More frequent fires reduce soil carbon and fertility, slowing the regrowth of plants

December 12, 2017 by Sarah Derouin, Stanford University
More frequent fires reduce soil carbon and fertility, slowing the regrowth of plants
Repeated fires in savannas, which are dominated by grasses, can reduce carbon and nitrogen in soils for decades. The reduction in nutrients can lead to poor plant regrowth. Credit: Carla Staver

Frequent burning over decades reduces the amount of carbon and nitrogen stored in soils of savanna grasslands and broadleaf forests, in part because reduced plant growth means less carbon being drawn out of the atmosphere and stored in plant matter. These findings by a Stanford-led team are important for worldwide understanding of fire impacts on the carbon cycle and for modeling the future of global carbon and climate change.

The results, published Dec. 11 in the journal Nature, offer a new perspective on the impact of fire on .

"Almost all the synthesis studies done to date conclude that fire has relatively little effect on soils, but in large part, researchers focused on a single fire event," said Adam Pellegrini, a post-doctoral scholar at Stanford's School of Earth, Energy & Environmental Sciences and lead author on the study.

Instead, this study examined and fertility in different ecosystems over 65 years.

"We are interested in the ways ecosystems change over many decades," said Rob Jackson, professor of Earth System Science and senior author on the study. "As the Earth's climate warms, we need to understand how changing fire frequencies alter soils and plant growth."

Together with an interdisciplinary team of researchers from eight institutions across the world, Pellegrini and Jackson found that estimates of fire impacts on the ecosystem's ability to store carbon may be substantially off. The new findings could help land managers better weigh how often they use prescribed burns to manage grasslands and forests.

More frequent fires reduce soil carbon and fertility, slowing the regrowth of plants
The locations of the fire-soil data used in the study, shown in black dots, on top a map showing the frequency of fires around the world. Credit: Adam Pellegrini

Fire and ecosystems

Focusing on three different types of landscapes – savanna grasslands, broadleaf forests, and needleleaf forests – from 48 sites covering multiple continents, the researchers compiled records of soil fertility after fires over up to 65 years. Comparing the changes in soil nutrients over time, they found that in frequently burned areas in savannas and broadleaf forests, there was a 36 percent reduction in soil carbon and a 38 percent reduction in nitrogen compared to areas that were protected from fire. Conifer forests did not show this reduction in carbon and nitrogen after fires.

"You can imagine after only one year, fire wouldn't make much of a difference, but over multiple years and repeated burning, the lack of plant inputs into soils decreases carbon and nutrients," said Pellegrini. "Plant productivity is what draws carbon out of the atmosphere – that's what sequesters the carbon. What we see over time is not just a net increase in the carbon emissions to the atmosphere, but a net decrease in carbon sequestration."

After the team found that repeated fire causes the continued loss of carbon and nitrogen in savannas and broadleaf forests, they wanted to see how plant recovery might be affected. They used a vegetation model to predict global plant growth in frequently burned areas and found the loss of nitrogen in soils suppressed the regrowth of .

More frequent fires reduce soil carbon and fertility, slowing the regrowth of plants
Fire in a conifer-dominated forest may not burn through the thick layer of needles on the forest floor, essentially protecting the soil below. Credit: Adam Pellegrini

Reduced carbon storage

The slower has implications for carbon storage, and Jackson warned there's a long-term feedback that should be considered. "There are additional losses and changes in carbon that can happen decades later because plants are unable to grow back as quickly as they would have," said Jackson, who is also a senior fellow at the Woods Institute for the Environment.

Surprisingly, needleleaf forests didn't show the same loss of nutrients. Instead, the conifer-dominated forest soils actually had more and nitrogen present with frequent burning. Pellegrini explained that burning of the dense layer of partially decomposed pine needles on the forest floor might provide ash to the soils, and added that future work will further examine the effects of fire in this type of .

The researchers stressed that they are not advocating fire suppression. "Fires often increase the diversity of plants and reduce the risk that a landscape will have a high-intensity fire," said Pellegrini.

Instead, in a time where creates drier and warmer conditions that favor fire, managers and conservationists may have to shift their management strategies.

"Managers may need to take a longer view of how much and how often they choose to burn systems," said Jackson.

Explore further: Expanding tropical forest spells disaster for conservation

More information: Fire frequency drives decadal changes in soil carbon and nitrogen and ecosystem productivity, Nature (2017).

Related Stories

Fire damage to soils sets back bushfire recovery

August 25, 2015

Soils in areas hit by bushfires like the Sampson Flat fire may take several years to recover, say University of Adelaide soil scientists starting a new study into the effects of bushfires on soils.

Recommended for you

Jet stream changes since 1960s linked to more extreme weather

January 12, 2018

Increased fluctuations in the path of the North Atlantic jet stream since the 1960s coincide with more extreme weather events in Europe such as heat waves, droughts, wildfires and flooding, reports a University of Arizona-led ...

Global warming will expose millions more to floods

January 11, 2018

Global warming is expected to unleash more rain, exposing millions more people to river flooding particularly in the United States and parts of Asia, Africa and central Europe, researchers said Wednesday.

Maps that show travel times to cities all across the globe

January 11, 2018

An international team of researchers, including a representative from Google, has created a color-coded map of the planet that shows travel times to cities from other places. In their paper published in the journal Nature, ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Dec 13, 2017
Given that fires in grassland and treed communities are the main reason that these ecosystems are maintained, it stands to reason that this study reflects the steady state of these environments. What are they using as a baseline for their study? How many locations in this study are in undisturbed areas where natural fires have occurred as they did in the past? 65 years in North America? I would venture to guess that you are looking at areas that were disturbed for a long time prior to this study, which would date back to approximately the early 1950's

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.