Victory or catastrophe? Amazon's pull-out leaves New York divided

February 15, 2019 by Thomas Urbain
Graffiti in Long Island City against Amazon, which had said it would build a headquarters there

Thousands of lost jobs or a victory against a monolith: reactions were sharply divided Thursday after Amazon abandoned its plans for a new headquarters in New York.

In Long Island City on the edge of the East River, some residents of the towers that have sprung up in recent years voiced relief, having expected some 25,000 people to descend on the district.

"I was nervous about Amazon bringing in just a lot more crowd," said Danielle Quagliata.

"I feel that the area is pretty built up as it is," she said. "I, for one, feel relieved."

Others feared skyrocketing rents—and doubted claims that Amazon would have inundated the area with jobs.

Carlos Dall'Orso, who runs the bicycle shop Spokesman Cycles, would have undoubtedly benefited from the influx of thousands of executives with —but he too is breathing easier now that the online giant pulled out.

"As someone who works in retail, I don't have fun things to say about Amazon," Dall'Orso said. "Amazon is killing retail. When all the retail is gone, then they're going to control the price and they won't be cheap anymore."

And of the theory that Amazon employees could have boosted his business, the entrepreneur is nihilistic.

"It's prolonging the death," he said. "Do I take chemotherapy now or do I shoot myself in the head?"

Lost opportunity

But some heard the Amazon news with dismay, having looked forward to the global operation's move into town.

In Long Island City on the edge of the East River, some residents of the towers that have sprung up in recent years voiced relief, having expected some 25,000 people to descend on the district
"Think about all the infrastructure and tech jobs and construction jobs and all the support that needs to go in for a campus like that," said David Katzen, who owns a construction company in the area.

"All those are gone."

He blames local politicians—many of whom fought the project, saying the state governor and city's mayor pushed it without their input—whom he accuses of "wanting to make noise."

"I think it was just a bully pulpit for which local legislators wanted to get up and beat their drums and be heard," Katzen said.

"And now it backfired on them because they never thought that Amazon would pull out."

Some 56 percent of New Yorkers were in favor of the project, according to a poll from Siena University, while 36 percent were opposed.

Katzen dismissed claims that the already stretched would have collapsed under the demands of thousands of new riders.

"They would have adapted it," he said. "They would have done something else to compensate."

Some critics had pointed to the risk of gentrification that Amazon would have caused, a prospect John Paul Palace, who moved there a year ago, rejected.

"It's already gentrified! That's why I moved here," he said.

Katzen, whose business has been in "LIC" since 1928, echoed that sentiment: "The people that used to live here were older immigrants; Italian, Irish people."

"Those people are already gone."

Explore further: Amazon drops New York headquarters plan amid protests

Related Stories

Amazon drops New York headquarters plan amid protests

February 14, 2019

Amazon abandoned plans for a new headquarters in New York City on Thursday, blaming opposition from community leaders angry at the huge subsidies being offered to one of the world's most successful companies.

Amazon reconsidering move to New York: report

February 8, 2019

Amazon is rethinking its decision to create an additional headquarters in New York City amid opposition from key political leaders and protests in the community, The Washington Post reported Friday.

NYC mayor defends Amazon deal at state budget hearing

February 11, 2019

It was "mission critical" for New York City to land one of Amazon's second headquarters and the tens of thousands of jobs the company promises to create, Mayor Bill de Blasio said Monday, just days after a report said the ...

Recommended for you

Galactic center visualization delivers star power

March 21, 2019

Want to take a trip to the center of the Milky Way? Check out a new immersive, ultra-high-definition visualization. This 360-movie offers an unparalleled opportunity to look around the center of the galaxy, from the vantage ...

Ultra-sharp images make old stars look absolutely marvelous

March 21, 2019

Using high-resolution adaptive optics imaging from the Gemini Observatory, astronomers have uncovered one of the oldest star clusters in the Milky Way Galaxy. The remarkably sharp image looks back into the early history of ...

When more women make decisions, the environment wins

March 21, 2019

When more women are involved in group decisions about land management, the group conserves more—particularly when offered financial incentives to do so, according to a new University of Colorado Boulder study published ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.