protein, low in saturated fats and rich in omega-3 fatty acids. Global per capita fish consumption has almost doubled ...

High-stakes fight over soybeans at US high court

February 18, 2013

(AP)—Vernon Hugh Bowman seems comfortable with the old way of doing things, right down to the rotary-dial telephone he said he was using in a conference call with reporters.

New and old threats to soybean production

June 23, 2011

University of Illinois researchers identified the top pathogens, pests and weeds affecting soybean production in a recent article in Food Security. Soybean aphid, soybean rust, soybean cyst nematode, Sclerotina stem rot and ...

Over-the-top grass control in sorghum on the horizon

September 13, 2010

Apply today's chemicals to a sorghum crop for grass control and the sorghum will be killed off also. But a solution could be only a few years away if Texas AgriLife Research plots are any indication.

Recommended for you

More reasons to eat your broccoli

June 22, 2016

Love it or hate it, broccoli is touted as a superfood, offering an array of health benefits. And it's about to get even more super.

Monkeys get more selective with age

June 23, 2016

As people get older, they become choosier about how they spend their time and with whom they spend it. Now, researchers reporting in the Cell Press journal Current Biology on June 23 find, based on a series of experimental ...

Team discovers new origins for farmed rice

June 22, 2016

Chew on this: rice farming is a far older practice than we knew. In fact, the oldest evidence of domesticated rice has just been found in China, and it's about 9,000 years old.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.