Researchers find mentor programs often harm, more than help first-year science teachers

April 22, 2014 by Angie Hunt
Lori Ihrig (left) explains the constraints new science teachers face in the first two years of their career. The results of her study support the stories Michael Clough (center) and Joanne Olson (right) hear from former students. Photo by Bob Elbert

New teachers deal with a multitude of challenges during their first year in the classroom, which is why many school districts develop mentoring programs to ease that transition. But a new Iowa State University study found that instead of helping beginning science teachers, these programs tend to reinforce the status quo, making it difficult for teachers to promote a deep understanding of science.

Lori Ihrig, a graduate student in ISU's School of Education, followed 10 new secondary during the first two years of their careers to study their teaching practices and the socialization process. Joanne Olson and Michael Clough, both associate professors of science education, worked with Ihrig on the study. The team found that new teachers were often pressured to adapt their practices to the status quo, even if that contradicted established research-based classroom teaching practices.

The structure of the mentoring programs these teachers encountered made it hard for them to trust their mentors and easy for mentors to exert power. In many cases, mentors reported directly to the school principal, who ultimately evaluated the teacher's performance in consideration of contract offers and recommendation for licensure.

As a result, new teachers were reluctant to confide in their mentors, implement research-based practices that went against the status quo, or ask for help for fear it would hurt their careers. Ihrig, Clough and Olson presented these findings at the Association for Science Teacher Education conference in January, and the National Association for Research in Science Teaching conference in April.

Teachers in the study attempted to implement research-based teaching methods that promote science education goals. However, few received support, and several were reprimanded because their teaching appeared different. Many were told by administrators to adopt practices aligned with other teachers at the school, Ihrig said. This occurred even when those practices fell short of what is known about effective science teaching.

"Some teachers in the study implemented effective teaching without receiving assistance from their mentors regarding research-based practices. Others ran into so many constraints that by the end of their second year, their use of effective practices had decreased, and in some cases, disappeared," Ihrig said. "Teachers who are capable of highly effective teaching practices are often being pressured to adopt the status quo. That needs to be talked about and addressed."

Olson and Clough were disappointed, but not surprised by this study's findings. "I stay in contact with most of our graduates and have a folder full of messages from former students, who describe how they are pressured to adopt archaic teaching practices," Clough said. "Decades of research have made clear that those teaching practices do not promote deep understanding of science content, how science works and other important science education goals."

Olson suspects the hostile teaching culture existing in some schools may contribute to the high attrition rate of new teachers. "The public usually assumes teachers leave because of the low pay, but when you ask teachers why they leave, the No. 1 reason they cite is working conditions," Olson said. "We have individuals who left their school after the first year because it was a toxic environment."

A hostile work environment can have a haunting effect for first-year teachers. The study found that even if teachers move to a more supportive district, they have a hard time trusting or building positive relationships with other teachers and administrators.

Teachers going stealth

Researchers spent time in the classroom observing teachers to evaluate their effectiveness. They found teachers who shared with their colleagues their research-based science teaching practices faced more negative pressure than those who did so quietly and did not call attention to their practices – what Clough, Olson and Ihrig call "going stealth."

They explained that first-year teachers who "go stealth" find ways to navigate the constraints at their school by pretending to comply with the status quo. Many built a network of support with educators outside their school who were also implementing research-based science teaching practices. Ihrig says even though these teachers were more effective in the classroom, the situation was far from ideal.

"The problem is that we know new teachers are still learning how to teach. If they keep quiet, there's no one around helping them implement those practices, and they don't have people with whom they can collaborate within their school," Ihrig said.

The need for support

The researchers do not want the study to be viewed as an attack on teachers, or as a sign of failing schools. They see it as a reflection of limited opportunities for administrators to learn about and support effective science teaching; a lack of infrastructure for safer mentoring programs; and pressures to meet external policies.

"Beginning teachers do need support and mentoring," Clough said. "But their teaching practice is not benefitting from the kind of support often provided in school-based mentoring programs."

It is clear that beginning teachers are capable of using research-based teaching methods and effective teaching, but they need support to further develop these practices, Ihrig said. She hopes policymakers will take note and support changes to benefit teachers and ultimately students.

"Putting new teachers in the position of transforming school culture is unfair," Ihrig said. "We can help teachers become highly effective, if we create the right types of support. But currently we're ushering new into schools and socialization pressures are working against them implementing teaching practices that promote the goals we all ardently want for children."

Explore further: Perceptions of student ability, testing pressures hinder some science teachers

Related Stories

Early burnout puts heat on teacher education

October 7, 2013

Teachers are at risk of burnout, even during their early career, according to a large-scale study looking at what motivates teachers and why their initial enthusiasm may be unable to be sustained.

Time-poor parents go digital to communicate

April 16, 2013

Teachers are turning to twitter, blogging and Facebook as a way of keeping in touch with parents about their child's learning, and according to QUT education expert Associate Professor Margaret Lloyd it is a trend which is ...

Recommended for you

Industrial "edge cities" have helped China grow

August 18, 2017

China's massive investment in industrial parks has paid economic dividends while reshaping the urban areas where they are located, according to a newly published study co-authored by an MIT expert on urban economics.

Ancient species of giant sloth discovered in Mexico

August 17, 2017

Mexican scientists said Wednesday they have discovered the fossilized remains of a previously unknown species of giant sloth that lived 10,000 years ago and died at the bottom of a sinkhole.

The mathematics of golf

August 16, 2017

(—The official Rules of Golf, which are continually being revised and updated as new equipment emerges, have close ties to mathematics. In many cases, math is used to place limitations on golf equipment, such as ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Apr 29, 2014
I honestly could not agree more. By the way, all the fact that you mentioned…are just brilliant. We should definitely do something about first year science. As for the support: I have been telling this for a while already. We should not limit researcher's opportunities, as they will need to do lots of work (like coursework writing for instance, unless they feel like ordering it here http://essayonlin...rks.html at EssayOnlineStore, of course). Anyways, I am looking forward to some logical resolution.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.