# Researchers seeking to redefine difference between solids and liquids

##### Apr 08, 2013 by Bob Yirka

(Phys.org) —Charles Radin a mathematical physicist with the University of Texas and one of his former student's David Aristoff, have built a 2D model material made of disks to represent atoms. In their article published in Notices of the American Mathematical Society, they suggest that their model shows that defining the difference between a solid and a liquid should be more a matter of measuring the way a material responds to shear, than looking at the way its atoms are arranged.

For most people, the difference between a solid and liquid is easy to discern—liquids move, they flow, they take the shape of whatever they are put in. Solids on the other hand, are rigid and don't slosh around. For however, things are not quite so simple, especially since 1984 when Dan Shechtman discovered what are now known as (for which he won the in 2011)—materials that appear rigid but upon closer inspection reveal a non-repeating pattern in the arrangement of their atoms. Thus, they're neither liquid nor solid according to the traditional definition (solids are supposed to be arranged in a ), which muddles the very definition of the . Because of that, physicists and mathematicians have been looking for a new way to clearly differentiate between a solid and a liquid.

Radin and Aristoff suggest that measuring shear in a material is the way to go. In physics, shear is witnessed as a body part being deformed and can be expressed mathematically as the sidewise displacement between two points in parallel planes divided by the distance between those planes. In building their model, they found that at low densities, materials show no response to shear, but as the atoms move closer to one another and eventually become densely packed together, they do show shear, and also tend to result in expansion of the material. It's where it crosses over, the two say, that the definition of solid versus liquid resides.

Another team, this one in France, has another idea—they say matter can be defined as solid or liquid by measuring its viscosity, or ability to flow. They note that glass actually flows, very slowly of course, and so does diamond, though they note researchers would have to measure it over the course of the age of universe to see it flow due to Earth's gravity.

In either case, redefining what constitutes the different states of matter is important because without clear terminology, material descriptions can lose their meaning.

Explore further: Strong teams attract crowds for international cricket

## Related Stories

#### Unlocking jams in fluid materials: A theoretical model to understand how to best avoid jamming of soft matter

Oct 05, 2011

In a study recently published in European Physical Journal E (EPJE), a German scientist constructed a theoretical model to understand how to best avoid jamming of soft matter that can be applied in food and cosmetics produc ...

#### A new way of making glass

Nov 09, 2012

(Phys.org)—A new way to make glass has been discovered by a collaboration of researchers at the Universities of Düsseldorf and Bristol using a method that controls how the atoms within a substance are ...

#### Quasicrystal mystery unraveled with computer simulation

Mar 06, 2008

The method to the madness of quasicrystals has been a mystery to scientists. Quasicrystals are solids whose atoms aren't arranged in a repeating pattern, as they are in ordinary crystals. Yet they form intricate patterns ...

#### Cracking a controversial solid state mystery

Feb 06, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Scientists can easily explain the structural order that makes steel and aluminium out of molten metal. And they have discovered the molecular changes that take place as water turns to ice. But, despite the ...

#### How to Rip a Fluid

Jun 01, 2007

In a simple experiment on a mixture of water, surfactant (soap), and an organic salt, two researchers working in the Pritchard Laboratories at Penn State have shown that a rigid object like a knife passes ...

#### Experimental evidence adds to the likelihood of the existence of supersolids, an exotic phase of matter

Feb 18, 2011

Supersolids and superfluids rank among the most exotic of quantum mechanical phenomena. Superfluids can flow without any viscosity, and experience no friction as they flow along the walls of a container, because ...

## Recommended for you

#### Serbs protest moving of famous inventor's ashes

Mar 08, 2014

Several hundred people protested in Belgrade on Saturday against plans to move the ashes of Nikola Tesla, one of the pioneers of modern electrical engineering, to Serbia's biggest church.

#### Service is key to winery sales

Mar 07, 2014

To buy, or not to buy? That is the question for the more than 5 million annual visitors to New York's wineries. Cornell University researchers found that customer service is the most important factor in boosting tasting room ...

Mar 07, 2014

A second viewing in a police line-up may help more eyewitnesses identify the culprit, new research from Flinders University reveals.

#### Statue of Egypt pharoanic princess found in Luxor

Mar 07, 2014

(AP)—Egypt has announced that a team of European archaeologists have found a nearly 2-meter- (6 ½-foot-) tall alabaster statue of a pharoanic princess, dating from approximately 1350 B.C., outside the ...

#### Expiration of terrorism risk insurance act could hurt national security, study finds

Mar 07, 2014

Allowing the federal terrorism risk insurance act to expire could have negative consequences for U.S. national security, according to a new study from the RAND Corporation.

#### Women's widespread inequality and rape as a weapon of war

Mar 07, 2014

Women are more likely to experience mass rape and sexual torture in armed conflicts around the world, as a deliberate strategy to humiliate, intimidate and dominate them and their 'enemy' community.

not rated yet Apr 08, 2013
"Charles Radin a mathematical physicist with the University of Texas and one of his former student's David Aristoff"

So which of his former students owns David Aristoff?

Do you people not read the stuff you print, or do you think grammar is optional? Good lord...

## More news stories

#### Secret to the perfect pancake is discovered

In a collaboration with Meadowhall Shopping Centre, students from the University's Maths Society (SUMS) developed, trialled and tested a formula which enables pancake-lovers across the world to rustle-up ...

#### Question of race not simple for Mexican Americans

About half of Latinos check "white" in response to the question about race on the U.S. Census. About half check "other race."

#### The science that makes us spend more in supermarkets, and feel good while we do it

When you walk into a supermarket, you probably want to spend as little money as possible. The supermarket wants you to spend as much money as possible. Let battle commence.

#### Lose yourself to dance, know yourself better

Could managers gain a new kind of understanding about their interaction with colleagues and employees by 'dancing'? That's the question arising from new research published this month in the International Journal of Work Or ...

#### Serbs protest moving of famous inventor's ashes

Several hundred people protested in Belgrade on Saturday against plans to move the ashes of Nikola Tesla, one of the pioneers of modern electrical engineering, to Serbia's biggest church.

#### Mapping the behavior of charges in correlated spin-orbit coupled materials

A team of Boston College physicists has mapped the inner atomic workings of a compound within the mysterious class of materials known as spin-orbit Mott insulators. The findings confirm the properties that ...

#### Cybercriminals entrenched in 'Dark Web', researchers says

Cybercriminals are settling into a comfortable place in the "Dark Web" where they test, refine and distribute malware for online thievery.

#### Britain, Germany to collaborate on 5G next mobile network

Britain and Germany will team up to work on developing the next super-fast mobile network, 5G, Prime Minister David Cameron told the opening of the world's biggest high-tech fair Sunday.

#### China bird flu deaths reach 72 this year

A total of 72 people died from the H7N9 bird flu strain in China in the first two months of this year, government figures showed, far more than in the whole of 2013.

#### Australia endures sweltering 'angry summer'

Australia has endured another "angry summer" with more than 150 temperature records smashed, a new report said Monday, with a warning that heatwaves and sweltering conditions will only get worse.