Hold the phone: Huawei mistrust imperils China tech ambitions

December 11, 2018 by Dan Martin
Analysts say mounting concern over Huawei imperils its lead over the market

China's ambitious drive to dominate next-generation 5G technology faces a sudden reality check as fears spread that telecom companies like Huawei could be proxies for Beijing's intrusive security apparatus.

Fifth-generation mobile communications are the next milestone in the digital revolution, bringing near-instantaneous connectivity and vast data capacity.

They will enable the widespread adoption of futuristic technologies such as artificial intelligence and automated cars and factories—advances China is desperate to lead.

With 5G's rollout expected to gain pace in coming years, the race to dominate standards and control security and data traffic underpins much of the current high-tech rivalry between the United States and China, technology experts said.

Huawei's status as a leading world supplier of the backbone equipment for telecoms systems—mostly in developing markets—gives China an inside track.

But analysts said mounting concern over Huawei imperils that lead.

"This is a big threat because if Huawei loses access to lucrative Western markets, this will impact its ability to grow and finance R&D," said Paul Triolo, a global technology policy expert with risk consultancy Eurasia Group.

It also could hinder the deployment of 5G networks in China, which are "a key piece of China's overall effort to upgrade its industrial base", he added.

China observers say President Xi Jinping's more assertive global stance bears much of the blame for Huawei's troubles

The US defence establishment fears China's dominance of critical 5G infrastructure could enable it to disrupt American military communications or otherwise wage asymmetrical warfare in a confrontation.

Triolo warned of potentially disastrous fallout for China if US law-enforcement efforts—in the spotlight after the arrest of Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou in Canada—result in a ban on sales of US chips and other vital technology to Huawei.

"This could be catastrophic for China's tech ambitions, threatening (Huawei) itself, supporting industries, and future development," he said.

Burglar with a key

New Zealand recently joined Australia and the US in essentially barring use of Huawei equipment in domestic networks. Following Meng's arrest on December 1, similar sentiments have arisen from Tokyo to Brussels.

On Monday, Kyodo news agency reported Japan's top three would forego equipment from Huawei and another big Chinese player, ZTE.

US officials and lawmakers have long expressed concern that China could use its tech firms to steal trade secrets—accusations Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Lu Kang dismissed on Monday as "ridiculous."

"These people do not provide a single (piece of) evidence to show how Huawei affects their national security," Lu said.

Huawei's status as a leading world supplier of the backbone equipment for telecoms systems—mostly in developing markets—gives China an inside track

Distrust of Huawei stems in part from the background of founder Ren Zhengfei, a 74-year-old former People's Liberation Army engineer.

The US has already put the squeeze on ZTE, which faced insolvency earlier this year after the Trump administration temporarily banned American companies from selling it vital components.

Huawei has secured many leading 5G patents and supplied networking equipment for telecom systems around the world that will inevitably carry huge amounts of US data, putting that information at potential risk.

"One way to envision (the threat) is to imagine the person who built your house decides to burgle it," James Lewis, a technology policy expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, wrote in an analysis last week.

"They know the layout, power system, access points, (and) may have kept a key."

'We don't like it'

But US firms like Intel and Qualcomm produce the advanced chips critical for 5G, giving Washington huge sway over Huawei, which depends heavily on those technologies.

If the US cuts off Huawei's chip supply and further isolates the company, the blow "will be huge, bigger than ZTE", said Shi Yinhong, an expert on China-US relations at Beijing's Renmin University.

Fifth-generation mobile communications are the next milestone in the digital revolution, bringing near-instantaneous connectivity and vast data capacity
"If Huawei is hit hard, China will lose its 5G lead."

China observers say President Xi Jinping's more assertive global stance bears much of the blame for Huawei's troubles.

Late leader Deng Xiaoping famously observed that China's strategy should be to "hide your strength, bide your time", to avoid triggering a crippling foreign backlash.

But Xi has dumped that, accumulating one-man power, scrapping term limits and openly declaring China's ambition to become a high-tech power.

Beijing also passed a law in 2015 obliging its corporations to aid the government on matters of national security.

These moves have sparked alarm in the West, and the US has accused Chinese entities of massive cyber-attacks.

"One of the biggest criticisms of Xi in China is: 'did he take the stage too fast, did he try to push Chinese power too soon?'" said Christopher Balding, a China expert at Fulbright University in Ho Chi Minh City.

"He has behaved as near-totalitarian and is acting similarly internationally and people are saying 'we don't like it.'"

Explore further: Under fire Huawei agrees to UK security demands: report

Related Stories

Britain's BT scrubs China's Huawei from 4G network

December 5, 2018

Britain's largest mobile provider revealed on Wednesday it was stripping the equipment of China's telecoms giant Huawei from its core 4G cellular network after similar moves by the United States and New Zealand.

Top Huawei executive detained in Canada, angering China

December 6, 2018

A top executive and daughter of the founder of Chinese telecom giant Huawei has been arrested in Canada and faces extradition to the United States, officials said Thursday, angering Beijing days into a trade war truce with ...

US urging allies to shun Huawei: WSJ

November 23, 2018

The United States is trying to persuade wireless companies and internet providers in allied countries to shun equipment made by Chinese telecoms giant Huawei, citing cyber security risks, The Wall Street Journal reported ...

Recommended for you

Semimetals are high conductors

March 18, 2019

Researchers in China and at UC Davis have measured high conductivity in very thin layers of niobium arsenide, a type of material called a Weyl semimetal. The material has about three times the conductivity of copper at room ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

godfreek
5 / 5 (1) Dec 12, 2018
"fears spread that telecom companies like Huawei could be proxies for Beijing's intrusive security apparatus"?

How do fears spread? Is it a passive process, like tides rising with the moon's cycle? Or does someone create them and agents spread them?

Does anyone ever analyze these spreading fears, or do our media just, um, spread them?

Or are they synthetic fears, generated to obscure the fact that Huawei uses an encryption system that prevents the NSA from intercepting its communications?

A number of governments and secret services in the non-Western world (think Germany) have begun to equip themselves exclusively with Huawei materials, and are doing so to protect the confidentiality of their communications.

Convincing Cisco or some other U.S. company to leave back doors in their equipment is quite simple. One can always threaten the management or board of these companies with some tax investigation or over other shady activities. Not so easy with Huawei, though.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.