This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:


peer-reviewed publication

trusted source


Research finds water quality in Gulf of Mexico improves when adding social costs to carbon emissions

Research finds water quality in Gulf of Mexico improves when adding social costs to carbon emissions
Evaluation using four coupled models to relate carbon pricing to nitrate export to the Gulf of Mexico. (A: Left) Integrated modeling framework. The ENVISAGE global economic model determines the change in agricultural input prices due to climate policy. These price changes feed into the SIMPLE-G-US-CS gridded economic model of corn–soy production which has been calibrated to capture the yield responses to changes in nitrogen fertilizer applications estimated using the Agro-IBIS agroecosystem model. When confronted with these input price changes, farmers alter their fertilizer usage, thereby changing nitrogen leachate. Nitrogen leachate is routed through the Mississippi River Basin hydrologic system into the Gulf of Mexico using the WBM hydrological model. Imposed policies are depicted in white or black boxes, and uncertainties in key model parameters characterized by sensitivity analyses are listed in gray boxes (Table 1). (B: Right) Spatial distribution of the relative changes of key factors including crop output (top maps), nitrogen fertilizer applied (Middle), and fraction of nitrate flux ultimately entering the Gulf (Bottom). Callouts identify points in the modeling framework where each factor is calculated. Inset values for each map provide the basin-wide average value for each depicted variable (blue), and the total change for basin export in black. (C: Top) Nonlinear response between fertilizer application rate with crop yield and nitrate leachate below the root zone represented, respectively, by Gompertz and quadratic functions. Callout identifies the grid cell location of this example response. Credit: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2023). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2302087120

U.S. Climate policies can offer options for putting climate change efforts into place that solve environmental problems like excessive carbon dioxide in the atmosphere created by greenhouse gas emissions. Research led by the University of New Hampshire took a closer look at what would happen to agriculture if there was an extra cost, or so-called social cost, added to fossil fuels, which are essential for making fertilizer used in farming.

They found that while CO2 emissions would decline by as much as 50%, the cost of fertilizer would rise leading to a significant benefit on water quality by lessening fertilizer runoff contributing to the Gulf of Mexico's dead zone—a low-oxygen area that struggles with harmful algal blooms that threatens marine life.

"Excessive fertilizer use creates a growing number of water quality concerns so we wanted to explore the consequences of applying a social cost to fossil fuel prices which should reduce fertilizer use and decrease the amount of runoff going into the Mississippi River Basin and on to the Gulf of Mexico, an important fishery in the U.S.," said Shan Zuidema, research scientist at UNH's Earth System Research Center and lead author.

"Our models showed that with this , U.S. carbon emissions could significantly decline but we could also see about a 3% to 4% reduction of the Gulf of Mexico dead zone in an average year."

In the study, published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), researchers from UNH, Purdue University and the University of Wisconsin-Madison used four different models that looked at various factors making up the world economy.

They focused on data from the global economy, U.S. agricultural economies, agroecology and hydrology/water quality to capture the impacts of the climate change mitigation policy on agriculture and the resulting water quality co-benefits. They analyzed a policy that would assign a range of social costs to fossil fuel-based CO2 emissions. The policy would raise energy costs and increase the price of nitrogen fertilizer production.

The researchers then considered three different levels of social costs applied to the fossil fuel and found at the highest carbon price the cost of nitrogen fertilizer could rise by roughly 90%. This could lead to upwards of a 16% decline in fertilizer application for corn production across the Mississippi River Basin and a roughly 9% decline in fertilizer loss to the environment.

Corn and soybean production would decline by about 7%, increasing crop prices by 6%, while nitrate leaching would decline by about 10%. Nitrates entering the environment are removed in various ways as they move through the watershed, so the decline in nitrogen leaving the watershed at the mouth of the Mississippi River was somewhat less (roughly a 9% reduction).

"Implementing a carbon price that reflects its social cost allows the U.S. to meet its commitment to the Paris Accord while significantly improving ," said Tom Hertel, professor of agricultural economics at Purdue University and project principal investigator. "Our models showed that with this range of climate policies, U.S. carbon emissions could decline by 29% to 50%, depending on the stringency of the carbon pricing. This represents 4.6% to 8% of global carbon emissions and satisfies the range of reductions outlined in the Paris Accord."

Researchers also considered the additional benefits of restored wetlands to mitigate nitrogen loading to reduce hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico and found a targeted wetland restoration scenario approximately doubles the effect of a low to moderate of carbon.

The team hopes these findings provide important context for policy makers to consider all aspects of climate mitigation, as well as for those that want to consider alternatives for reducing contamination to the Gulf of Mexico.

More information: Shan Zuidema et al, US climate policy yields water quality cobenefits in the Mississippi Basin and Gulf of Mexico, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2023). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2302087120

Citation: Research finds water quality in Gulf of Mexico improves when adding social costs to carbon emissions (2023, October 17) retrieved 3 March 2024 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

More sustainable agriculture by global redistribution of nitrogen fertilizer


Feedback to editors