Study uncovers new hurdle for developing immunotherapies

September 18, 2018 by Deanna Csomo Mccool, University of Notre Dame
Brian Baker, the John A. Zahm, C.S.C., Professor of Structural Biology and chair of the Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry Credit: University of Notre Dame

The body's immune system is a valiant weapon against disease, and harnessing its power through a technique called immunotherapy is at the forefront of current research to treat cancer and other diseases.

That's why an unexpected finding by University of Notre Dame researchers and their collaborators, related to the way two distinctively different peptide antigens react with one T-cell receptor (TCR), tosses a new wrench into the process of building better molecules to develop immunotherapies.

The surprising research showing peptide adaptability was published Monday (Sept. 17) in Nature Chemical Biology. Brian Baker, the John A. Zahm, C.S.C., Professor of Structural Biology and chair of the Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, was principal investigator on the study and worked with co-authors from Notre Dame as well as Stanford University, Loyola University and the University of Kentucky.

"Essentially, we discovered that T-cell receptors can be much more cross-reactive than we previously envisioned, which is somewhat concerning for the entire field," said lead author Timothy Riley, Baker's former graduate research assistant and now co-founder and chief scientific officer of startup Structured Immunity, a company incubated through Notre Dame's IDEA Center that aims to de-risk early stage immunotherapeutics.

T cells are a subtype of a white blood cell responsible for sensing whether you're healthy or have an infection, but they often ignore cancer cells as a potential threat. In T-cell immunotherapy, some of the cells are altered to contain receptors that allow the T cells to seek and destroy specific, undesirable cells when the receptor reacts with specific peptide antigens, an action required to induce an immune response. While the treatment is effective in some cases, in others, it can destroy . Therefore, researchers seek to predict reactivity and assure the reaction is specific only to the cells they want to target.

Scientists knew there were many millions more , or antigen targets, than TCRs. They expected that the recognized and adjusted to many different peptides that have similar properties. In the case of the TCR studied in the current research, DMF5, researchers knew it recognized hydrophobic peptide antigens, which are water-insoluble. But K. Christopher Garcia, the Younger Family Professor and Professor of Structural Biology at Stanford University, alerted Baker to an anomaly uncovered in his own research. Garcia noticed that DMF5 also appeared to bind with a different class of peptides—one that was highly charged and easily dissolvable.

Baker's lab, which has experience in analyzing that TCR, decided to delve deeper.

"We thought the TCR was ignoring small differences (in the highly charged target) a little bit, and simply found things similar to recognize," said Baker, who is also affiliated with the Harper Cancer Research Institute. "But that was wrong. We discovered that this peptide moved and adapted in order for the receptor to bind, in a way that no one had seen before."

The two different peptide antigens worked equally well at binding with DMF5, stimulating the receptor and inducing an . "It doesn't really matter how it works, as long as binding occurs," Riley said.

Though the discovery is notable for increasing the understanding of how to develop immunotherapies, it's an unexpected challenge to overcome, Baker explained. Though the current research was completed on just one TCR and that only two peptides were evaluated, he noted, it's likely that others may function in a similar way.

"What's significant is that people try to make predictions for developing these models for therapy, and about the kinds of ways you can recognize targets," he said. "And this is a new, unanticipated complication."

Researchers have dealt with the knowledge that some TCRs can attack healthy as well as the life-threatening ones they've been engineered to tackle, and have built that concern into their studies. "But for those people who are trying to take advantage of that biology to develop immunotherapies, you have to be worried about this new issue and build it into whatever design platform that you have," Baker said.

Armed with this new discovery, however, Riley is up for the challenge. "Now that we have great examples of a T-cell receptor recognizing multiple peptide antigens that are structurally different, we can use them to build hypotheses and test predictions," he said.

Explore further: Toward an 'ultra-personalized' therapy for melanoma

More information: Timothy P. Riley et al, T cell receptor cross-reactivity expanded by dramatic peptide–MHC adaptability, Nature Chemical Biology (2018). DOI: 10.1038/s41589-018-0130-4

Related Stories

Toward an 'ultra-personalized' therapy for melanoma

September 12, 2018

With new immunotherapy treatments for melanoma, recovery rates have risen dramatically, in some cases to around 50%. But they could be much higher: A new study led by researchers at the Weizmann Institute of Science showed, ...

Engineering the immune system to kill cancer cells

June 15, 2016

In late 2015, former President Jimmy Carter announced that he was free of the metastatic melanoma that had spread to his liver and brain. In addition to surgery and radiation, Carter was treated with an immunotherapy drug, ...

Recommended for you

Engineers repurpose wasp venom as an antibiotic drug

December 7, 2018

The venom of insects such as wasps and bees is full of compounds that can kill bacteria. Unfortunately, many of these compounds are also toxic for humans, making it impossible to use them as antibiotic drugs.

Researchers probe hydrogen bonds using new technique

December 7, 2018

Researchers at Carnegie Mellon University have used nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy to probe the hydrogen bonds that modulate the chemical reactivity of enzymes, catalysts and biomimetic complexes. The technique ...

Are amorphous solids elastic or plastic?

December 7, 2018

In a crystalline solid, the atoms form an ordered lattice. Crystalline solids respond elastically to small deformations: When the applied strain is removed, the macroscopic stress, as well as the microscopic configuration ...

Molecular insights into spider silk

December 7, 2018

Spider silk is one of the toughest fibres in nature and has astounding properties. Scientists from the University of Würzburg discovered new molecular details of self-assembly of a spider silk fibre protein.

Copycat cells command new powers of communication

December 7, 2018

From kryptonite for Superman to plant toxins for poison ivy, chemical reactions within the body's cells can be transformative. And, when it comes to transmuting cells, UC San Diego researchers are becoming superhero-like ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.