Study: One in four divorces 'inefficient'

Sep 13, 2012

(Phys.org)—Many people divorce with hope of finding greater happiness than they did in a "bad" marriage. But a new national study by an Iowa State University economics professor found that in approximately one in four divorces, the individuals involved might have been happier staying married—producing what he calls "inefficient" divorces.

Oleksandr (Alex) Zhylyevskyy, an assistant professor of economics at Iowa State, analyzed the of marriage from self-reported data collected from nearly 3,900 couples who participated in the National Survey of Families and Households between the 1980s and early 2000s.  The study is published in the October issue of the , which is available online.

The ISU researcher is one of the first to explore why some couples have intense disputes but keep living together, while other couples cooperate and the rest . He emphasizes that his results are model specific.

"What the paper actually does is look at the impact of spousal cooperation, conflict and divorce in marriage on the happiness of the spouses," Zhylyevskyy said. "Effectively, I'm trying to get a measure of how happy people are in a particular marital state and analyze factors impacting that across individuals. I can use this model to look at relevant variables and see how changes might affect the incidence of , conflict and divorce among in the United States."

"Among several measures that can be quantified with this model is the incidence of cases in which people who divorced could have been better off had they stayed married," he continued.

Calculating inefficiency in divorce

Zhylyevskyy calculated the inefficiency of divorce given the characteristics of the couples—age, education, race, etc.—as they relate to happiness in marriage, separation and divorce. He also investigated variables that the government has control over—separation period requirements and child support enforcement.

The ISU researcher found that eliminating separation period requirements may decreases the conflict rate between spouses by 9.2 percent of its baseline level and increase the divorce rate by 4.0 percent. He also calculated that perfect child support enforcement may decrease the frequency of conflict by 2.7 percent and divorce by 21.2 percent. It also reduces the incidence of "inefficient" divorces.

Zhylyevskyy says that longer separation periods are likely to increase financial divorce costs because the spouse may need to retain a lawyer for a longer period of time, and there could also be increased psychological cost from being left in marital "limbo" for a longer period of time.

"But the effects of the separation periods do not seem that strong," he said. "What is more interesting is the policy of how effectively child support payments are enforced. What I have seen is that states have some variation as to how well child support is enforced. In some states, you're more likely to be caught if you're a 'deadbeat parent.' The state can locate you and force you to pay. In other states, that doesn't work that well. So the strength of child support enforcement affects what you think about your divorce opportunities and may also impact bargaining between spouses in marriage."

Child support enforcement is a key factor

If all child support payment rulings were enforced, Zhylyevskyy's model predicts that the likelihood of an inefficient divorce goes down.

Zhylyevskyy says his research suggests that the government could indirectly induce people to reconcile their differences and work toward a more successful marriage.

"What I see is some indication that public policy may help decrease inefficiency in divorce," he said. "Inefficient outcomes are bad and are something that should be avoided."

The ISU researcher notes that he did not directly look at the impact of spousal and divorce on the children, which may be an interesting topic to explore in future research.

Explore further: Many solve civil justice problems on their own, rarely involving attorneys

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Divorce hurts health more at earlier ages

Jan 30, 2012

Divorce at a younger age hurts people's health more than divorce later in life, according to a new study by a Michigan State University sociologist.

Researcher Helps People See Beyond the 'Typical' Divorce

Dec 09, 2008

(PhysOrg.com) -- According to a University of Missouri family researcher, there is no “typical divorce.” Realizing this, friends and family members of people experiencing divorce should be aware of the appropriate type ...

First-time divorce rate tied to education, race

Nov 03, 2011

New research from the National Center for Family and Marriage Research (NCFMR) at Bowling Green State University shows there is substantial variation in the first-time divorce rate when it is broken down by race and education. ...

Recommended for you

LGBT advocacy within companies works

2 hours ago

Activism in the workplace surrounding lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) issues is often effective at changing a company's social policies – even before government mandates bring about change, ...

User comments : 0