The science of studying the effects of extraordinary beliefs on consumer behavior

October 31, 2018, University of Chicago

The study of superstition and other extraordinary beliefs in the marketplace brings challenges and opportunities for the enhancement of consumer well-being. In "Superstition, Ethics, and Transformative Consumer Research," published in the October issue of the Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, Stuart Vyse examines the ethical issues involved in research on consumer superstitions and how the principles of Transformative Consumer Research can be applied to this area of investigation to promote consumer welfare and sustainability.

Transformative consumer research (TCR) refers to an initiative proposed by marketing scholar David Mick, wherein investigations are framed by a fundamental problem or opportunity and strive to respect and improve life for . For instance, studies adopting the TCR approach might focus on vulnerable consumer groups, gambling, product safety, or financial and medical decision making.

Vyse explores some of the implications of applying utilitarian, deontological, and virtue ethical standards to superstition in the marketplace. He notes that when it comes to homeopathic medicine, for instance, the FDA has adopted a utilitarian risk-based philosophy "that takes no moral stand on the acceptability of medical treatments based on unsubstantiated theories of disease," contrasting to a moral approach that would prioritize truth and evidence in the marketing of goods and services—"but as of this moment, such rules are generally lacking," he writes.

Invalid claims from marketers offering superstitious products (from rabbit's feet to spell kits to psychic readings) are not disallowed by any regulatory agency, and the exploitation of customers' superstitious beliefs for financial gain does not run afoul of deceptive advertising standards. The TCR virtue ethical approach, Vyse says, assumes that if a society based on reason is more sustainable than one based on superstition and unscientific thinking, questions arise as to whether there is an obligation for researchers and policy makers to discourage the role of in the marketplace.

Vyse suggests that researchers should more specifically identify irrational behavior. "Avoiding a hotel room because it is on the 13th floor or being attracted to an airline because their company number is made up entirely of lucky numbers is not rational," he says. Instead of assuming that everyone recognizes rational vs. , research in this area may more constructively affect consumer well-being if the rationality of the behavior in question is assessed and clearly stated.

Explore further: Are you feeling lucky? How superstition impacts consumer choice

More information: Stuart Vyse, Superstition, Ethics, and Transformative Consumer Research, Journal of the Association for Consumer Research (2018). DOI: 10.1086/698869

Related Stories

'Lucky' numbers make for unlucky customers

March 19, 2012

( -- Chinese consumers pay too much for goods and services because of superstitions surrounding particular numbers, Binghamton University economist Zili Yang says.

EU commissioner questions legality of new Ryanair terms

October 4, 2018

Consumer officials should examine budget airline Ryanair's new terms and conditions, as any move to force dissatisfied customers to seek redress in Ireland would be illegal, a top European official said Thursday.

Recommended for you

Researchers engineer a tougher fiber

February 22, 2019

North Carolina State University researchers have developed a fiber that combines the elasticity of rubber with the strength of a metal, resulting in a tougher material that could be incorporated into soft robotics, packaging ...

A quantum magnet with a topological twist

February 22, 2019

Taking their name from an intricate Japanese basket pattern, kagome magnets are thought to have electronic properties that could be valuable for future quantum devices and applications. Theories predict that some electrons ...

Solving the jet/cocoon riddle of a gravitational wave event

February 22, 2019

An international research team including astronomers from the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn, Germany, has combined radio telescopes from five continents to prove the existence of a narrow stream of material, ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.