Geneticist warns against intervention in the human germline made possible by the CRISPR/Cas 'gene scissors'

CRISPR/Cas9 opens up many possibilities in medicine presenting opportunities and risks. It is hoped that the new method can be used for the genetic treatment of serious diseases, such as AIDS. Scientists could simply cut out a gene modified by disease in the body cells and replace it with a healthy one. Scientists in China and the UK are taking this a step further by conducting research in the laboratory using human embryonic stem cells. This has broken a taboo sparking outrage and debate worldwide. How far should research go? Stefan Mundlos, Director of the Institute for Medical Genetics and Human Genetics at the Charité and Research Group Leader at the Max Planck Institute for Molecular Genetics in Berlin, holds a very critical view of interventions in the human germline.

The genetic make-up of human embryos can be modified using CRISPR/Cas. What benefits do scientists hope this research will bring?

In my view, there is no medical indication for such . Correcting genetic diseases at the embryo's stem cell stage is a purely theoretical possibility. Establishing this procedure would certainly not only involve huge costs but would also be superfluous, as embryos can already be tested for mutations as part of pre-implantation diagnostics. Only the healthy ones would then be placed in the womb.

The manipulation of embryonic also has far-reaching implications, as all of the organism's cells will then subsequently carry this change. In addition, it involves intervening in the germline, which means the modified gene is passed onto future generations through ovum and sperm cells.

Such research is prohibited in Germany by the Embryo Protection Act. Do you envisage this law being softened as in the United Kingdom?

First of all, while are indeed being manipulated in the UK, they are not used for implantation. That would also be illegal there.

The experiments currently being performed involve pure basic research. Scientists are seeking to discover which genes play a key role in the early development of the human embryo. Whether such research produces significant gains in scientific knowledge is highly contentious.

And there are of course risks too, as the technology being developed essentially paves the way for medical application. I can't imagine such research being carried out in Germany. There is clearly no medical indication for manipulating , and such research should not therefore be authorized in my view.

So where do you believe the benefits of CRISPR/Cas lie?

It provides incredible potential for basic research. By recreating modifications in the genome, the influence of individual genes on the organism can be tested, for example. This is also where I believe the greatest potential for application lies.

The major advancement achieved by this technology is the capability to change the genome with a high degree of precision. CRISPR/Cas enables targeted mutations and modifications to be made to a cell or organism and even allows new parts to be inserted.

CRISPR/Cas also opens up new opportunities in gene therapy in humans. How does that work exactly?

Gene therapy always concerns diseases caused by mutated or altered . Diseased cells are removed from the patient, for example from the blood. These are genetically modified in the test tube so that pathogenic mutation is corrected and then put back into the patient's blood. Such modification cannot be inherited, as no other cells – in particular ovum and semen cells – are affected.

What benefits does CRISPR/Cas offer for gene therapy?

Virus systems have thus far been used to make genomic modifications. An artificial virus infects the and implants the DNA fragments. The gene encoded in the fragments is precisely the one changing in the patient and which therefore no longer works properly. The healthy gene is then incorporated into the patient's genetic make-up.

Virus systems nevertheless have a major disadvantage: they insert the healthy gene into the genome randomly. This often causes problems, because if the gene ends up in the wrong place it can result in cell degeneration and the onset of cancer. Genetic treatment is therefore not used routinely at the moment.

Being able to insert the healthy gene with great precision – as is possible with CRISPR/Cas technology – would represent major progress. Even though CRISPR/Cas is still in its infancy, this treatment is expected to be available in the not too distant future.


Explore further

Chinese team uses CRISPR to genetically modify human embryo

Provided by Max Planck Society
Citation: Geneticist warns against intervention in the human germline made possible by the CRISPR/Cas 'gene scissors' (2016, April 20) retrieved 19 July 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2016-04-geneticist-intervention-human-germline-crisprcas.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
14 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments


Apr 20, 2016
It's the future, LIVE with it (Literally). :-)

Apr 21, 2016
The Chinese are quite 'in yer face' about this, just like they violate openly the Treaty on the International Law of the Sea. The do not care about world opinion or morality because they do not have to care. No one is going to go into China with an army of a 100,000,000 troops to enforce anyone's view of morality. They follow Trotskiy: "One man with a machine gun and the will to use it can control a hundred!" ... or more! Also Stalin: "How many divisions does God have?" This new century is starting out with insanity controlling vital international resources...energy; and bullying replacing the rule of law in wider and wider areas of the world. This is the road to war and the century has barely gotten started yet!
This disease infects us here in the good old USA too. Just read Trump's speeches! He quite possibly will be our next president. Hillary Clinton's votes are in big cities. Bernie's votes are country resident populists just like Trump voters. Read da tealeaves

Apr 24, 2016
This disease infects us here in the good old USA too. Just read Trump's speeches! He quite possibly will be our next president. Hillary Clinton's votes are in big cities. Bernie's votes are country resident populists just like Trump voters. Read da tealeav


Sounds Good To Me! :-)

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more