Study refutes theory linking cognition, genes and income

November 17, 2017 by Erin Karter, Northwestern University
Study refutes theory linking cognition, genes and income
Credit: Northwestern University

Researchers have cast doubt on a widely-held belief that connects family income with cognitive development, according to a new study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

A popular theory holds that genes play a larger role in brain development for children from advantaged environments than in those from poorer backgrounds, especially in the United States.

But in the largest study to date using matched birth and school records, the researchers from Northwestern University, Stanford University and the University of Florida found won't necessarily mitigate the effects of genetics on cognitive outcomes.

"While children from higher socio-economic status backgrounds have much better cognitive outcomes on average than those from lower socio-economic status households, genetics appear to just as much for both groups," said Northwestern economist David Figlio, study lead author and dean of the School of Education and Social Policy. "Genes matter. Environment matters. But we find no evidence that the two interact."

Some studies suggest that the difference in genetic influence between rich and poor families is particularly pronounced in the U.S., but the Florida data, which includes records of siblings and twins, calls this idea into question, the researchers said.

The finding mildly surprised Figlio, but he said it falls in line with his previous work published in American Economic Review, which indicated that heavier babies do better in school. In that study of Florida children, Figlio and his coauthors found that those who were heavier at birth scored higher on math and reading tests in the third to eighth grades, and that the relationship between birth weight and is essentially the same for everybody.

"It's definitely still true that, from the point of view of test scores, you'd rather be a tiny baby from a wealthy than a big baby from a poor family," said Figlio, faculty fellow at Northwestern's Institute for Policy Research. "But matters, and it matters for everyone. It seems the same effect is at play here."

A full understanding of how genes interact with the environment for cognition is more complex and elusive than previously supposed, the researchers said.

"Being able to say that 'genes' matter more for this group versus that group is appealing partly for its simplicity," said study co-author Jeremy Freese of Stanford. "We suspect the truth is more complicated: Some genes may matter more in richer families and other may matter in poorer families. There's no overall characterization."

Freese emphasized that genetic differences do matter in . "But we are still far from understanding how in any useful way," he said. "Meanwhile, we know poor children face many social disadvantages, and there is much we can do to address those to help promote the flourishing of all children."

Explore further: Heavier newborns show academic edge in school

More information: David N. Figlio et al. Socioeconomic status and genetic influences on cognitive development, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2017). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1708491114

Related Stories

Heavier newborns show academic edge in school

December 2, 2014

Birth weight makes a difference to a child's future academic performance, according to new Northwestern University research that found heavier newborns do better in elementary and middle school than infants with lower birth ...

How do preemies perform in school?

June 12, 2017

Parents of prematurely born babies often fear their children may go on to struggle in school, but findings from a new large-scale study from the Institute for Policy Research at Northwestern University and Northwestern Medicine ...

Recommended for you

Excavators find tombs buried in Bolivia 500 years ago

November 17, 2018

Archaeologists say they found tombs at a Bolivian quarry containing remains from more than 500 years ago that give an insight into the interaction of various peoples with the expanding Inca empire.

Preventing chemical weapons as sciences converge

November 15, 2018

Alarming examples of the dangers from chemical weapons have been seen recently in the use of industrial chemicals and the nerve agent sarin against civilians in Syria, and in the targeted assassination operations using VX ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.