Mantas, devil rays butchered for apothecary trade now identifiable

September 19, 2013 by Sandra Hines
Water flows through the 40-inch (1 meter) wide mouth of a giant manta and over the ray's gill arches, the white triangular parts running across the bottom and top of its mouth, five on each side. Its filters, too small to see at this distance, are located in the black portions in between. Credit: S Kajiura

Since dried filters from the mouths of filter-feeding rays hit apothecary shop menus in Asia—the thought being that eating ground-up filters will cleanse one's liver—there's been no way to know which of these gentle-natured rays was being slaughtered.

Unlike predatory rays that attack and crush prey with their mouths, the filter-feeder rays eat plankton particles, and fish eggs that they sieve from . Most lack other rays are notorious for, and the filter-feeders are generally considered harmless, although one group is provocatively named devil rays—they have horn like on their heads—and the other group includes the monstrous-sized manta, measuring up to 23 feet (7 meters) across and weighing 2 ½ tons.

Now, scientists with the University of Washington's Friday Harbor Laboratories have discovered enough differences in the filters to be able to identify the giant manta and eight of the devil rays using the part from inside their mouth that has been dried and is being sold.

"There is no historical or traditional medical use of these filters and there's no scientific evidence they will help your filter out toxins. Still there are thousands of these ray filters in the markets, especially in Indonesia," said Misty Paig-Tran, who studied the filters in detail while earning her doctorate in biology at the UW.

People have been looking at this group of animals for protection under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species, but there has been no way to know which of the groups need protection because the filters are cut out and the rest of the animal is discarded, she said.

Paig-Tran is lead author of the cover story in the September 2013 issue of the Journal of Morphology about the distinctive filters of these rays.

"You could take this paper to a market and tell which species the filters came from, and that would give you an idea of the number of each species being hunted," she said.

The basic ray filter consists of plates of tissue that share the gill arches with respiratory organs taking oxygen out of the water so the rays can "breathe." There are 10 gill arches, five on each side of the mouth. Paig-Tran estimates that the devil rays, for instance, might be handling a flow of 4 gallons a second or 240 gallons a minute for breathing and feeding, based on their mouth size.

Filter tissue with rows of what look like fern leaflets are distinctive for each filter-feeding ray, for example here's Manta birostis, a giant manta ray, compared to Mubula tarapacana, the Chilean devil ray. Even when dried, the differences remain and could be a way to identify which animals are being hunted from the filters being sold in apothecary shops. Credit: M Paig-Tran

Paig-Tran determined that the shapes of gill arches distinguishes them as filter-feeding rays and the filter tissue with its rows of what look like fern leaflets makes it possible to tell one ray from the other. Three of the ray species have filters with layers of hair like cilia to capture food, the rest do not. At the microscopic level many of the filters have denticles, which are tooth-like points that can deflect hard particles.

Paig-Tran relied on specimens borrowed from museums to describe these and other differences. She had also traveled to the Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico, to swim with rays and filter-feeding whale sharks to try to film their mouths as they feed.

"Whale sharks are incredibly docile and don't mind you in front of them, filming into their mouths. So long as you're a fast swimmer, you're OK," she said, describing swimming on her back, camera in hand, in front of the school-bus-sized creatures.

"Mantas are more difficult. Mantas have one of the largest brain to body ratio of any of the fishes. They are highly intelligent, they don't like to be disturbed and they're highly maneuverable."

And the devil rays?

"Way too fast," she said.

Filters, in red, attached to the gill arches, in blue, of a Munk's devil ray are typical of the placement in mantas and other devil rays. Credit: M Paig-Tran/T Kleinteich

These kinds of rays typically live in tropical and subtropical ocean waters. They are spotted where plankton-rich water upwells and they can feed, but not much is known about what they're eating. This new research describing the filters in detail could provide more clues. And Paig-Tran put satellite tags on a few of the rays to track their movements.

"Knowing their specific prey and if they are following blooms of particular plankton would be a way for us to remotely detect places where we might find these rays. Then we could learn more about their basic biology, where they are going, where they mate, where are they producing their young," Paig-Tran said.

One surprising feature the rays share is that they are all capable of cross-flow filtering, Paig-Tran said. She and her co-authors wrote that the cross-flow filtration by the rays is more similar to that used by humans in a number of manufacturing processes than is the cross-flow filtration shown by certain other fishes. Cross-flow filtration slows the amount of fine particles caking on a filter and is used in making such things as wine, fruit juices and certain pharmaceuticals.

Watch devil rays feeding and flying off Baja, California, in what National Geographic says could be the largest school ever filmed.

So apart from conservation implications, the new findings might be one step toward developing better industrial filters, said Adam Summers, a UW professor of biology, co-author on the paper and leader of a lab that looks for opportunities to copy or imitate nature, a field called biomimicry. The other co-author is Thomas Kleinteich, a postdoctoral researcher with the lab.

While human-made cross-flow filters eventually clog, the of rays don't. They'd have been extinct long ago if they did.

"There is no filter in the manufacturing realm like the ones these rays use," Summers said. His lab is now building models to better show how it's happening.

Explore further: First satellite tag study for manta rays reveals habits and hidden journeys of ocean giants

More information: … jmor.v274.9/issuetoc

Related Stories

Barrier reef corals deliver world first for sunscreen

August 2, 2013

CSIRO, in partnership with skincare company Larissa Bright Australia, has created the world's first UVA/UVB sunscreen filters which mimic the natural sun protection used by corals on the Great Barrier Reef.

US backs adding teeth to global shark protection

January 25, 2013

The United States said Friday it would support proposals to curb the trade of five shark species and manta rays, whose numbers are declining because of demand for fins and gills.

Majestic manta ray designated vulnerable species

November 15, 2011

Diving with the majestic manta ray is an eco-tourist’s dream come true that may soon be experienced only by viewing pictures and videos of the shark family’s graceful giants.

Whale's streaming baleen tangles to trap food

March 13, 2013

Many whales filter food from water using racks of baleen plates in their mouths, but no one had ever investigated how baleen behaves in real life. According to Alexander Werth from Hampden-Sydney College, baleen was viewed ...

Recommended for you

Mating induces sexual inhibition in female jumping spiders

October 18, 2017

After mating for the first time, most females of an Australian jumping spider are unreceptive to courtship by other males, and this sexual inhibition is immediate and often lasts for the rest of their lives, according to ...

Understanding the coevolving web of life as a network

October 18, 2017

Coevolution, which occurs when species interact and adapt to each other, is often studied in the context of pair-wise interactions between mutually beneficial symbiotic partners. But many species have mutualistic interactions ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Sep 20, 2013
Including the Nat Geo video was a nice touch. Enjoyed the article!
3 / 5 (4) Sep 20, 2013
These Asian cultures need to abandon the folklores and superstition of the past and join up with the present and stop killing rare animals for it.(I realize this one is a new one but it's because of the old superstitions that these ones have been accepted, doing stuff like that to cure some random ailment is only natural to them.)

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.