In America, high-speed train travel is off track

February 15, 2019 by Delphine Touitou
A higher-speed Acela passenger train pulls out of Washington's Union Staton

California's suspension this week of a high-speed rail project underscores the up-hill battle the modern mode of transport faces in the United States—including myriad cultural, political and economic obstacles.

Long gone are the days of the 19th century gold rush, when Americans raced to build transcontinental rail links and conquer the nation's vast expanse.

Today modern rail transport is decidedly off track: it has weak political backing and Americans prefer driving or flying while other industries are opposed. Freight companies in particular are not keen to share rail lines with passenger trains.

"We have a Congress polluted by special interest money ... that has been working for years to stop/prevent any rail investment," said Andy Kunz, head of the US High Speed Rail Association, pointing to the oil, aviation and auto industries in particular.

While in a few short years China has spent hundreds of billions to build the world's largest high-speed network, the United States has yet to enter the high-speed rail era.

California's newly elected Governor Gavin Newsom said Tuesday he was indefinitely suspending plans to complete a 520-mile (830-kilomter) high-speed rail link between Los Angeles and San Francisco, saying it was too costly and taking too long.

"There's no doubt that our state's economy and quality of life depend on improving transportation," Newsom said in his first state of the state address.

But with costs up 20 percent (now at $77 billion) and the project's horizon already pushed back (completion is now slated for 2033, instead of 2029), Newsom said that for the moment only a segment linking the towns of Bakersfield and Merced would be completed in the heavily agricultural Central Valley.

Main foe: the American car

"The Central Valley was phase 1 all along ... Nothing has changed with that," said Kunz.

He said he expected California would ultimately have its own high-speed rail network once the Bakersfield-Merced link proved its viability and Americans got a taste of a mode of travel already so popular in Europe, China and Japan.

California is America's largest economy and its most populous state, with about 40 million inhabitants.

And in a 2008 referendum, voters approved partial financing of $10 billion for the Los Angeles-San Francisco route.

"California has been forced to cancel the massive bullet train project after having spent and wasted many billions of dollars," President Donald Trump tweeted Wednesday.

"Whole project is a 'green' disaster!"

But Kunz said California's rail plans were in the national interest, a means of easing congestion on roads and at airports and reducing pollution.

But in the United States, regional governments have hesitated to finance costly projects that sometimes run into legal hurdles.

"It is extremely difficult for the government to force individuals to sell their land," said Jacob Kirkegaard, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics.

While authorities may use "eminent domain," or the compulsory sale of private assets to complete infrastructure projects, US law places constraints on such powers and projects can wind up in protracted court battles.

Furthermore, the vast expanse of the United States means even high-speed is sometimes not practical, Kirkegaard added.

"It doesn't mean there are not areas which could benefit from it," he said.

But he noted that in an like the greater Los Angeles area—which is almost three times the size of Belgium—spending 90 minutes just to get to the train station could be prohibitive in itself.

Above all, Americans love their cars, emblems of personal freedom, something encouraged by the sustained recent drop in fuel prices.

"There is no doubt that the car, and its importance over many decades for infrastructure, is the problem for shifting towards more public and mass transportation with high speed trains," said Kirkegaard.

Explore further: California nixes plans for high-speed LA-SF rail line

Related Stories

California nixes plans for high-speed LA-SF rail line

February 12, 2019

California Governor Gavin Newsom announced on Tuesday that he was abandoning plans to build a high-speed rail line between Los Angeles and San Francisco, citing the high cost and the time it would take.

California bullet train staff recommend German operator

October 7, 2017

The agency overseeing California's bullet train project recommended Friday that a U.S. subsidiary of a German rail company design and operate a train segment from the Central Valley to Silicon Valley in its early stages.

California bullet train costs soar to $77B; opening delayed

March 9, 2018

The projected cost of California's bullet train between San Francisco and Los Angeles has jumped to $77 billion and the completion date has been pushed back four years to 2033, according to a business plan released Friday.

Siemens wins Canada train contract over Bombardier

December 13, 2018

German manufacturer Siemens saw off Canadian rival Bombardier to clinch a Can$989 million contract to produce 32 trains, Canada's state-subsidized passenger rail company announced Wednesday.

Obama vows to fast track high speed rail

April 16, 2009

US President Barack Obama Thursday called for a US high speed rail service to rival the express trains of France, Japan, Spain and China, highlighting a 13 billion dollar government funding boost.

Recommended for you

Physicists discover new class of pentaquarks

March 26, 2019

Tomasz Skwarnicki, professor of physics in the College of Arts and Sciences at Syracuse University, has uncovered new information about a class of particles called pentaquarks. His findings could lead to a new understanding ...

Study finds people who feed birds impact conservation

March 26, 2019

People in many parts of the world feed birds in their backyards, often due to a desire to help wildlife or to connect with nature. In the United States alone, over 57 million households in the feed backyard birds, spending ...

Matter waves and quantum splinters

March 25, 2019

Physicists in the United States, Austria and Brazil have shown that shaking ultracold Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) can cause them to either divide into uniform segments or shatter into unpredictable splinters, depending ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 15, 2019
Building high speed transportation is for countries that lead in technology and science, e.g., Germany, Japan, France.

For countries filled with psychopaths and hatred, build a wall around them, so they stay there and never leave!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.