Foodborne illness caused by common agricultural practice, casts doubts on biocidal product labeling

April 17, 2018, American Society for Microbiology
Colonies of pathogenic bacteria growing on an agar culture plate - Salmonella enterica (serovar typhimurium) Credit: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Chlorine, commonly used in the agriculture industry to decontaminate fresh produce, can make foodborne pathogens undetectable, according to new research published in mBio, an open-access journal of the American Society for Microbiology. The study may help explain outbreaks of Salmonella enterica and Listeria monocytogenes among produce in recent years.

"This important work is a major breakthrough, after 100 years of relying on chlorine to sanitize foods and drinking water, and may explain the many unrecognized or untraceable disease outbreaks relying on the gold standard of culture recovery," said lead study author Bill Keevil, PhD, chair in environmental healthcare within Biological Sciences and head of the Microbiology Group at the University of Southampton, United Kingdom.

In response to stress such as extreme temperatures, nutrient starvation, or desiccation (extreme dryness), some Gram-positive bacteria can form tough spores and survive for thousands of years in the environment. Bacillus anthracis, which causes Anthrax, is one example. Many bacteria, however, cannot form spores and instead survive a stress by entering a "dormant" or viable but nonculturable (VBNC) state in response to environmental stresses. "VBNC cells cannot be detected by standard laboratory culture techniques, presenting a problem for the food and water supply industries, which uses these techniques to detect pathogen contaminants," said Dr. Keevil.

In their study, Dr. Keevil and colleagues incubated Listeria monocytogenes and Salmonella enterica populations on spinach leaves and then subjected the spinach to chlorine washes. The viable Listeria and Salmonella populations became VBNC by 50 and 100 ppm chlorine, respectively. Further experiments revealed that Caenorhabiditis elegans that ingested VBNC cells had shortened lifespans.

"Chlorine induces the VBNC state in Listeria monocytogenes and Salmonella enterica and chlorine was ineffective at killing total populations of these pathogens," said Dr. Keevil. "These data show that viable but nonculturable foodborne pathogens can both be generated and avoid detection by industrial practices, while potentially retaining their ability to cause disease." Even modern molecular detection (PCR and qPCR) are flawed, if labs rely on a pre-enrichment step that involves chlorine, to increase cell numbers and sensitivity of the assay.

The findings have implications for food safety as well as biocidal products. "This has big implications for many household and industrial cleaning agents, paints, cosmetics etc. sold with an antimicrobial claim," said Dr. Keevil. "The efficacy of many validated products with a biocidal claim may need to be re-examined when they rely solely on culture recovery techniques [that involve chlorine]."

Dr. Keevil said the study will also impact on post-BREXIT trade agreements, with countries insisting the UK import their chlorine-treated foodstuffs. This new work shows this may not actually be safe. One of the collaborators on the study, Steve Rothwell, PhD, works for Vitacress Salads ltd, which has now become the first UK company to obtain supermarket approval to sell fresh produce washed in spring water without chlorine. "The problem with of course is that many people eat it fresh, so it misses the cooking step which would kill most pathogens, one reason why companies have relied on washing before sale," said Dr. Keevil.

Explore further: Double disinfection treatment for safer drinking water

Related Stories

Double disinfection treatment for safer drinking water

March 7, 2018

In spite of good progress in water hygiene during the recent decades, contaminated water still causes millions of diseases every year. Most of these diseases are caused by enteric viruses, and better water disinfection methods ...

How to deliver drinking water chlorine-free

February 26, 2016

Chlorinated tap water is the norm around the world, but the experiences of several European countries is that it doesn't have to be. The benefits of foregoing chlorine include better-tasting and, potentially, healthier water.

Lettuce: buy bagged or not?

September 7, 2012

(HealthDay)—Six separate recalls of bagged lettuce since April haven't done much to bolster the public's confidence in pre-cut and pre-washed greens.

Recommended for you

Matter waves and quantum splinters

March 25, 2019

Physicists in the United States, Austria and Brazil have shown that shaking ultracold Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) can cause them to either divide into uniform segments or shatter into unpredictable splinters, depending ...

How tree diversity regulates invading forest pests

March 25, 2019

A national-scale study of U.S. forests found strong relationships between the diversity of native tree species and the number of nonnative pests that pose economic and ecological threats to the nation's forests.

Study suggests trees are crucial to the future of our cities

March 25, 2019

The shade of a single tree can provide welcome relief from the hot summer sun. But when that single tree is part of a small forest, it creates a profound cooling effect. According to a study published today in the Proceedings ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

2.5 / 5 (2) Apr 17, 2018
So we need to forgo Chlorine the savior of millions because some bacteria create hard tough spores when they are used. Grate research but no answers Hmmmm... So we test them before the Chlorine? Obviously.
Da Schneib
1 / 5 (1) Apr 17, 2018
I don't think any answers are forthcoming yet; it's not just a matter of what biocides we use but what culturing and assay methods we use.

This also affects all sorts of assumptions about growers using bad practices resulting in outbreaks. In these cases they might be using approved and well tested techniques and still there are some disease-causing organisms getting past those techniques. Fining the growers because the techniques didn't work might be pointless, and abusive.
Da Schneib
2.3 / 5 (3) Apr 21, 2018
The recent E. Coli outbreak has apparently been traced to all romaine lettuce, both processed and whole, from Arizona. I expect there are some pretty unhappy growers down there. Maybe they'll raise enough of a fuss that someone will do something about the testing procedures. But considering it's Arizona, I bet we'll find out they cut taxes by not doing enough testing; they got a lot of Libertardians down there. As I already said elsewhere ya gets what ya pays for. Bet it doesn't change their minds about being Libertardians, too, no matter how many of them go out of business.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.