Harnessing sunlight on the cheap

May 07, 2008
Harnessing sunlight on the cheap
MIT students work on a new kind of solar generator that employs low-cost materials. Here they mount the frame of the concentrator (which will be mounted with mirrors) on the base near Tang Hall on Memorial Drive. Photo / Donna Coveney

For a project that could be on the very cutting edge of renewable energy, this one is actually decidedly low tech--and that's the point.

A team of students, led by mechanical engineering graduate student Spencer Ahrens, has spent the last few months assembling a prototype for a concentrating solar power system they think could revolutionize the field. It's a 12-foot-square mirrored dish capable of concentrating sunlight by a factor of 1,000, built from simple, inexpensive industrial materials selected for price, durability and ease of assembly rather than for optimum performance.

Rather than aiming for a smooth parabolic surface that would bring the sunlight to a perfect focus, the dish is being made with 10-inch-wide by 12-foot-long strips of relatively low-cost, lightweight bathroom-type mirror glass. The frame is assembled from cheap aluminum tubing, with holes drilled in precise locations using a simple jig for alignment, so that the struts can be assembled into a framework that passively snaps into just the right parabolic curvature.

The control mechanism, which allows the dish to track the sun automatically across the sky, is also remarkably simple--photocells mounted on each side of the dish with opaque baffles, which cast a shadow on the cell when it drifts out of alignment, connect to a simple circuit that turns on small electric motors to push the dish back into the right position.

"The technical challenge here is to make it simple," Ahrens explains. The team is keeping careful track of all the costs for parts and the time spent on assembly, to provide a baseline for figuring out what an eventual large-scale field of such dishes would cost. "We're using all commodity materials that are all in high production," he says.

That's in stark contrast to most attempts to build solar dish concentrating systems, which have tended to use expensive custom-made equipment to achieve high efficiency. A few large companies that have built such prototypes tend to "turn it into an ultimate high-tech, high-end project," says Jefferson Tester, HP Meissner Professor of Chemical Engineering, who has been advising the student-led group. "Then Spencer came along and said, 'We're going to fundamentally change this and make this an affordable technology for popular, widespread deployment.'"

Ahrens thinks that in mass production the dishes can be competitive in cost with other energy sources and could produce heat for space heating and electric power at the same time.

The prototype isn't quite finished yet, because of delays in getting the mirror glass shipped from the factory. And the details of assembly and operation could well present some unexpected stumbling blocks, as is so often the case with new designs, Tester says. Still, "they're smart kids, they know what they're doing," he says. "That's how you learn."

This is not the kind of thing you'd build for a single-home, backyard power system, however. Because the highly concentrated sunlight will be so powerful, the team is employing several precautions to safeguard against potential safety risks, and the prototype will not operate in public without supervision.

Instead, the systems are designed to be deployed in large, utility-scale fields, fenced in to protect anyone from being in the wrong place. But because the beam comes to a focus about 12 feet from the surface, the danger is strictly localized--no risks for adjacent buildings or for planes flying overhead, Ahrens explains. When not attended, the dish will be covered "parked" pointing straight up, and will be mounted 7 feet above ground.

The students working on the project, because of their close proximity, will have to take precautions, wearing all-white clothing, to reflect the light, and welder-type goggles to protect their eyes.

Ahrens believes that such a design could quickly produce both hot water for space heating and electricity for the grid at prices that would be competitive today, unlike conventional photovoltaic systems that are still far too pricey for baseload generation. "In the sunbelt, our dish would make about 10,000 peak watts of heat and 3,500 peak watts of electricity," he says. Deployed in large numbers, the systems could make a big difference: "One square meter of concentrator is worth about one barrel of oil per year," he says.

"It's designed for long life--we hope they will last more than 30 years with good maintenance--and for indigenous manufacturing in the developing world with minimal tooling," Ahrens says. "We want to get something up that will be kind of viral and be widely adopted around the world."

Source: MIT

Explore further: Switch on sunlight for a brighter future

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

A solar booster shot for natural gas power plants

Apr 12, 2013

Natural gas power plants can use about 20 percent less fuel when the sun is shining by injecting solar energy into natural gas with a new system being developed by the Department of Energy's Pacific Northwest ...

ONR, marines eye solar energy

Nov 29, 2012

The Office of Naval Research (ONR) is looking to the sun for energy in an effort to help Marines do away with diesel-guzzling generators now used in combat outposts, officials announced Nov. 29.

Making mirrors for the sun

Jul 06, 2012

With $1.5 million from the Department of Energy, University of Arizona researchers are continuing to improve groundbreaking technology to produce solar electricity at a price competitive with non-renewable ...

Recommended for you

Switch on sunlight for a brighter future

2 hours ago

Imagine sitting in a windowless room yet having the feeling of the sun shining on your face. This unique experience is now possible thanks to the COELUX EU-funded project which recreates the physical and ...

US urged to drop India WTO case on solar

18 hours ago

Environmentalists Wednesday urged the United States to drop plans to haul India to the WTO to open its solar market, saying the action would hurt the fight against climate change.

Is nuclear power the only way to avoid geoengineering?

Apr 23, 2014

"I think one can argue that if we were to follow a strong nuclear energy pathway—as well as doing everything else that we can—then we can solve the climate problem without doing geoengineering." So says Tom Wigley, one ...

Finalists named in Bloomberg European city contest

Apr 23, 2014

Amsterdam wants to create an online game to get unemployed young people engaged in finding jobs across Europe. Schaerbeek, Belgium, envisions using geothermal mapping to give households personalized rundowns of steps to save ...

Bloomberg invests $5M in solar-powered lamp

Apr 22, 2014

Former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg's foundation has announced a $5 million investment in an artsy-looking solar-powered lamp designed for use in off-grid populations in Africa.

User comments : 15

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1bigschwantz
5 / 5 (4) May 07, 2008
Interesting technology.
i wish them luck.
if the article is right, a few hundred of these things could supplly alot of juice to developing countries
Rick69
not rated yet May 07, 2008
From my rough calculations, the wattage size they are quoting would produce roughly enough heat and electricity for one house.
weewilly
3.3 / 5 (3) May 07, 2008
These semi-focused mirror arrays even on a small do it yourself scale can atomise an aluminum can in about 20 seconds. The biggest problem that they have with them is that they are like sails and have to be anchored securely and of course they do not work at night. Can't wait to see MIT's configuration and hopefully some specifications.
E_L_Earnhardt
3 / 5 (2) May 07, 2008
Go to it, Kids! Cheep is the way to go!
RYM
4.7 / 5 (3) May 08, 2008
Better and cheaper than building Nuclear
Power stations for Indonesia, Thailand,and
Indonesia. poor developing but sun rich
nations.

Hope it works & can be rolled out sooner

than later.

neptuneK
5 / 5 (1) May 08, 2008
I think there was a competition on the very same theme at IIT-Bombay's Techfest , which took place this January.
plaasjaapie
3 / 5 (4) May 08, 2008
This sort of nonsense has been done by students for the last 40 years. All this article demonstrates is that MIT and, indeed, the Ivy League in general has a brilliant publicity machine.
googleplex
5 / 5 (1) May 08, 2008
What are they using as the solar energy convertor? The article only talks about the solar concentrator which is the easy part.
mrlewish
5 / 5 (2) May 08, 2008
Seems to me they are still making it to complicated. You just need some mylar or some silvered airproof material, two rings stacked with small supports so they are separated. Wrap the stucture with the mylar kind of snuggly, suck some air out to create a parabola and viola a solar concentrator.. just add your gizmos/cells/stirling engine to the outside and put it on a pole to track the sun with a simple motor. Your done.
Mercury_01
not rated yet May 08, 2008
I wonder if they use that hydrogen ion solar collector thing. have you seen it? it works quite well and is simple to make. I saw it on youtube, but unfortunately i dont have the link right now.
googleplex
5 / 5 (1) May 09, 2008
Seems to me they are still making it to complicated. You just need some mylar or some silvered airproof material, two rings stacked with small supports so they are separated. Wrap the stucture with the mylar kind of snuggly, suck some air out to create a parabola and viola a solar concentrator.. just add your gizmos/cells/stirling engine to the outside and put it on a pole to track the sun with a simple motor. Your done.

How would your idea cope with wind. One big issue is that the dish acts like a sail?
What about holes like a sieve to aleviate the air pressure from wind. The other issue is what is the shelf life of mylar in the sun?
Sepp
not rated yet May 10, 2008
All this article demonstrates is that MIT and, indeed, the Ivy League in general has a brilliant publicity machine.


Indeed.

For making hot water, there are simpler methods.

For making electricity, you need a turbine and generator. The article is strangely silent aobout that.

HOW do they propose to make electricity with their mirrors?

fireofenergy
not rated yet May 11, 2008
This should've been mass produced decades ago, covering the deserts. No cover needed since it uses a focal point. On such a large scale, the albedo effect has to be considered (imagine seeing "black deserts" from space covered with PV). These simply reflect the sky, and if too many were to be built (crazy robots), then we would counter the effect of melting glaciers by reflecting the sun back into space!
Easily available mass produced parts create a rugged tile like structure as the mirrors need to be tilted which allow wind to pass through.
Steam engines are not the most efficient, but giant versions (the solar tower) can generate juice on through the night!
Only post holes have to be "environmentally intrusive" and all of these things will dissapear in a few years if we do not employ solar on a vast scale soon!

Renewable energy is the cure for
Death by oil depletion
lowbatteries
not rated yet May 14, 2008


Indeed.

For making hot water, there are simpler methods.

For making electricity, you need a turbine and generator. The article is strangely silent aobout that.

HOW do they propose to make electricity with their mirrors?



Too bad there isn't some sort of device that converts sunlight directly to electricity, then solar concentrators would be useful! Oh wait, the photocell! It's expensive to produce, but if you concentrate a lot of light on a small area, it becomes economically feasible. You think they just decided to concentrate sunlight for no reason? Too bad the article didn't explain the entire idea of solar power for you.
Cyril
not rated yet Jul 09, 2008
Cheap is good. I like the inflatable solar design by CoolEarthSolar, and the Ausra approach too. KISS - Keep It Simple, Stupid

More news stories

Review: 'Hearthstone' card game is the real deal

Video game publishers don't take many risks with their most popular franchises. You know exactly what you are going to get from a new "Call of Duty" or "Madden NFL" game—it will probably be pretty good, ...