Fossil fish with platypus-like snout shows that coral reefs have long been evolution hotspots

June 20, 2018 by Benedict King, The Conversation
Left: two key fossils of Brindabellaspis, the upper one showing the elongate snout and the lower one a more complete skull, but missing the most anterior part. Right: A skeletal reconstruction of the skull of Brindabellaspis, viewed from above. Credit: Ben King and Gavin Young, author provided

Coral reefs are well known today for their incredibly diverse and abundant marine life, including fish species ranging from delicate butterflyfish to huge humphead wrasse and ornate lionfish.

Published today, my new paper written with co-authors Gavin Young and John Long provides evidence that even 400 million years ago, life on coral reefs was already diverse. The research describes Brindabellaspis, a bizarre fossil fish with a platypus-like snout.

The fish was discovered at a fossil reef ecosystem bordering Lake Burrinjuck in New South Wales. The Burrinjuck reefs were built and inhabited by organisms very different from those around today.

A strange fish

Brindabellaspis is named after the nearby Brindabella ranges. Some detail is required to explain just how odd this fish was.

Brindabellaspis had eyes on the top of the head, facing upwards. In front of the eyes the skull was stretched into a long and broad snout. The inside of this snout was packed with a complex web of nerves and blood vessels. On the upper surface was a groove that housed part of the lateral line system, which detects water movement. However, this particular groove in Brindabellaspis is in a position that is unknown in any other vertebrate.

Even weirder was the creature's nose. The nostrils are on top of the head, and the nasal organs were housed in the corners of the eye sockets on either side.

The final surprise is the jaw of Brindabellaspis. Although not preserved, we can reconstruct the position of the jaws based on attachment points and the paths of nerves. We can tell that they must have been attached well forward. In fact, the entire jaw apparatus was probably in front of the eyes.

There is no exact modern equivalent to Brindabellaspis, but the combination of the upward-looking eyes and the long snout (which probably had a soft tip) suggests that it may have been a bottom-feeder. The snout, or "bill" may have been used to detect hidden prey.

Top: The Early Devonian fossil site on the shore of lake Burrinjuck. Bottom: Another Devonian reef, at Windjana Gorge in the Kimberley. These reefs were built by tabulate corals and stromatoporoid sponges, groups that have since gone extinct. Credit: Ben King
A thriving, ancient coral reef ecosystem

The coral reefs around Lake Burrinjuck are the oldest well-known tropical reef ecosystem. Despite its age (400 million years), the inhabitants can in no way be described as primitive or unspecialised. Brindabellaspis is just one example from a fauna that includes more than 70 known species: from a tiny bony fish to large possible filter-feeders.

It is clear that ancient reefs were inhabited by many species of ecologically specialised fish.

However, the Lake Burrinjuck fauna also highlights a major difference between at different points in time. Although coral reefs have always been diversity hotspots, the groups of animals making up the have changed drastically.

Brindabellaspis, for example, is a placoderm, a group of jawed vertebrate, often known as the "armoured fish." Placoderms were the dominant fish group in the Burrinjuck reefs, followed by lungfishes.

Another reef from a similar time period, the Gogo reef in the Kimberley region of Western Australia, is also dominated by placoderms and lungfishes.

Today the placoderms are completely extinct, while the lungfishes are reduced to just six living species worldwide (less than are known from the Burrinjuck and Gogo fossil sites alone) – all of which live in fresh water.

Modern reefs, on the other hand, are dominated by teleost fish, a group that first appeared around 230 million years ago, long after the Burrinjuck reef.

A life reconstruction of Brindabellaspis stensioi, an unusual placoderm fish from the 400-million-year old Burrinjuck reef in New South Wales, Australia. Credit: Jason Art, Shenzhen, Author provided
The changing face of reefs through time

A similar story applies to the reef-builders themselves. The Burrinjuck reef consisted mainly of a group of corals known as tabulate corals. The Gogo reef is largely built by stromatoporoids which are actually a type of sponge, not corals at all.

Tabulate corals and stromatoporoids were wiped out in the end-Permian mass extinction 250 million years ago. This may have been driven by enormous volcanism at the time, contributing carbon dioxide to the atmosphere, and leading to climate change and ocean acidification.

Reefs did not reappear for several million years after the end-Permain extinction. Eventually new reef-building organisms emerged, including the scleractinian corals, the familiar corals of today.

Another reef-building organism that thrived during the time of the dinosaurs was a strange type of bivalve mollusc called the rudists.

There seems to be a clear pattern. Reef ecosystems have always been diversity hotspots, but the groups of animals that build and inhabit them have changed, as extinctions wipe out old groups and new ones evolve.

Future reef ecosystems

It is well documented that face an uncertain future in the face of human induced climate change. If we do drive them to extinction, it is probable that reefs will eventually return in some form, although probably not for several million years.

It is far harder to predict what these future reef ecosystems will look like. The oldest known tropical ecosystem contained Brindabellaspis, an evolutionary oddity not quite like anything that has evolved before or since.

I expect that the reefs of the future will contain their own specialised and unique organisms.

Explore further: Degrading coral reefs bad news for commercial fishing

More information: New information on Brindabellaspis stensioi Young, 1980, highlights morphological disparity in Early Devonian placoderms, Royal Society Open Science, rsos.royalsocietypublishing.or … /10.1098/rsos.180094

Related Stories

Reef fish arrived in two waves

April 10, 2014

( —The world's reefs are hotbeds of biological diversity, including over 4,500 species of fish. A new study shows that the ancestors of these fish colonized reefs in two distinct waves, before and after the mass ...

Care about coral reefs? Protect the 'lawnmowers'

May 20, 2016

Coral reefs provide protection for islands, billions of dollars in economic value, and a dazzling array of biodiversity. Keeping reefs healthy is an important job, and one particular group of herbivorous fish and invertebrates ...

Algae fortifies coral reefs in past and present

August 28, 2017

The Great Barrier Reef, and most other large reefs around the world, owe their bulk in large part to a type of red algae that grows on corals and strengthens them. New research led by Anna Weiss, a Ph.D. candidate at The ...

Recommended for you

In colliding galaxies, a pipsqueak shines bright

February 20, 2019

In the nearby Whirlpool galaxy and its companion galaxy, M51b, two supermassive black holes heat up and devour surrounding material. These two monsters should be the most luminous X-ray sources in sight, but a new study using ...

Research reveals why the zebra got its stripes

February 20, 2019

Why do zebras have stripes? A study published in PLOS ONE today takes us another step closer to answering this puzzling question and to understanding how stripes actually work.

When does one of the central ideas in economics work?

February 20, 2019

The concept of equilibrium is one of the most central ideas in economics. It is one of the core assumptions in the vast majority of economic models, including models used by policymakers on issues ranging from monetary policy ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.