New study suggests shark declines can lead to changes in reef fish body shapes

January 16, 2018, University of Miami
For these reef fish, eye size is critical for detecting sharks, especially under low-light conditions, and tail size is important for escaping sharks with burst speed. Credit: Hiram Henriquez

Scientists studying nearly identical coral reef systems off Australia discovered something unusual on the reefs subjected to nearly exclusive fishing of sharks—fish with significantly smaller eyes and tails. The study is the first field evidence of body shape changes in fish due to human-driven shark declines from overfishing. These findings shed new light on the cascading effects the loss of the ocean's top predators is having on marine ecosystems.

The University of Miami (UM) Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science-led collaborative research team analyzed seven different fish species from two neighboring coral reef systems off the coast of northwestern Australia to uncover this unusual effect. The coral reef systems, known as the Rowley Shoals and the Scott Reefs, are each comprised of multiple atoll-like reefs, are nearly identical biologically and physically in all but one way— the coral reefs in Rowley Shoals are protected from fishing, while the coral reefs in the Scott Reefs have been subjected to nearly exclusive commercial shark fishing for centuries. Targeted shark fishing has intensified in the region in recent decades to fuel the demand of . As a result, have been decimated at the Scott Reefs, but remain healthy at the Rowley Shoals.

The research team collected 611 fish of seven species across multiple sites from different coral reefs within the Rowley Shoals and the Scott Reefs. They then took photographs of each fish and digitally analyzed photographs, measuring body length, body width, eye area and tail area of each fish.

The researchers found that at Scott Reefs, where shark populations have declined, the eyes of fishes that are normally prey for sharks were on average up to 46 percent smaller compared to the same sized fish of the same species on reefs at the Rowley Shoals where shark populations are healthy. The same pattern was true for fish tail sizes, with the overall size of fish tails being on average up to 40 percent smaller at the Scott Reefs compared to the Rowley Shoals.

"Eye size is critical for detecting predators, especially under low-light conditions when many sharks usually hunt, and tail shape enables burst speed and rapid escape from sharks," said the study's lead author Neil Hammerschlag, a research assistant professor at the UM Rosenstiel School and UM Abess Center for Ecosystem Science and Policy. "Our results suggest that removals of sharks by humans have potentially caused a reduction in the size of fish body parts that are important for shark detection and evasion."

"These patterns were consistent across seven fish species that vary in behavior, diet and trophic-guild," said study coauthor Mark Meekan, a principal research scientist at the Australian Institute of Marine Science. "These results are particularly important since are among the most threatened marine animals and the consequences of their global removals due to fishing is not well understood and has been a topic of significant speculation, debate and concern."

"The differences in body shapes we measured between the two coral systems could have consequences for energy flow throughout the ecosystem, ultimately impacting the food web," said study coauthor Shanta Barley, a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Western Australia.

"There is an urgent need to understand the potential cascading ecosystem consequences of shark declines, especially on that we rely heavily on for tourism, food and recreation," said Hammerschlag.

Explore further: Declines in sharks drive 'fatter' fish

More information: N Hammerschlag et al, Predator declines and morphological changes in prey: evidence from coral reefs depleted of sharks, Marine Ecology Progress Series (2017). DOI: 10.3354/meps12426

Related Stories

Declines in sharks drive 'fatter' fish

April 20, 2017

New research from The University of Western Australia and the Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS) suggests that reef fishes eat differently when sharks are around. To avoid unwanted attention from large predators, ...

Reef sharks prefer bite-size meals

February 22, 2016

Sharks have a reputation for having voracious appetites, but a new study shows that most coral reef sharks eat prey that are smaller than a cheeseburger.

Sharks more abundant on healthy coral reefs

September 10, 2014

Sharks in no-fishing zones in the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) Marine Park are more abundant when the coral is healthy, according to a study published September 10, 2014 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Mario Espinoza from ...

Healthy sharks sustain healthy oceans

July 24, 2017

A team from The University of Western Australia has completed a four month research expedition looking for signs of healthy coral reefs in the remote Kimberley. They observed an unexpectedly high number of sharks in the region, ...

Recommended for you

Bolder targets needed to protect nature for people's sake

June 18, 2018

University of Queensland (UQ) and Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) researchers argue that the world needs more diverse, ambitious and area-specific targets for retaining important natural systems to safeguard humanity. ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

TrollBane
5 / 5 (1) Jan 16, 2018
Aside from ocean acidification, climate change, overfishing, bycatch, disrupted habitat, etc., can any of the decline in shark populations be attributed to the number of television shows that have 'jumped the shark'?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.