Leaders may create ineffective cultures because they are stuck in the past, study shows

September 26, 2018, University of Toronto

Where does culture come from? This basic question is one of the toughest for both researchers and practitioners to answer because culture is deeply entrenched in people's minds and taken for granted.

To date, researchers have proposed a functional view of —that culture is a response to the current needs within and outside a group, and thus the created culture enables the group to maintain high performance.

New research from the University of Toronto shows another cause of culture—a leader's past experience. The culture a leader experienced in the past shapes the culture of the group they go on to lead. As a result, the created culture may have little to do with because culture is driven by the leader's past experience.

Yeun Joon Kim, a doctoral candidate at the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management wrote the paper with Soo Min Toh, an associate professor of organizational behaviour at the University of Toronto Mississauga (UTM) with a cross appointment to the Rotman School, who is also Director of the Institute for Management & Innovation at UTM. They studied newly-formed sales groups at a manufacturing start-up as well as groups created in a behavioral laboratory. Leaders in both cases were new to the groups they joined.

The result showed that the new leaders created their groups' cultures based on their past cultural experience acquired in their former groups. The researchers termed this finding the cultural transfer perspective. That is, the new leaders tended to transfer the same cultures from their former groups to their current groups. Due to this tendency among the new leaders, the created cultures do not guarantee their effectiveness in enhancing group performance.

While leaders should create their cultures based on analysis of their actual circumstances, most are too busy to do that and fall back on familiar, old approaches, said Mr. Kim.

"Many companies talk about building effective cultures. But our research shows that leaders rely too much on their past experience. They believe that their past experience will continue to provide effective solutions in a new situation," said Mr. Kim. "So what we need to do is to disconnect them from their belief. They should be aware that their past experience in their former groups could actually be a liability in this new situation. To create effective cultures, leaders should look at the current situation, not the past."

The paper is forthcoming in Academy of Management Journal.

Explore further: Gender quotas work in 'tight' cultures, says new paper

Related Stories

Culture not a factor in management styles globally

December 19, 2016

Geert Hofstede's "Culture's Consequences" is one of the most influential management books of the 20th century. With well over 80,000 citations, Hofstede argues that 50 percent of managers' differences in their reactions to ...

Pre-op urine culture doesn't predict stone culture

August 16, 2016

(HealthDay)—For patients undergoing percutaneous stone removal, preoperative urine culture does not predict intraoperative stone culture results, according to a study published in the September issue of The Journal of Urology.

Recommended for you

Coffee-based colloids for direct solar absorption

March 22, 2019

Solar energy is one of the most promising resources to help reduce fossil fuel consumption and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions to power a sustainable future. Devices presently in use to convert solar energy into thermal ...

Paleontologists report world's biggest Tyrannosaurus rex

March 22, 2019

University of Alberta paleontologists have just reported the world's biggest Tyrannosaurus rex and the largest dinosaur skeleton ever found in Canada. The 13-metre-long T. rex, nicknamed "Scotty," lived in prehistoric Saskatchewan ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 27, 2018
What is culture?
When considering an individual, some genetic predisposition and interaction with the environment (conditioning) result in a personality (general disposition) which best serves them in the environment in which they have gained their experience (includes interaction with other people).

Culture as it impacts on an individual is the same process as above except comprising of the experience of other people, present and past, as averaged out over a population. In industrial setting culture differentiates into specific areas and formal institutions such as Law, Education, Religion, Health, Entertainment and so on but all manifestations of this process still exist including personality and the culture of friends and family.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.