$430k settlement reached in Love Twitter lawsuit

Mar 04, 2011 By ANTHONY McCARTNEY , AP Entertainment Writer
In this Sept. 20, 2010 file photo, musician Courtney Love attends the premiere of 'Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps' at the Ziegfeld Theatre in New York. (AP Photo/Evan Agostini, File)

(AP) -- Courtney Love's 140 character Twitter rants against a fashion designer are costing her more than $430,000, an attorney says.

The singer has settled a lawsuit filed by Dawn Simorangkir, who sued the Hole frontwoman in March 2009 accusing her of making false statements about the designer and her past in a series of postings on the microblogging site Twitter and Love's blog.

The settlement was confirmed by Simorangkir's attorney, Bryan J. Freedman. The designer's label is called Boudoir Queen, and according to her lawsuit, she first came in contact with Love in 2008 and they met in February 2009 in Los Angeles to discuss some custom clothing.

The lawsuit contained several postings written under Love's former Twitter account, courtneylover79, that accused Simorangkir of theft and of having a criminal background.

The widow of grunge rocker Kurt Cobain, Love has gained a reputation on the microblogging service Twitter, posting occasionally profane and sometimes nonsensical messages on a variety of topics. Several posts have lashed out at attorneys and other individuals who have drawn the musician's ire, with her coming in rapid succession and using every bit of the site's 140 character maximum per post.

The case had been scheduled to go to trial in February, and was expected to be the first trial in which a jury decided whether a celebrity's Twitter posts could be considered libel.

Freedman confirmed that a settlement had been reached, and said Love's attorneys had hoped to keep it confidential.

"In order to show the world the comments were derogatory and completely illegal, it was imperative to my client to have the settlement be public," Freedman said.

The attorney said a public statement will be issued next week, but the nearly $430,000, plus interest, that Love is required to pay, reflects the seriousness of the case.

"Personally I think $430,000 is an appropriate way to say she's sorry," Freedman said.

The settlement was first reported by The Hollywood Reporter.

Love's attorney, Michael Niborski, did not immediately return an after-hours phone message.

Douglas Mirell, a First Amendment attorney and partner at the firm Loeb and Loeb, said it was not surprising that the case settled before reaching trial.

Earlier rulings in the case had established that Simorangkir only had to prove that Love was negligent in her postings, not that she knowingly knew them to be false. That increased the designer's likelihood of winning at trial, Mirell said.

He said despite many of the statements in question being posted on Twitter, the case wasn't unique.

"The laws controlling what is and isn't libelous are the same regardless of the medium in which the statements appear," Mirell said.

The libel laws that would govern similar cases have been established for decades, Mirell said. Although Love lost an early motion to dismiss the case, he said there was also the possibility she could win on appeal.

Love's attorneys had denied wrongdoing, saying it couldn't be proven that some of the statements were false, and that others were protected speech.

Freedman said Love had hoped to keep the terms of the settlement private and that a public statement will be issued next week.

Simorangkir's lawsuit claimed Love became angry with her after she completed five outfits for the singer and sent her a bill.

"Love mounted a malicious campaign to not only terrorize Simorangkir, but to ruin and destroy her reputation and livelihood," Freedman wrote in a May 2009 filing.

Some of the statements directed toward Simorangkir were posted on Love's blog on MySpace and in comments on the designer's merchandise on online stores.

The designer's lawsuit does not state how much she was seeking to recoup from Love, but states her postings damaged her business relationship with several clients.

Love's attorney disagrees, stating in a filing that Simorangkir's profile actually improved as a result of Love's rants.

"She simply did not suffer any financial harm due to any alleged actions undertaken by Ms. Love - in fact, her relationship with Ms. Love greatly enhanced her business image and profits," Niborski wrote in a brief filed in December.

Mirell said that if Love lost at trial, it might cause celebrities to become more cautious about how they tweet, but probably wouldn't have much impact legally.

Freedman predicted that will happen anyway once people see the amount Love is paying.

"People are getting in trouble for postings on an almost daily basis," he said.

He said stars do need to be cautious about how and what they post online, especially when they're talking about other. "When you start talking about someone other than yourself, you are beginning to get into dangerous territory," Mirell said.

Explore further: Bernanke forecasts gains from computer technology

not rated yet
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Teens in Love Do Less Crime

Jan 21, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Teenagers in love may be less likely to get mixed up in crime and substance abuse, according to new UC Davis research. But while romantic love seems to help keep teens law-abiding, casual sex can mean trouble.

Gender affects perceptions of infidelity

Oct 29, 2008

A new study in the Journal of Marital and Family Therapy explored how men and women perceive online and offline sexual and emotional infidelity. Results show that men felt sexual infidelity was more upsetting and women felt e ...

Lawsuit seeks arbitration in Microsoft case

Jul 06, 2010

(AP) -- Attorneys representing 23 states involved in a class-action lawsuit against Microsoft Corp. have filed a lawsuit over attorney fees against the Iowa lawyer who spearheaded a $179.5 million settlement with the software ...

Recommended for you

Bernanke forecasts gains from computer technology

8 hours ago

(AP)—Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke says pessimists who are forecasting that the economy will not reap sizable benefits from the computer revolution are likely to be proven wrong.

Yahoo Japan suspects 22 million IDs stolen

11 hours ago

Yahoo Japan Corp. has said it suspects up to 22 million user IDs may have been stolen during an unauthorised attempt to access the administrative system of its Yahoo! Japan portal.

US seizes Bitcoin operator accounts

19 hours ago

US authorities seized the accounts of a Bitcoin digital currency exchange operator, claiming it was functioning as an "unlicensed money service business," court documents showed Friday.

Italian police raid hackers who took on Vatican

May 17, 2013

Italian police on Friday arrested four alleged hackers believed to belong to the activist group Anonymous for attacking websites, including those of the Vatican and the parliament in Rome.

User comments : 0

More news stories

Morocco to harness the wind in energy hunt

Morocco is ploughing ahead with a programme to boost wind energy production, particularly in the southern Tarfaya region, where Africa's largest wind farm is set to open in 2014.

US seizes Bitcoin operator accounts

US authorities seized the accounts of a Bitcoin digital currency exchange operator, claiming it was functioning as an "unlicensed money service business," court documents showed Friday.

Galaxy's Ring of Fire

Johnny Cash may have preferred this galaxy's burning ring of fire to the one he sang about falling into in his popular song. The "starburst ring" seen at center in red and yellow hues is not the product of ...

US psychiatry gets makeover in new manual

The latest makeover to a massive psychiatric tome honored by some, reviled by others and even called the "Bible" of mental disorders is being released Saturday with a host of new changes.