Problem of gender differences on physics assessments remains unsolved

Nov 01, 2013
Students are shown in an interactive physics classroom. Credit: Thomas Cox, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

In a new synthesis of past work, researchers found that women consistently score lower than men on common assessments of conceptual understanding of physics. However, when examining the factors that may account for these differences (such as student background and test-taking strategies), no clear pattern emerged. Thus, despite previous claims that the causes of this gender gap have been pinpointed, the problem remains unsolved and poorly understood. This has critical importance for science education reform.

Many changes have been made in college science instruction in the past decades. Numerous classrooms have shifted from a traditional lecture presentation to more interactive formats that aim to engage in building their own knowledge. Physics has been a forerunner of this movement, in part because of early and ongoing research on how students grapple with key ideas in this difficult field. Comparisons of student understanding have been made possible through the development of "concept inventories" – multiple choice tests of student understanding, developed through years of research, enabling the same test to be given to students in a variety of classrooms.

"These tests have been very important in the history of physics education reform," said Dr. McKagan, who co-authored the new analysis. Past studies have shown that students in classrooms using interactive techniques get significantly higher scores on these tests than do students in more traditional lecture settings; "these results have inspired a lot of people to change the way that they teach," said McKagan.

But several studies had also reported that women's scores on these tests are typically lower than men's. "We set out to determine whether there is a gender gap on these concept inventories," said lead author Madsen, "and if so, what causes it."

Students are shown in an interactive physics classroom. Credit: Thomas Cox, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

The authors combined results from 26 previous studies of several common physics concept inventories, covering 12 different institutions. They found that women almost always score lower than men on these tests (12% on average for tests about force and motion), both before instruction, and at the end of the course. The same trend is also found when comparing male and female students' gains on the tests, showing that this gap is not simply due to differing levels of incoming knowledge. There is some variation across studies – the gender gap sometimes goes up and sometimes goes down, but rarely goes away, observe the authors. Women also receive lower scores on course exams (4% on average) than do men, which can impact course grades. These results mirror those in other studies of gender differences on other types of science and math tests, such as standardized placement exams.

One key finding from the study is that, while there is a gender gap in performance on concept inventories, the performance of both men and women is improved when they experience an interactive classroom. These teaching techniques improve student gains on these tests by four times as much as the size of the gap between men's and women's scores. Thus, previous results on the positive impact of interactive teaching techniques are still valid for both men and women.

Another important result of the authors' analysis is that no obvious factor appears to be responsible for women's lower scores. Unlike the impact of interactive engagement on student performance, "we haven't found a miracle that solves the gender gap," said McKagan. The authors cross-checked the results from studies investigating the potential impact of student background, their beliefs about physics, the teaching method used, their ingrained stereotypes about women's abilities, and the wording of test questions. Some studies – several of which were quite high-profile – demonstrated that one or more of these elements had a significant influence, but most were contradicted in other studies. One of the more promising findings is that women's poorer background preparation in physics may account for much of the gender gap, but those results have not been replicated outside of a single university and may be reflective of several underlying causes.

Such contradictory results suggest that gender differences in physics performance are a particularly thorny and complex issue. When a single study claims to have found a solution to in science, it should be treated with healthy skepticism. (Research on female performance in math and science more broadly have also met with contradictory results, though social factors – such as stereotypes – appear to contribute powerfully to gender gaps.)

While the gender gap on physics concept inventories remains an unsolved problem, the researchers suggest some take-home messages for instructors. One is that the use of interactive teaching techniques can improve student understanding for both genders. Another is simply to recognize that there is a gender gap on conceptual assessments and exams, and that addressing this gap will require creativity on the part of the instructor. Prior work suggests some strategies that an instructor may take (such as having students reflect on their values prior to a test), but it is important not to rely too heavily on any one technique. The authors call for researchers to devote additional attention to investigating the underlying causes of this and possible interventions.

Explore further: Depression and mental health services usage

More information: "The gender gap on concept inventories in physics: what is consistent, what is inconsistent, and what factors influence the gap?" A. Madsen, S. B. McKagan and E. C. Sayre, Physical Review Special Topics – Physics Education Research. To be published online November 7

Provided by American Physical Society

4.6 /5 (10 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Gender gap in STEM majors linked to high school job plans

May 10, 2013

(Phys.org) —The fact that women are much less likely than men to choose science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) majors in college can be traced to gender differences in occupational plans in high school, reports ...

Depression and mental health services usage

Sep 30, 2013

More than half the people in Ontario who reported they had major depression did not use physician-based mental health services in the following year, a new study has found.

Young women do not want to run for office

Mar 26, 2013

Despite some very high-profile female candidates and elected officials, and what looks like a changing landscape of U.S. politics, a new study conducted by American University professor and director of its ...

Recommended for you

Spin-based electronics: New material successfully tested

15 hours ago

Spintronics is an emerging field of electronics, where devices work by manipulating the spin of electrons rather than the current generated by their motion. This field can offer significant advantages to computer technology. ...

A transistor-like amplifier for single photons

Jul 29, 2014

Data transmission over long distances usually utilizes optical techniques via glass fibres – this ensures high speed transmission combined with low power dissipation of the signal. For quite some years ...

User comments : 9

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Sean_W
1 / 5 (17) Nov 01, 2013
Ban women from nursing, biology and sociology. It will be easy to get women into fields they aren't in once you get them out of fields they are over represented in.
Humpty
1.2 / 5 (18) Nov 01, 2013
Women tend to score poorly when significantly outnumbered by men, because they are too preoccupied with thoughts of sex - and cannot concentrate, even less than usual.

Osiris1
1.3 / 5 (13) Nov 02, 2013
Having gone through college with women in courses, let me offer my experience in Calculus. To get thru engineering college, three courses of Calculus, I, II, and III, and differential equations are required. The attrition rates of women in these courses is ...amazing... Calc I in my Community College started with 34 students including a dozen women. Only 2 were left after six weeks; none lasted to the final. Only six of us were at the final and three passed, including yours truly. I had never seen such carnage in a course before. Think part of the problem is women have trouble with hard logic and especially with multidimensional thinking and function visializations. Conceptualization of solutions by borrowing on other branches of math, including trigonomic identity substitutions and factoring tends to elude them. The carnage continued into the Calc II, techniques of integration...only worse. Out of 32 students starting, only three of us were at the final and only I survived.
ToolMan78
1.3 / 5 (12) Nov 02, 2013
Would admitting that biology may have differentiated the male and female mind be so bad? It astounds me that no one wants to say that men, on average, simply have higher proficiency in physics.
Raymailhot
1 / 5 (5) Nov 02, 2013
Social engineering has its limitations on regendering the sciences and it is funny they can't figure out what has been known for many years. Men and women think differently and have different desires. At the same point there are women that have become very famous for their contributions and were not held back. This whole article is a big so what! Lets stop trying to skew the system with bad theology!
Tektrix
1 / 5 (1) Nov 04, 2013
"Ban women from..."

"You cannot beat the biology with gender quotas and I even don't know, what it would be good for."

"because they are too preoccupied with thoughts of sex - and cannot concentrate, even less than usual."

There's nothing like a bunch of misogynists to clearly illustrate the problem. :(
Tektrix
not rated yet Nov 04, 2013
The girls are now returning into more traditional (i.e. "masculine") perception of women as a housewives and sex toys and the natural sciences, the physics in particular is interesting for them even less, than before twenty years. So I'm pretty sure, that this gender "problem" with application of women in physics will disappear spontaneously, when the human civilization will get richer again after implementation of cold fusion: the physicists can solve their gender problems by itself.


I so hope you have never reproduced.
ant_oacute_nio354
1 / 5 (2) Nov 06, 2013
Is very simple: men are better than woman.

Antonio Jose Saraiva
ant_oacute_nio354
1 / 5 (2) Nov 06, 2013
If woman are better everything is ok but if men are better there's a mistery.

Antonio Jose Saraiva