Research team finds that the ratio of component atoms vital to performance

May 24, 2013 by David L. Chandler
Balance is key to making quantum-dot solar cells work
This illustration shows a lead sulfide quantum dot array. Each quantum dot (the colored clusters) is 'passivated' by molecules that bind to its surface. Dots that are made up of unequal amounts of lead and sulfur tend to cause electrons (shown in red) to become highly localized, which can substantially lower the electrical transport of the device. Credit: DONGHUN KIM AND JEFFREY C. GROSSMAN

There has been great interest in recent years in using tiny particles called quantum dots to produce low-cost, easily manufactured, stable photovoltaic cells. But, so far, the creation of such cells has been limited by the fact that in practice, quantum dots are not as good at conducting an electric charge as they are in theory.

Something in the of these cells seems to trap their electric- (known as electrons and holes), but researchers have been hard-pressed to figure out exactly what. Now, for the most widely used type of , made of compounds called metal chalcogenides, researchers from MIT may have found the key: The limiting factor seems to be off-kilter ratios of the two basic components that make up the dots.

The new findings—by Jeffrey Grossman, the Carl Richard Soderberg Associate Professor of Power Engineering, graduate student Donghun Kim, and two other researchers—were reported this month in the journal Physical Review Letters.

In bulk quantities of lead sulfide, the material used for the quantum dots in this study, the ratio (known by chemists as "stoichiometry") of lead atoms to is exactly 1-to-1. But in the minuscule quantities of the material used to make quantum dots—which, in this case, were about 5 , or billionths of a meter, across—this ratio can vary significantly, a factor that had not previously been studied in detail. And, the researchers found, it turns out that this ratio is the key to determining the of the material.

When the stoichiometry is a perfect 1-to-1, the quantum dots work best, providing the exact semiconductor behavior that theory predicts. But if the ratio is off in either direction—a bit more lead or a bit more sulfur—the behavior changes dramatically, impeding the solar cell's ability to conduct charges.

Taking care of dangling bonds

Grossman explains that every atom inside the material has neighboring atoms on all sides, so all of that atom's potential bonds are used, but some surface atoms don't have neighbors, so their bonds can react with other atoms in the environment. These missing bonds, sometimes called "dangling bonds," have been thought to play a critical role in a quantum dot's electronic properties.

As a result, the consensus in the field has been that the best devices will have what is known as full "passivation": the addition of extra molecules that bind to any loose atomic bonds on the material's surface. The idea was that adding more of the passivating material (called ligands) would always improve performance, but that didn't work as scientists had expected: Sometimes it improved performance, but sometimes it made it worse.

"That was the traditional view that people believed," says Kim, who was the paper's lead author. But now it turns out that "how many dangling bonds the quantum dot has is not always important, as it doesn't really affect the density of trap states—at least in lead-and-sulfur-based dots." So, if a given dot already has an exact 1-to-1 ratio, adding ligands makes it worse, Kim says.

The new research solves the mystery of why that is: Computer simulations reveal that there is an optimum amount of passivating material, an amount that neutralizes exactly enough of these loose bonds to counterbalance any discrepancy in the stoichiometry, restoring an effective 1-to-1 balance. Too much or too little passivating material, and the imbalance remains, or even increases, reducing the efficiency of the material.

Great potential for solar cells

There has been "a lot of excitement" about the potential for quantum dots in applications including electronic devices, lighting and solar cells, Grossman says. Among other potential advantages, quantum-dot solar cells could be made in a low-temperature process, by depositing material from a solution at room temperature, rather than the high-temperature, energy-intensive processes used for conventional photovoltaics. In addition, such devices could be precisely "tuned," to obtain maximum conversion of specific wavelengths (colors) of light to energy, by adjusting the size and shape of the particles.

To go beyond the efficiencies achieved so far with quantum-dot , Grossman says, researchers needed to understand why the charges got trapped in the material. "We found something quite different than what people thought was causing the problem," he says.

"We hope this will inspire experimenters to look at this in new ways," he adds.

Figuring out how to apply this knowledge, and how to produce quantum dots with well-controlled elemental ratios, will be "challenging," Grossman says, "but there are a number of ways of controlling the surface."

The discovery came as a pleasant surprise, Kim says, noting that the researchers unexpectedly observed the origin of trap states as they were studying the way surface treatments would affect the material. But now that they have found this key factor, he says, they know what their goal is in further research: "The will be happy when the distribution … is just right," he says.

Giulia Galli, a professor of physics and chemistry at the University of California at Davis who was not connected with this research, says it is "quite a creative and important piece of work," and adds that, "I'm pretty sure this will stimulate new experiments" to engineer the stoichiometry of quantum dots in order to control their properties.

The paper is titled "Impact of Stoichiometry on the Electronic Structure of PbS Quantum Dots."

Explore further: Perfectly doped quantum dots yield colors to dye for

Related Stories

Perfectly doped quantum dots yield colors to dye for

May 10, 2013

( —Quantum dots are tiny nanocrystals with extraordinary optical and electrical properties with possible uses in dye production, bioimaging, and solar energy production. Researchers at the University of Illinois ...

Team demonstrates quantum dots that assemble themselves

April 16, 2013

( —Scientists from the U.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory and other labs have demonstrated a process whereby quantum dots can self-assemble at optimal locations in nanowires, a breakthrough ...

Researchers demonstrate quantum dots that assemble themselves

February 11, 2013

(—Scientists from the U.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory and other labs have demonstrated a process whereby quantum dots can self-assemble at optimal locations in nanowires, a breakthrough ...

New solar-cell design based on dots and wires

March 25, 2013

Using exotic particles called quantum dots as the basis for a photovoltaic cell is not a new idea, but attempts to make such devices have not yet achieved sufficiently high efficiency in converting sunlight to power. A new ...

Recommended for you

Graphene's sleeping superconductivity awakens

January 19, 2017

Researchers have found a way to trigger the innate, but previously hidden, ability of graphene to act as a superconductor - meaning that it can be made to carry an electrical current with zero resistance.

New low-cost technique converts bulk alloys to oxide nanowires

January 19, 2017

A simple technique for producing oxide nanowires directly from bulk materials could dramatically lower the cost of producing the one-dimensional (1D) nanostructures. That could open the door for a broad range of uses in lightweight ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (9) May 24, 2013
At this scale, one would expect to require greater precision in ingredient ratios; any extraneous material would act to clog and alter the characteristics in the resulting material. To me, this seems an intuitive conclusion. The smaller the scale, the greater the need for precision.
1 / 5 (6) May 26, 2013
Quite intuitive evident, Moreover PbS is the galena of the first radio in the 1920,, very variable !!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.