This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:


peer-reviewed publication

trusted source

written by researcher(s)


Earth may have had all the elements needed for life—contrary to theories that they came from meteorites

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

For many years, scientists have predicted that many of the elements that are crucial ingredients for life, like sulfur and nitrogen, first came to Earth when asteroid-type objects carrying them crashed into our planet's surface.

But new research published by our team in Science Advances suggests that many of these elements, called volatiles, may have existed in the Earth from the beginning, while it formed into a planet.

Volatiles evaporate more readily than other elements. Common examples include carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen, though our research focused on a group called chalcogens. Sulfur, selenium and tellurium are all chalcogens.

Understanding how these volatile elements made it to Earth helps planetary scientists like us better understand Earth's geologic history, and it could teach us more about the habitability of terrestrial planets beyond Earth.

The popular "late veneer" theory predicts that Earth first formed from materials that are low in volatiles. After the formation of the Earth's core, the theory says, the planet got volatiles when volatile-rich bodies from the outer solar system hit the surface.

These objects brought around a half a percent of Earth's mass. If the late veneer theory is right, then most elements that make up life arrived on Earth sometime after the Earth's core had formed.

But our new research suggests that Earth had all its life-essential from the very beginning, during the planet's formation. These results challenge the late veneer theory and are consistent with another study tracing the origin of water on Earth.

Isotopes have a host of useful applications, from archaeology and medicine to planetary science.

To study the origin of volatiles in the Earth, we used a called first-principles calculation. This technique describes the behaviors of isotopes, which are atoms of an element that have varying numbers of neutrons. You can think of an element as a family—every atom has the same number of protons, but different isotope cousins have different numbers of neutrons.

Different isotopes behaved slightly differently during each stage of Earth's formation. And the isotopes left behind a signature after each formation stage that scientists can use as a kind of fingerprint to track where they were throughout Earth's formation.

First-principles calculation allowed us to calculate what isotope signatures we'd expect to see for different chalcogens, depending on how the Earth formed. We ran a few models and compared our isotope predictions for each model with the actual measurements of chalcogen isotopes on Earth.

We found that while many volatiles evaporated during Earth's formation, when it was hot and glowing, many more are still left over today. Our findings suggest that most of the volatiles on Earth now are likely left over from the early stage of Earth's formation.

While chalcogens are interesting to study, future research should look at other critical-for-life volatiles, like nitrogen. And more research into how these volatiles behave under extreme conditions could help us know more about how isotopes were behaving during each of the growth stages of Earth's formation.

We also hope to use this approach to see whether some exoplanets—planets beyond our solar system—could be habitable to life.

More information: Wenzhong Wang et al, Chalcogen isotopes reveal limited volatile contribution from late veneer to Earth, Science Advances (2023). DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.adh0670

Journal information: Science Advances

Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation: Earth may have had all the elements needed for life—contrary to theories that they came from meteorites (2023, December 7) retrieved 24 February 2024 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Meteorites reveal likely origin of Earth's volatile chemicals


Feedback to editors