Flattened nanotubes are full of potential: Researchers reveal details of 'closed-edge graphene nanoribbons'

June 21, 2012
Researchers at Rice University found that nanotubes of a large diameter can spontaneously collapse into closed-edge graphene nanoribbons when atoms on the inside wall get close enough to attract each other. (Credit: Ksenia Bets/Rice University)

(Phys.org) -- Squashed nanotubes may be ripe with new possibilities for scientists, according to a new study by Rice University.

Researchers at Rice’s Richard E. Smalley Institute for Nanoscale Science and Technology have come up with a set of facts and figures about carbon nanotubes that appear to collapse during the growth process; they found that these unique configurations have properties of both nanotubes and graphene .

What the researchers call “closed-edge graphene nanoribbons” could kick-start research into their usefulness in electronics and materials applications.

The pioneering work led by Robert Hauge, a distinguished faculty fellow in chemistry at Rice, is detailed in a paper that appeared online this month in the American Chemical Society journal ACS Nano.

“A collapsed nanotube looks a lot like graphene in the middle, but exactly like buckyballs (carbon-60 molecules, a Nobel Prize-winning discovery at Rice) on the sides,” Hauge said. “That means you have the chemistry of graphene in the middle and the chemistry of buckyballs on the edges. And you can separate the two electronically by putting functional groups on the sides to isolate the top and bottom layers.

“If you do edge chemistry that turns the sides into insulators, then the top doesn’t communicate with the bottom electronically, except through some van der Waals-type or excited-state interaction,” he said. “That’s where the new physics and perhaps electronic properties will come from.”

The finding may lead to grown-to-order, two- or four-layer graphene nanoribbons with perfect edges, a product difficult to attain by unzipping or otherwise slicing nanotubes. “The graphene world is searching for ways to make well-defined ribbons,” Hauge said. “They always have to cut up graphene and end up with ill-defined sides that affect their electronic properties. These have the advantage of a much better-defined edge.”

Hauge’s awareness of earlier work on nanotube collapse led him to study the phenomenon. “I’ve been interested in growing larger diameter nanotubes, based on catalyst particle size, for some time now,” he said. “We thought they could collapse, so we started looking for the evidence.”

The team found that folds, twists and kinks in nanotubes seen through a transmission electron microscope and measured through an atomic force microscope were good indicators of collapsed nanotubes. These nanotubes were about 0.7 nanometers in height along the middle and a little more at what the researchers called the “highly strained bulbs” at the edges. But finding flattened tubes didn’t indicate how they got that way.

Hauge approached Rice theoretical physicist Boris Yakobson to see how the intrinsic energy of atoms in graphene – one of his specialties – would allow such a collapse to happen. Yakobson put graduate student and co-author Ksenia Bets on the case.

“Originally, we thought this would be a small and simple problem, and it turned out to be simple – but not that small,” Bets said. Using molecular dynamic simulation, she fit data from the experimentalists to atomistic models of single-wall nanotubes. “And then, using the same parameters, I produced results for double walls, and they also fit exactly with the experimental data.”

The results gathered over six months confirmed the probability that at growth temperature – 750 degrees Celsius – flexible nanotubes fluttering in the gas breeze inside a furnace could indeed be induced to collapse. If two atoms on either side of the inner wall get close enough to each other, they can start a van der Walls cascade that flattens the nanotube, Bets said.

“At first, it takes energy to press the nanotube, but you reach a point where the two sides begin to feel each other, and they begin to gain the energy of attraction,” Hauge said. “The van der Waals force takes over, and the tubes then prefer to be collapsed.”

He said the energy required to collapse a nanotube decreases as the tube’s diameter increases. “It’s like a straw,” he said. “For a single-wall nanotube, the bigger it gets, the easier it is to distort.”

More significant were calculations that determined the specific diameters at which nanotubes become prone to collapse. There’s a point, Hauge said, at which a nanotube could go either way, so the dispersion of nanotubes to nanoribbons in a batch of a particular diameter should be about equal. As diameter increases, the balance shifts in the ribbons’ favor.

“It’s a playoff between the strain energy on the edges versus the van der Walls interaction in the center,” he said. Specifically, they found that freestanding single-wall tubes become amenable to collapse when they are at least 2.6 nanometers in diameter — what the researchers called the “energy equivalence point.” Theory dictates that diameter would drop to 1.9 nanometers for a single-wall tube sitting on a surface, he said, because of additional atomic interaction with the substrate.

Double-wall nanotubes reach energy equivalence at 4 nanometers, Hauge said, but nanotubes with more walls would take much more – probably too much – energy to collapse.

Bets’ formulas agreed nicely with his group’s observations, Hauge said. “What we measured in this paper for the first time is the point where the energy of a collapsed tube is equal to that of an uncollapsed tube,” he said. “That’s the tipping point. Anything above, energetically, prefers to be collapsed rather than uncollapsed. It’s a fundamental property of nanotubes that hadn’t been measured before.”

The discovery has implications for bundles of nanotubes beginning to see use in fibers for electrical applications or as strengthening elements in advanced materials. “The question is whether a layer of collapsed tubes in a bundle is actually more energetically favorable than that same bundle of hexagonally shaped tubes,” Hauge said. “That hasn’t been determined.”

Many basic questions remain, Hauge said. The researchers don’t know whether a nanotube collapses along its entire length, nor whether pressure from outside could start a chain reaction leading to collapse. “It’s possible that you could apply pressure to force everything to collapse, and it would stay that way because that’s what it wants to be,” he said. They would also like to know whether a nanotube’s chirality – its internal arrangement of atoms – influences collapsing.

But he believes nano researchers will have a field day with the possibilities. “This should get people thinking about the whole area of larger-diameter nanotubes and what they might offer,” he said. “It’s like what that guy on the radio used to say: We’ve all heard the story of – and now we know the rest of the story.”

Explore further: Two-dimensional boron has potential advantages over graphene

More information: Read the abstract at pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/nn301039v

Related Stories

Graphene can be strengthened by folding

September 20, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- With a strength 200 times greater than that of steel, graphene is the strongest known material to exist. But now scientists have found that folding graphene nanoribbons into structures they call “grafold” ...

In nanotube growth, errors are not an option

June 18, 2012

(Phys.org) -- At the right temperature, with the right catalyst, there’s no reason a perfect single-walled carbon nanotube 50,000 times thinner than a human hair can’t be grown a meter long.

Shining light on the elusive carbon nanotube

October 20, 2011

Michael Blades shakes a small bottle of liquid and watches as tiny black specks swirl around. Each speck represents a cluster of millions of carbon nanotubes (CNTs).

Hydrogen opens the road to graphene ... and graphane

May 9, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- An international research team has discovered a new method to produce belts of graphene called nanoribbons. By using hydrogen, they have managed to unzip single-walled carbon nanotubes. The method also opens ...

Recommended for you

Nanotube fiber antennas as capable as copper

October 23, 2017

Fibers made of carbon nanotubes configured as wireless antennas can be as good as copper antennas but 20 times lighter, according to Rice University researchers. The antennas may offer practical advantages for aerospace applications ...

Resistive memory components the computer industry can't resist

October 23, 2017

Make way for some new memsistors. For years, the computer industry has sought memory technologies with higher endurance, lower cost, and better energy efficiency than commercial flash memories. Now, an international collaboration ...

Taming 'wild' electrons in graphene

October 23, 2017

Graphene - a one-atom-thick layer of the stuff in pencils - is a better conductor than copper and is very promising for electronic devices, but with one catch: Electrons that move through it can't be stopped.

Breakthrough in ultra-fast data processing at nanoscale

October 20, 2017

A research team from the National University of Singapore has recently invented a novel "converter" that can harness the speed and small size of plasmons for high frequency data processing and transmission in nanoelectronics.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 21, 2012
I wonder how wide a carbon nanoribbon must be between the two buckyball-like sides to maintain the maximum of performance and the minimum distance to still work as electronic components?

Getting carbon nanoribbon computer parts may be the way to go, long term.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.