Herring can give us even more food

July 9, 2012, Chalmers University of Technology

Herring is one of the most common table fish in the entire world, but large parts of the catch is being used for fish feed. "From an environmental perspective, it is better if the herring is used for food for humans," says Chalmers researcher Sofia Marmon. She has succeeded in extracting fish proteins from herring, which can be used for new foodstuffs. In addition, the dioxin content decreases.

Sofia Marmon recently defended her PhD thesis at Chalmers University of Technology.  She has succeeded in making use of the proteins in , using a method that is known as the pH-shift process. The aim is to extract the proteins from raw materials that are not used as food for human consumption today. In addition to herring that is used for fishmeal production, other poorly consumed small species can be used, such as Anchoveta and European sprat, or the muscle-rich backbones that are left over when fish are filleted.
“Fish fillets have been used in most previous experiments where the pH-shift process has been employed, but I think that fish fillets should instead be eaten as they are”, says Sofia Marmon.
The method of extracting proteins used by Sofia Marmon was invented at the end of the 1990s at the University of Massachusetts. Sofia Marmon’s tutor, Professor Ingrid Undeland, was one of the researchers there and she then brought the method to Chalmers.
The structure of the muscle isolate that is extracted through the pH-shift process resembles a paste with quite a high water content. The consistency of the proteins is moldable and they can therefore be used as an ingredient in various products, or for developing entirely new foodstuffs.
The pH-shift process has already started to be used in production in the USA and Iceland.  The company in the USA uses the extracted proteins as a replacement for breadcrumbs in the coating of fried products. The advantage is that the proteins protect the fish better towards moisture loss during the frying, at the same time as it absorbs less fat.
Sofia Marmon’s research shows that the extracted proteins have a good nutritional value and are a lot purer than in the raw product. Both skin and bone are removed and the fat content is lowered. This means that fat-soluble toxins are also removed, such as PCB and harmful dioxins, which can be found for example in the herring in the Baltic Sea. Sofia Marmon has also shown, using a test tube model, that the extracted fish proteins can easily be digested in the stomach and intestinal tract.

Sofia Marmon thinks that in order for the process to be used more commercially, the industry must have enough believe in its potential to make the necessary investments.
“It’s time to move onto product development. Of course we as scientists can play an important role here in providing background information and also help out during up-scaling. I hope that this becomes a product that people are well aware of and have confidence in. In order to avoid any misconceptions, it is important that the industry is open and clearly declares what the new product consists of. We do not want to have a situation where people think that a new ingredient has been added surreptitiously.”
Naturally, Sofia Marmon has tasted the purified proteins extracted from herring, which after heat treatment have a consistency similar to crabsticks.
“It didn’t taste or smell of much. You have to use spices to make it tasty.”
More about: How the pH-shift process works

The herring is ground and mixed with water. An acid or base is added in order to adjust the pH value. When the pH value decreases or increases, the proteins become electrically charged and repel each other. The proteins open up and attract more water. When most of the fish’s proteins are water-soluble, they can be separated from the non-soluble unwanted parts by centrifugation. Most of the fish fat can also be removed. Once the pH value of the water solution has been readjusted so that the protein solubility is minimal, the proteins can be collected by a second centrifugation.
More about: Herring and the environment

From a resource perspective, it is better to eat fish, such as herring and European sprat, than manufacture fish meal, which is then used for feed in fish farming and in chicken and pig breeding.This is mainly due to the fact that only a small part of the energy is transferred from one stage of the food chain to the next. In all animals, most of the food is used for “fuel”. Only 5 - 25 per cent of the food forms “building blocks” in the body and, consequently, food for the next consumer in the food chain.
Herring is one of the more sustainable fish species and is one of the most common fish species in the world. Last year, 2.5 million tonnes of herring were caught worldwide. However, a large proportion of the total catch is being used for things other than for human consumption, such as . The same scenario is seen for many other small pelagic ; large quantities are caught but the catches are mostly used for fishmeal production.

Explore further: Finding an alternative to feeding fish fish

More information: Read the thesis Protein isolation from herring (Clupea harengus) using the pH-shift process - Protein yield, protein isolate quality and removal of food contaminants

Related Stories

Finding an alternative to feeding fish fish

May 15, 2012

Scientists at the University are developing a new plant-based product that could replace fishmeal, reducing the need for farmers to feed fish to other fish at a time when more than 90% of EU waters are at risk from overfishing.

8 species of wild fish have been detected in aquaculture feed

April 25, 2012

Researchers from the University of Oviedo have for the first time analysed a DNA fragment from commercial feed for aquarium cichlids, aquaculture salmon and marine fish in aquariums. The results show that in order to manufacture ...

North Sea cod and herring under threat

June 26, 2006

European scientists say cod and herring populations in the North Sea are not reproducing enough, jeopardizing the Norwegian fishing industry.

Alternative fish feeds use less fishmeal and fish oils

October 13, 2010

As consumers eat more fish as part of a healthy diet, U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) scientists are helping producers meet this demand by developing new feeds that support sustainable aquaculture production.

In cod we trust: DNA test combats fisheries fraud

May 22, 2012

Scientists on Tuesday said they had devised a DNA test to pinpoint the geographical origins of commercial seafish, in a breakthrough against illegal trawling that threatens fish stocks worldwide.

Recommended for you

Microbial communities demonstrate high turnover

January 19, 2018

When Mark Twain famously said "If you don't like the weather in New England, just wait a few minutes," he probably didn't anticipate MIT researchers would apply his remark to their microbial research. But a new study does ...

Hot weather is bad news for bird sperm

January 19, 2018

A new study led by Macquarie University and spanning Sydney and Oslo has shown that exposure to extreme temperatures, such as those experienced during heatwave conditions, significantly reduces sperm quality in zebra finches, ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.