How to deliver drinking water chlorine-free

February 26, 2016, Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne
Drinking water: how to deliver it chlorine-free?

Chlorinated tap water is the norm around the world, but the experiences of several European countries is that it doesn't have to be. The benefits of foregoing chlorine include better-tasting and, potentially, healthier water.

If you have spent time in southern Europe or overseas, you are probably familiar with the taste of chlorinated tap water. Distributing tap water with residual chlorine is a century-old strategy used to protect populations by preventing the proliferation of waterborne pathogens. But is it necessary? In a commentary published in the journal Science, researcher Urs von Gunten from EPFL and his colleagues at Eawag provide evidence from Europe showing that chlorine could be forgone if other protective barriers are in place.

Three factors determine the quality of tap water: the quality of its source, of its treatment, and of its distribution network. Decades of experience in the Netherlands, Germany, Austria, and Switzerland have shown that, when none of these three elements are compromised, the number of waterborne-disease outbreaks are low, even lower than in countries that add to their water supply in order to compensate for poorly maintained networks, insufficient water treatment, or contaminated water sources.

But the researchers point out that distributing the water without added chlorine comes at a cost. It requires protecting groundwater sources, properly controlled water treatment, and regular maintenance of the water . But where chlorine can be foregone, the benefits go beyond improving the taste of . When disinfectants, like , react with natural organic matter that is always present in drinking , this can lead to the formation of disinfection by-products, some of which are potential carcinogens.

Explore further: Cooking with chloraminated water and salt could create toxic molecules

More information: F. Rosario-Ortiz et al. How do you like your tap water?, Science (2016). DOI: 10.1126/science.aaf0953

Related Stories

Canadian city detects E. coli in water supply

January 28, 2015

Inhabitants of Winnipeg, Canada's sixth largest city, have been warned not to use tap water without first boiling it, after E. coli bacteria was detected in the water supply, officials said Wednesday.

The chemistry behind Flint's water crisis

February 17, 2016

When the city of Flint switched drinking water sources in 2014, it triggered a health emergency as startlingly high levels of lead turned up in the water. An article in Chemical & Engineering News (C&EN), the weekly newsmagazine ...

Canada's Winnipeg still under boil-water advisory

January 29, 2015

Residents of Canada's sixth-largest city were advised to keep boiling tap water before using it late Wednesday, even though latest tests showed no traces of harmful bacteria, officials said.

Recommended for you

Antarctic ice shelf 'sings' as winds whip across its surface

October 16, 2018

Winds blowing across snow dunes on Antarctica's Ross Ice Shelf cause the massive ice slab's surface to vibrate, producing a near-constant set of seismic "tones" scientists could potentially use to monitor changes in the ice ...

New understanding of Mekong River incision

October 16, 2018

An international team of earth scientists has linked the establishment of the Mekong River to a period of major intensification of the Asian monsoon during the middle Miocene, about 17 million years ago, findings that supplant ...

World Heritage sites threatened by sea level rise

October 16, 2018

From Venice and the tower of Pisa to the medieval city of Rhodes, dozens of UNESCO World Heritage sites in the Mediterranean basin are deeply threatened by rising sea levels, researchers warned Tuesday.

Was life on the early Earth purple?

October 16, 2018

Early life forms on Earth may have been able to generate metabolic energy from sunlight using a purple-pigmented molecule called retinal that possibly predates the evolution of chlorophyll and photosynthesis. If retinal has ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

vlaaing peerd
4 / 5 (2) Feb 26, 2016
Lucky to live in NL, not many people realise what a luxury it is to have tapwater that is both tastier and mineral-richer than actual spa/evian mineral water.

We use both ground- and surface water, the latter requiring a more extensive filtering process. Ground water can be cleaned by a process called cascaded oxygen filtering which is the best quality water.

Surface water is indeed more troublesome, especially because our rivers (Rhine/Maasdelta), flow through an enormous industrial area on the German border, where industrial giants like BASF have little concerns about illegally dumping chemical waste into the rivers.

So only clean flows get stored in reservoirs and preprocessed with ozone and UV light treatment (which replaces the need for fluoride after it was forbidden in 1973) and sinks into the ground over a period of 3~4 months, after this it gets the same treatment as groundwater and though it's just as clean, the calcium level is higher making it less tasty.
5 / 5 (1) Feb 26, 2016
This is lovely, if the infrastructure is clean enough to support it and the filtration is tight enough to keep it from getting dirty. But in many cases, it isn't. Problems with cryptosporidium are commonplace.

The other problem with ozonation is that it doesn't stay in solution nearly as long as chlorine does. In many cities, the water can remain in the distribution system for several days before it reaches the tap. Chlorine at reasonable levels can help to keep that water sanitary.

Another point: We know that high doses of trihalomethanes (THM), a byproduct of chlorination, are probably not good for anyone, but we don't know the lower limits of what THM exposure should be. Saying that we shouldn't have any THM is unrealistic in today's distribution systems with ages measured in many decades, if not centuries.

If you want to rip up and replace the pipeline infrastructure, I'd be happy to entertain the idea. But it probably isn't necessary.
not rated yet Feb 27, 2016
More crank ideas. Much like anti-vaccination types. Ban chlorine, die of cholera and other water-borne diseases. Ban fluoride, go back to the days when people lost all their teeth by 30.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.