Tesla Motors dealing as states play factory poker

August 31, 2014 by Justin Pritchard
This Aug. 1, 2014 file photo shows security guards at the gate to the site Tahoe Reno Industrial Center about 15 miles east of Reno, Nevada. Tesla Motors is considering the site as one of two, or possibly three, finalists where it will build a $5 billion factory to make batteries for a new model of electric car. (AP Photo/Scott Sonner, File)

From the start, little has been typical about Tesla Motors' plan for a $5 billion factory to make batteries for a new generation of electric cars.

It's not just the project's massive scale, the cutting-edge technology, or even the bonanza of 6,500 good-paying jobs.

It's how Tesla is deciding where to build.

Through a series of unusual plays, Tesla has five states bidding up subsidy packages to land the coveted plant. The winner is expected to offer the luxury car-maker publicly financed incentives exceeding a half-billion dollars.

Tesla signaled this would be no ordinary competition last fall, when it gathered officials from seven Western states and unveiled its vision for a "gigafactory." ("Giga" refers to the large amount of power that batteries produced at the plant will store.)

This spring, CEO Elon Musk announced that Tesla would take the extremely unusual step of spending millions to prepare sites in two states—or perhaps even three—before the finalist was chosen. Then, over the summer, Musk said the winning state would pitch in about 10 percent of the cost, effectively signaling a minimum bid of $500 million.

"We don't usually see companies setting a floor at which states will be considered," said Leigh McIlvaine of the research group Good Jobs First, which tracks large subsidy packages by states.

For all the public anticipation Musk has created, much about the process remains secret.

While an industrial park in the desert outside Reno, Nevada, is one known site, the other—or others—remains a mystery. Tesla has asked states not to discuss their offers, and states aren't talking.

The effect is a game of high-stakes poker, with the states as players and Tesla dealing.

"You can't see any cards at all. Do you stay in or not, push more chips onto the table or fold?" said Kim Hill, who studies incentives at the nonprofit Center for Automotive Research in Michigan.

The factory promises something that every state wants but rarely gets these days: thousands of good-paying factory jobs and all the residual economic benefits they bring.

In this June 22, 2012 file photo, Tesla CEO Elon Musk waves during a rally at the Tesla factory in Fremont, Calif. Musk has five states bidding up subsidy packages to land a coveted plant for a $5 billion factory to make batteries for a new generation of Tesla electric cars. (AP Photo/Paul Sakuma, File)

So far, Nevada, California, Texas, Arizona and New Mexico remain contenders. They have passed tax breaks, promised worker-training funds or proposed shelving environmental regulations that could slow the factory's construction. There is talk of special legislative sessions to sweeten the bids.

When The Associated Press filed public records act requests for documents about the competition with each of the five finalist states, none released much useful information and most refused to release anything at all, citing the competitive need to keep their offers secret.

In one glimpse behind the curtain of confidentiality, California provided an email from a Tesla official to the governor's senior adviser for jobs and economic development. It contained a newspaper story speculating on a possible site and said, simply: "This is unhelpful." What might be unhelpful was unclear, and the governor's office of business and economic development refused repeated requests to discuss its pursuit of the factory.

Tesla needs the factory to make cheaper batteries for its Model 3, a mass-market electric car the company hopes to sell by 2017 for around $35,000. Currently Tesla only offers the Model S sedan, which starts at $70,000.

The tight production timeframe compels Tesla to prepare at least two sites, said spokesman Simon Sproule, who likened the approach to "an insurance policy."

Tesla will pay about half of the factory's cost; the other major investor is Panasonic, which will manufacture the lithium-ion battery cells and invest in equipment.

Musk has said to expect groundbreaking on at least one other site in the coming months and a final decision by year's end.

The last comparable bidding frenzy for a factory, according to John Boyd of the New Jersey-based site selection firm The Boyd Company, involved competition to attract automaker Saturn in the 1980s, at the leading edge of the car manufacturing boom in the southern states.

The competition for the gigafactory began at an October meeting at Tesla's auto assembly plant in the San Francisco Bay Area city of Fremont—a rare approach to opening a site selection process. Tesla executives laid out what a winning bid must have: "Green" energy such as solar or wind at a low cost, an affordable and well-trained labor force, good transportation links to Tesla's Fremont assembly plant. And a robust package of incentives.

In this June 10, 2014 file photo, Texas Gov. Rick Perry walks over to talk to reporters after driving up in a Tesla Motors Type S electric car in Sacramento, Calif. Texas and California are two of five states where Tesla Motors is considering building a $5 billion factory to make batteries for a new model of electric car. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli, File)

Tesla required states to submit their proposals within three weeks, an early indication of influence the company would wield. "Given the scale, it was a very short turnaround time," said Susan St. Germain, the lead business recruiter for Washington, who attended the meeting but whose state did not make the short list.

Along the way, there has been plenty of political theater. Texas Gov. Rick Perry drove to California's state Capitol in a Tesla and California state Sen. Ted Gaines delivered a gold-painted shovel to Tesla headquarters. Cities in both states pitched Tesla directly. Tucson, Arizona, sent the company a preapproved building permit.

The director of the industrial park outside Reno where Tesla prepared land said he's seen plenty of secrecy before, but never anything like this.

"It has been a very, very unusual transaction," said Lance Gilman of the Reno Tahoe Industrial Center, which at 167 square miles (433 square kilometers) is the nation's largest industrial park. "They have played their cards so close to the vest."

Texas has done business with Musk before. The state is providing his commercial space company, SpaceX, $15.3 million in incentives to develop a rocket-launching site. The money comes from what is regarded as the nation's most generous "deal-closing fund" of incentives, which has doled out $487 million since 2003.

New Mexico's governor has said that, if needed, she will ask the Legislature to consider changes in law to help land the plant. California Gov. Jerry Brown got lawmakers to pass language helping battery manufacturers, and Musk said Brown is working to address his concerns that California's arduous environmental reviews would make the project's three-year timeframe impossible to meet.

Nevada may hold a special session of its part-time legislature to discuss incentives.

"There's kind of a bidding war out there with the state of California and the state of Texas," said U.S. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, a Nevada Democrat. "We'll have to wait and see. I'm not going to start counting the jobs until it happens."

Explore further: Tesla says decision on battery factory months away

Related Stories

Tesla says decision on battery factory months away

August 1, 2014

(AP)—Electric car maker Tesla Motors said Thursday that it is preparing a site near Reno, Nevada, as a possible location for its new battery factory, but is still evaluating other sites.

California back in running for Tesla battery plant

May 8, 2014

California is back in the running for a massive battery plant that electric car maker Tesla Motors plans to start building this year, but CEO Elon Musk said the state remains in the "improbable" category for winning the plant ...

Panasonic, Tesla to build big US battery plant

July 31, 2014

(AP)—American electric car maker Tesla Motors Inc. is teaming up with Japanese electronics company Panasonic Corp. to build a battery manufacturing plant in the U.S. expected to create 6,500 jobs.

Tesla, Chinese firm plan 400 charging stations

August 29, 2014

Tesla Motors Co. and a state-owned Chinese phone carrier announced plans Friday to build 400 charging stations for electric cars in a new bid to promote popular adoption of the technology in China.

Recommended for you

Cryptocurrency rivals snap at Bitcoin's heels

January 14, 2018

Bitcoin may be the most famous cryptocurrency but, despite a dizzying rise, it's not the most lucrative one and far from alone in a universe that counts 1,400 rivals, and counting.

Top takeaways from Consumers Electronics Show

January 13, 2018

The 2018 Consumer Electronics Show, which concluded Friday in Las Vegas, drew some 4,000 exhibitors from dozens of countries and more than 170,000 attendees, showcased some of the latest from the technology world.

Finnish firm detects new Intel security flaw

January 12, 2018

A new security flaw has been found in Intel hardware which could enable hackers to access corporate laptops remotely, Finnish cybersecurity specialist F-Secure said on Friday.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

2 / 5 (5) Aug 31, 2014
it always ends badly when government gets involved in the marketplace.
5 / 5 (2) Aug 31, 2014
Last year Tesla lost $74 million yet Elon made $78 million in his own profits as the Tesla CEO. I really start believing he's a genius.
3.7 / 5 (3) Sep 01, 2014
@Shootist , no, you misunderstood.

The article is saying that local government will invest money to build a battery factory for Tesla. Why is this bad? Its genius!

The liability is shared by both Tesla & local government instead of Tesla risking it alone with their own money. What local government want is the jobs, and what Tesla want is the factory.

Its win win!
5 / 5 (2) Sep 01, 2014
The Chinese government has a long history of offering foreign companies significant tax breaks to set up their factories there (Detroit anyone?). I think Musk deserves credit for giving the US a chance to compete back in the manufacturing sector.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 01, 2014
@animah is speaking truth. Developing country give tax break for several years (and sometimes no tax at all) and it work. They attempt to rely on trickle-down economic.

I heard that the reason Detroit became bankrupt is because their car factory did not create job, since its all automated assembly.

Sep 01, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
not rated yet Sep 01, 2014
Msafwan, I think you need to go back to grammar school. You pretent[sic] to be an expert on the US. How long have you been there?

So says the pot to the kettle.
1 / 5 (2) Sep 01, 2014
Why is this bad? Its genius!

Good for the crony socialist.
Bad for taxpayers.
not rated yet Sep 01, 2014
@verkle says:
Msafwan, I think you need to go back to grammar school. You pretent to be an expert on the US. ...?

I said "I heard that the reason Detroit became bankrupt is because their car factory ...."

I read or watch this article somewhere, but I can't remember. I wasn't really paying attention. The solution said was: "the local government must be flexible. They must be responsible to creating new job. For example: in New York city, the new job created was in I.T. industries such as programming. The problem with Detroit is that they embraced new automotive technology quickly (upgraded factory automation) but this do not create job. In end, Detroit filed bankruptcy around 1993 or 95?"

When I said "@animah is speaking truth. Developing country give tax break ..."

Is because I live there. I know 1 state have no tax zone and they have a lot of western factory including from Intel. Some Intel CPU is made here.

I do not lie...
not rated yet Sep 01, 2014
@verkle , I found the article, here: http://www.scient...detroit/

google is soo awesome, thank you American people for making everyone soo smart. This article travel 20000Km to me and 20000Km back to you.
5 / 5 (1) Sep 01, 2014
The biggest threat to the "marketplace" is unethical business people. They have crashed the American economy, the government didn't do it. Look there for your socialist puppet crowd.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.