Words to the wise: Experts define wisdom

Compassion. Self-understanding. Morality. Emotional stability.

These words would seem to describe at least some of the universal traits attributed to , each of them broadly recognized and valued. In fact, there is no enduring, consistent definition of what it means exactly to be wise. It is a virtue widely treasured but essentially unexplained, a timeless subject only now attracting rigorous, scientific scrutiny.

In 2009, Dilip V. Jeste, MD, and Thomas W. Meeks, MD, both professors in the department of psychiatry at the University of California, San Diego and researchers at the Sam and Rose Stein Institute for Research on Aging, published a paper proposing that sagacity might have a neurobiological basis.

In other words, that wisdom is wired.

In the June issue of The Gerontologist and currently online, Jeste and Meeks go further, attempting to identify the central, unifying elements that define wisdom. With colleagues from four other universities, Jeste and Meeks asked a group of international experts to characterize the traits of wisdom, and spirituality - and measure how each trait is either similar to or different from the others.

"There are several major definitions of wisdom, but no single definition that is all-inclusive and embraces every important aspect of wisdom," said Jeste, who is the Estelle and Edgar Levi Chair in Aging, professor of psychiatry and and chief of geriatric psychiatry at UC San Diego. "Intelligence and spirituality share features with wisdom, but they are not the same thing. One can be intelligent, yet lack practical knowledge. Spirituality is often associated with age, like wisdom, but most researchers tend to define wisdom in secular terms, not spiritual."

The research consisted of a two-part survey and a questionnaire comprised of 53 statements related to the concepts of wisdom, intelligence and spirituality. Fifty-seven experts were identified and contacted by email; 30 responded.

Phase 1 of the survey revealed significant group differences among the concepts on 49 of 53 statements. Wisdom differed from intelligence on 46 of 49 items, and from spirituality on 31 items.

In Phase 2, the definition of wisdom was further refined by focusing upon 12 items from the Phase 1 results. Most of the experts, Jeste and Meeks said, agreed that wisdom could be characterized thus:

  • It is uniquely human.
  • It is a form of advanced cognitive and emotional development that is experience-driven.
  • It is a personal quality, albeit rare.
  • It can be learned, increases with age and can be measured.
  • It is probably not enhanced by taking medication.
The survey was conducted using the Delphi method, developed by the RAND Corporation in the 1950s and based on the principle that forecasts from a structured group of experts are more accurate than those from unstructured groups or individuals. The paper's authors identified 60 recognized experts on wisdom in the world, focusing upon those outside their own institutions. The nominees were required to have at least two peer-reviewed publications on wisdom or spirituality, though the number of total publications was not the sole criterion for selection.

The survey asked participating experts to rate the relevance and importance of six statements (i.e. "The concept can be applied to human beings."), based upon their knowledge of empirical evidence, to the concepts of intelligence, wisdom and spirituality. The rating scale ranged from 1 (definitely not) to 9 (definitely so). The experts were then asked to rate the importance of 47 components, such as altruism, practical life skills, sense of humor, realism, willingness to forgive others and self-esteem, to the concepts of wisdom, intelligence and spirituality.

"One survey, of course, cannot fully and completely define wisdom," said Jeste. "The value here is that there was considerable agreement among experts that wisdom is indeed a distinct entity with a number of characteristic qualities. The data from our research should help in designing future empirical studies on wisdom."


Explore further

Is there a seat of wisdom in the brain?

Citation: Words to the wise: Experts define wisdom (2010, May 7) retrieved 22 August 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2010-05-words-wise-experts-wisdom.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
0 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

May 07, 2010
Proverbs 2:6
For the LORD gives wisdom;from his mouth come knowledge and understanding;
Proverbs 1:7
The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge;fools despise wisdom and instruction.

May 07, 2010
Although one can look to alleged experts and dictionaries for definitions, most people make definitions up as they go along. Attempting to conform the masses to specifications provided by a handful of unknowns is a lofty goal, and said experts may also be considered lofty in their expectations.

May 07, 2010
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

May 07, 2010
"Wisdom is uniquely human" is a bit of a bold statement when we have no clue as to the internal states and communications of animals.

That wisdom is solely experience-driven is also debatable. For example one might see a lot of wisdom in buddhist teachings. But many of these teachings aren't experience-driven.

May 08, 2010
Phillip Tetlock: Why experts are usually wrong


Tetlock in both articles is talking about the reliability of prediction. This exercise is descriptive, not predictive. Besides, if he's the expert on why the experts are usually wrong isn't he also most likely wrong? :P

May 08, 2010
Greetings...

An Action deliberately chosen to perform self in due consideration amidst all valid and vital choices been valued by Knowledge ( i.e to be awake, aware and acquaint) how to graduate an act especially by selecting 'what not to do ' certain things in certitude of an understanding... This is WISDOM

Knowledge is an element of Wisdom, whilst the manifestation is an Understanding.

Wisdom is your preference ; choice for doing a diligent performance for all of your self into action only by selecting to curtail bare minimum aspects of what not to do...

TO DO ALL OF SELF BY CHOICE GRADUATED BY KNOWLEDGE THAT INFORMS TO CURTAIL WHAT NOT TO DO ... IS WISDOM.

TO DO ALL OF SELF BY CHOICE GRADUATED BY KNOWLEDGE THAT PROPAGATES TO AUGMENT WHAT TO DO ... IS PRUDENCE.

Laconically, misjionder of words as to its use and utility is because beyond grammar and syntax we are not taught fundamental values of etymology and epistemology.

CHARANJEET SINGH LAMBA
cs.astralscientist@gmail.com

May 08, 2010
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

May 08, 2010
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

May 08, 2010
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

May 08, 2010
Wisdom is the ability to live one's life with equanimity and with neither too much attachment nor too much aversion.

May 08, 2010
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

KBK
May 08, 2010
Proverbs 2:6
For the LORD gives wisdom;from his mouth come knowledge and understanding;
Proverbs 1:7
The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge;fools despise wisdom and instruction.


I'm not a religious man, but...

the danger on such a statement lies in the idea that externalization maintains the ego, ie --fear the lord. All workable religions are not really religions, they tell you to look inside. Which is why when the elected Gnostic representative stood up to say exactly that at the first council of Nicaea, the gnostic who was there to say that..was punched in the face by a member of the corporate driven Christian/latin/roman system.

The creation of fear, the maintenance of ego via externalization of self realization into a deity was the real sin and crime against human clarity and man of a most heinous and evil nature.

Thus, in that moment of that single punch western religion was doomed into controlist egoic externalization over that of basic human truth.

May 09, 2010
I'm not sure enough information was provided in the summary above to justify the research conclusions, but in my opinion, Wisdom is the ability to use one's limited knowledge / intelligence / experience to generate successful deductions repeatedly. It includes hesitation / pause, contemplation, consideration, detachment, cunning, creativity, and so on. Without an active mind, wisdom cannot arise... but that activity has to be sophisticated to look beyond the merely visible, to the essence. Wisdom is also culturally defined (which wise choices or wise judgment is valued depends on the context) but the condition or act of wisdom is universal.

I don't think wisdom has anything to do with compassion, emotions, or sentimentalism. Those are ascribed by the authors. But I also don't believe that thought and feeling can be separated... they're intrinsically connected, so perhaps wisdom includes a feeling of some sort.

May 11, 2010
KBK,

It would seem that since modern government wishes to implement itself as the salvation of men for purposes of control, that it would not be a religion problem, so much as a man problem.

Otto,

The first council of Nicaea was over the doctrine of the Trinity and the divinity/humanity of Christ.

Frankly, a gnostic would have been lucky to leave with only a busted nose...they didnt believe in either, or the authority of Scripture.

If men were not corrupt, there would never have been a Bible written. It's whole point and purpose is to the redemption of corrupted man, man that can even abuse and distort religion for his own selfish purposes.

In other words, religions failures have been due to man's corruption, and sense so, one can not attribute man's failures as evidence against religion...especially one with the concepts expressed in the Bible. Its central figure, came not for power or control of the world, but for sacrifice to restore what is broken.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more