Paradigm shift: How Galileo's spy glass upended science

Oct 23, 2009 by Marlowe Hood
Galileo Galilei
Portrait of Galileo Galilei by Justus Sustermans painted in 1636. Image: Wikimedia Commons

Today it would hardly pass muster as a child's plaything, but the telescope Galileo used 400 years ago this week to peer into the heavens overturned the foundations of knowledge, changing our perception of the Universe and our place in it.

Galileo's "optick tube" magnified a meagre nine-fold and was not even conceived for astronomy.

Indeed, when the gadget was first demonstrated, Venetian senators were so smitten with its military potential that they doubled Galileo's salary and awarded him life tenure in the city-state's most prestigious university.

But when, in late October 1609, the 45-year-old Italian mathematician pointed his newfangled instrument -- essentially two lenses aligned in a tube -- skyward, what he glimpsed would unleash a scientific revolution and a rare "paradigm shift" in thought.

"He immediately made several surprising discoveries that contributed to the demise of the Earth-centered cosmology that had dominated Western thought for two millennia," says Robert Joseph, a professor of astronomy at the University of Hawaii.

Using ever-more powerful telescopes over the next year, Galileo observed that the Moon was not perfectly smooth as claimed by Aristotle but cratered and mountainous.

He spotted hundreds of stars previously untouched by human eyes.

More critically, he discovered the four inner satellites of Jupiter -- still known as the "Galilean moons" today, in his honour -- and learnt that , Earth's closest planet, goes through a full range of phases.

Put together, his observations validated the revolutionary theory of Nicolaus Copernicus that orbits the Sun, and not the other way round.

A graphic on the 400th anniversary of Galileo's telescope, which he presented in Venice on August 25, 1609. The technical breakthrough helped to establish the theory of a heliocentric universe. 130x85mm

Galileo understood the implications of what he had seen, but the Catholic Church was not ready to accept such heresy.

Only in 2000 did the Holy See apologise for putting Galileo on trial in 1633, forcing him to recant his ideas lest he face imprisonment or worse. The Vatican also paid tribute to him in an exhibition that opened this month.

But resistance to a solar-centric view was not only religious.

The ancient Greek notion that Earth was at the centre of the cosmos was also a deeply ingrained scientific dogma, and it took decades to dislodge it.

Even the notion that "we can improve on our senses" by magnifying our vision was considered taboo, says Jerome Lamy, a French science historian at the Paris Observatory.

The concept of paradigm shifts was first articulated by US philosopher Thomas Kuhn in a 1962 book, "The Structure of Scientific Revolutions".

A sea change in thinking entails not only the overturning of a theory but the creation of an entirely new world view, he said.

It happened again at the start of the 20th century, only a few years after Scottish mathematician Lord Kelvin had famously declared there was "nothing new" to be discovered in physics.

That seismic shift came in the form of a short paper on special relativity by a German-born patent-office worker by the name of Albert Einstein.

Again, it did not happen overnight. But Einstein's ideas eventually toppled laws of physics that had prevailed for three centuries.

Some scientists say that we may be on the edge of yet another such turning point as the world's biggest atom smasher, the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), gears up to search for a theoretical sub-atomic particle that could explain how matter acquires mass.

"Dark matter" and "dark energy" deemed to account for 96 percent of the cosmos are other theorised puzzles.

If the LHC answers them, it could once again throw science into a period of fruitful crisis before a new consensus emerges.

German nuclear physicist Max Planck understood that old theories die hard.

"A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die," he wrote.

(c) 2009 AFP

Explore further: Cassini watches mysterious feature evolve in Titan sea

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Eyes to the skies for the 'Galilean Nights'

Oct 22, 2009

Astronomers around the world are gearing up for three days of intense sky-watching in honour of Galileo, whose observations 400 years ago revolutionised our understanding of the cosmos.

Looking through Galileo's eyes

Jan 08, 2009

In 1609, exactly four centuries ago, Galileo revolutionised humankind's understanding of our position in the Universe when he used a telescope for the first time to study the heavens, which saw him sketching radical new views ...

What did Galileo actually do?

Feb 19, 2009

( -- What convinced Galileo 400 years ago that the Earth orbits the Sun and not vice-versa? How did one man make such a startling discovery, armed with just a 2 inch lens telescope?

Galileo's telescope on historic visit to Philly

Apr 02, 2009

(AP) -- Though it looks like a cardboard tube that got left out in the rain, it's a priceless instrument whose owner changed the world. The mottled brown cylinder on display at The Franklin Institute science ...

World event hopes to lure 1 mln to astronomy

Apr 02, 2009

At sunset on Thursday, astronomers around the world will be limbering up for a 100-hour marathon aimed at celebrating the night sky and nurturing the Galileos of tomorrow.

Recommended for you

US-India to collaborate on Mars exploration

6 hours ago

The United States and India, fresh from sending their own respective spacecraft into Mars' orbit earlier this month, on Tuesday agreed to cooperate on future exploration of the Red Planet.

Swift mission observes mega flares from a mini star

7 hours ago

On April 23, NASA's Swift satellite detected the strongest, hottest, and longest-lasting sequence of stellar flares ever seen from a nearby red dwarf star. The initial blast from this record-setting series ...

Sandblasting winds shift Mars' landscape

11 hours ago

High winds are a near-daily force on the surface of Mars, carving out a landscape of shifting dunes and posing a challenge to exploration, scientists said Tuesday.

PanSTARRS K1, the comet that keeps going

14 hours ago

Thank you K1 PanSTARRS for hanging in there! Some comets crumble and fade away. Others linger a few months and move on. But after looping across the night sky for more than a year, this one is nowhere near ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3 / 5 (2) Oct 23, 2009
Once again we have scientists saying that we have discovered all there is to discover. They will be proved wrong as the next paradigm shift is just around the corner.
2.3 / 5 (3) Oct 23, 2009
Once again we have scientists saying that we have discovered all there is to discover. They will be proved wrong as the next paradigm shift is just around the corner.

Exactly right! The scientific establishment of this century is no less dogmatic than the Catholic Church in the time of Galileo Galilei.

On June 11-15, 2001 I was in Sicily to present a paper at the institution where Galileo Galilei taught in Santa Flavia (near Palermo) Italy.

Our paper with experimental evidence that the interior of the Sun is mostly Fe, O, Ni, Si, S, Mg and Ca - just like ordinary meteorites and rocky planets near the Sun - was excluded from the proceedings.

With kind regards,
Oliver K. Manuel
3 / 5 (2) Oct 24, 2009
"Exactly right! The scientific establishment of this century is no less dogmatic than the Catholic Church in the time of Galileo Galilei."

Rubbish! I hope you know more about the sun than history.
1 / 5 (2) Oct 24, 2009
"Exactly right! The scientific establishment of this century is no less dogmatic than the Catholic Church in the time of Galileo Galilei."

Absolutely correct! LHC hopefully will have a PROFOUND effect on science, pulling down the dogma and showing the emperor he is naked.

I see two paradigm shifts are taking place at the moment -

cosmology:a shift to a plasma orientated universe (not billiard ball physics) and eventual understanding of gravity

evolution: a shift towards horizontal gene transfer mechanisms as the principle driver for evolution, and Darwinian evolution downsized as only one refining mechanism of existing gene code.