Scientists find oldest dinosaur—or closest relative yet

Dec 04, 2012
Scientists find oldest dinosaur – or closest relative yet
This is the humerus, or upper arm bone, of Nyasasaurus parringtoni next to a cross section of the bone. The many colors indicate that the bone fibers are disorganized, much like those of early dinosaurs. (c) Natural History Museum

Researchers have discovered what may be the earliest dinosaur, a creature the size of a Labrador retriever, but with a five foot-long tail, that walked the Earth about 10 million years before more familiar dinosaurs like the small, swift-footed Eoraptor and Herrerasaurus.

The findings mean that the dinosaur appeared 10 million to 15 million years earlier than fossils previously showed, originating in the Middle Triassic rather than in the Late Triassic period.

"If the newly named Nyasasaurus parringtoni is not the earliest dinosaur, then it is the closest relative found so far," according to Sterling Nesbitt, a University of Washington postdoctoral researcher in biology and lead author of a paper published online Dec. 5 in Biology Letters, a journal of the United Kingdom's Royal Society.

"For 150 years, people have been suggesting that there should be Middle Triassic dinosaurs, but all the evidence is ambiguous," he said. "Some scientists used , but we now know that other animals from that time have a very similar foot. Other scientists pointed to a single dinosaur-like characteristic in a single bone, but that can be misleading because some characteristics evolved in a number of reptile groups and are not a result of a shared ancestry."

The researchers had one humerus – or upper arm bone – and six vertebrae to work with. They determined that the animal likely stood upright, measured 7 to 10 feet in length (2 to 3 meters), was as tall as 3 feet at the hip (1 meter) and may have weighed between 45 and 135 pounds (20 to 60 kilograms).

The were collected in the 1930s from Tanzania, but it may not be correct to say dinosaurs originated in that country. When Nyasasaurus parringtoni lived, the world's continents were joined in the called Pangaea. Tanzania would have been part of Southern Pangaea that included Africa, South America, Antarctica and Australia.

"The new findings place the early evolution of dinosaurs and dinosaur-like reptiles firmly in the southern continents," said co-author Paul Barrett at the Natural History Museum, London.

Scientists find oldest dinosaur – or closest relative yet
Artist rendering of Nyasasaurus parringtoni, either the earliest dinosaur or the closest dinosaur relative yet discovered. Nyasasaurus parringtoni was up to 10 feet long, weighed perhaps 135 pounds and is depicted near plant-eating reptiles of the genus Stenaulorhynchus. (c)Natural History Museum, London/Mark Witton

The bones of the new animal reveal a number of characteristics common to early dinosaurs and their close relatives. For example, the bone tissues in the upper arm bone appear as if they are woven haphazardly and not laid down in an organized way. This indicates rapid growth, a common feature of dinosaurs and their close relatives.

"We can tell from the bone tissues that Nyasasaurus had a lot of bone cells and blood vessels," said co-author Sarah Werning at the University of California, Berkeley, who did the bone analysis. "In living animals, we only see this many bone cells and blood vessels in animals that grow quickly, like some mammals or birds."

"The bone tissue of Nyasasaurus is exactly what we would expect for an animal at this position on the dinosaur family tree," she added. "It's a very good example of a transitional ; the bone tissue shows that Nyasasaurus grew about as fast as other primitive dinosaurs, but not as fast as later ones."

Another example is the upper arm 's distinctively enlarged crest, needed to anchor the muscles. The feature, known as an elongated deltopectoral crest, is also common to all early dinosaurs.

Bones of Nyasasaurus parringtoni were collected in southwest Tanzania in the 1930s from the Manda beds, which preserves fossils of many animals from the Triassic Period of Earth's history. Credit: U of Washington

"Nyasasaurus and its age have important implications regardless of whether this taxon is a dinosaur or the closest relatives of dinosaurs," Nesbitt said. "It establishes that dinosaurs likely evolved earlier than previously expected and refutes the idea that dinosaur diversity burst onto the scene in the Late Triassic, a burst of diversification unseen in any other groups at that time."

It now appears that dinosaurs were just part of a large diversification of archosaurs. Archosaurs were among the dominant land animals during the 250 million to 200 million years ago and include dinosaurs, crocodiles and their kin.

" are just part of this archosaur diversification, an explosion of new forms soon after the Permian extinction," Nesbitt said.

The specimen used to identify the new species is part of the collection at the Natural History Museum, London. Four from a second specimen of Nyasasaurus, which were also used in this research, are housed in the South African Museum in Cape Town. The work was funded by the National Science Foundation and the Natural History Museum, London. The fourth co-author on the paper is Christian Sidor, UW professor of biology.

The name Nyasasaurus parringtoni is new, but "Nyasasaurus" – combining the lake name Nyasa with the term "saurus" for lizard – is not. The late paleontologist Alan Charig, included as a co-author on the paper, named the specimen but never documented or published in a way that was formally recognized. "Parringtoni" is in honor of University of Cambridge's Rex Parrington, who collected the specimens in the 1930s.

"What's really neat about this specimen is that it has a lot of history. Found in the '30s, first described in the 1950s but never published, then its name pops up but is never validated. Now 80 years later, we're putting it all together," Nesbitt said.

"This work highlights the important role of museums in housing specimens whose scientific importance might be overlooked unless studied and restudied in detail," Barrett said. "Many of the more important discoveries in paleontology are made in the lab, or museum storerooms, as well as in the field."

Explore further: Scientists seek more tombs at ancient Greek site

More information: Fact sheet

Nyasasaurus parringtoni

The following fact sheet was developed by co-authors of "The oldest dinosaur? A Middle Triassic dinosauriform from Tanzania," being published online Dec. 5, 2012, in Biology Letters.

Major Findings

Nyasasaurus parringtoni is either the oldest dinosaur or the closest relative to dinosaurs that has been found to date.

Nyasasaurus parringtoni shows that dinosaurs likely appeared in the fossil record 10 million to 15 million years earlier than expected and this suggests that dinosaurs were not a dominant vertebrate group during their early evolution.

We can say, with confidence, that the lineage leading to dinosaurs evolved by the Anisian (early part of the Middle Triassic epoch, approximately 243 million years ago).

Fast growth, typical of most dinosaurs, is recorded in the bones of Nyasasaurus in the Middle Triassic.

Our analysis supports the hypothesis that dinosaurs first evolved in the southern portion of the supercontinent of Pangaea.

Name

Nyasasaurus parringtoni was named for one of the nearby great rift lakes of Africa – a combination of the lake name Nyasa with the term "saurus" for lizard – and for the person (Rex Parrington) that discovered the holotype (parringtoni). (Note that Lake Nyasa is today called Lake Malawi.)

Size

It is estimate that Nyasasaurus was 2-3 meters in length and about 0.5 to 1 meters tall at the hip (size of a Labrador retriever, but with a very long tail).

20 - 60 kilograms in weight (approximately 45-135 pounds).

Relationships

Nyasasaurus is either a dinosaur or the closest relative of dinosaurs discovered to date.

Nyasasaurus is more closely related to birds than to crocodylians.

Ornithodira is the lineage leading to birds; this group includes the common ancestor of pterosaurs, dinosaurs and all their descendants (including living and fossil birds).

Archosaurs are reptiles that are more closely related to crocodylians and birds than to lizards, snakes and turtles.

Anatomy

Nyasasaurus shares many features of dinosaurs including characteristics of the bones and rapid growth.

Nyasasaurus is only known from a few bones – specifically, only parts of the backbone (six vertebrae) and upper arm bone (right humerus).

Age and geography

Nyasasaurus is from the Anisian (Middle Triassic, approximately 243 million years old) and predates all other dinosaurs by approximately 10 million years.

Nyasasaurus fossils were excavated from the Manda beds of southwestern Tanzania.

The Triassic Period lasted from 252 million to 201 million years ago, and the following animals arose during this time: dinosaurs, crocodile relatives, mammals, pterosaurs, turtles, frogs and lizards.

During the Triassic, the continents were coalesced into a single landmass named Pangaea. At that time, what is now the country of Tanzania was located approximately 50 degrees south of the equator, much farther south than it is today.

The southern portion of Pangaea included what is now South America, Africa, Madagascar, Antarctica, Australia and India.

The presence of Nyasasaurus there is consistent with a dinosaurian origin in the southern hemisphere.

Discovery

Nyasasaurus was discovered in the early 1930s on a paleontological expedition to the Ruhuhu Valley of Southern Tanzania by Rex Parrington of the University of Cambridge.

Nyasasaurus fossils are housed at the Natural History Museum, London and the South African Museum in Cape Town, South Africa.

The rocks that produced Nyasasaurus have also yielded giant fossil amphibians; the fossil reptiles: rhynchosaurs, rauisuchians and small archosaurs; and the fossil synapsids (mammal relatives): cynodonts and dicynodonts.

Other

Alan Charig (deceased) studied Nyasasaurus for 50 years but was unable to publish his report on the animal before he died.

Our paper does not say…

That Nyasasaurus is a direct ancestor of all other dinosaurs.

That the ancestors of dinosaurs evolved in Tanzania.

Funding:

Natural History Museum collections improvement grant

National Science Foundation (EAR-1024036)

Related Stories

Dinosaurs might be older than previously thought

Mar 03, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Until now, paleontologists have generally believed that the closest relatives of dinosaurs possibly looked a little smaller in size, walked on two legs and were carnivorous. However, a research ...

Muscle reconstruction reveals how dinosaurs stood

Jun 21, 2012

(Phys.org) -- Much is known about the dinosaurs that walked on 4 legs like Stegosaurus and Triceratops, but their stance has been a topic of debate, until now. Scientists at the Natural History Museum have ...

Early carnivorous dinosaurs crossed continents

Dec 10, 2009

Did the first dinosaurs wander across continents or stay put where they first evolved? The first dinosaurs evolved 230 million years ago when the continents were assembled into one landmass called Pangea. ...

Recommended for you

Laser from plane discovers Roman goldmines in Spain

Nov 20, 2014

Las Médulas in León is considered to be the largest opencast goldmine of the Roman Empire, but the search for this metal extended many kilometres further south-east to the Erica river valley. Thanks to ...

Ancient New Zealand 'Dawn Whale' identified

Nov 18, 2014

University of Otago palaeontologists are rewriting the history of New Zealand's ancient whales by describing a previously unknown genus of fossil baleen whales and two species within it.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.