Scientists demonstrate new driver of extinction

April 11, 2018, Smithsonian
Fossil ostracods on a slide from the collection of the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History. A team of scientists drew on this collection to understand the role of sexual selection in extinction. Their findings were published in Nature on April 11. Credit: Gene Hunt, Smithsonian

The lengths that some males go to attract a mate can pay off in the short-term. But according to a new study from scientists at the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History (NMNH), extravagant investments in reproduction also have their costs.

By analyzing the fossils of thousands of ancient crustaceans, a team of scientists led by NMNH paleontologist Gene Hunt has found that devoting a lot of energy to the competition for mates may compromise species' resilience to change and increase their risk of extinction. Hunt, NMNH postdoctoral fellow M. João Fernandes Martins, and collaborators at the College of William and Mary and the University of Southern Mississippi reported their findings April 11, 2018, in the journal Nature.

Many present-day species offer showy examples of —characteristic differences between and females that usually help males attract and secure mates. The need to pass genes to future generations is so critical that in some species, males put a lot of energy into generating these sex-specific features—a peacock's elaborate tail feathers or an elephant seal's massive, territory-defending body size, for example.

Hunt says some scientists have proposed that the energy animals devote to developing these traits may limit the resources they have available for survival, particularly when something in their environment changes. That would put species with strong sexual dimorphism at greater risk of extinction. But it's been difficult to determine how sexual dimorphism has impacted species survival because in most cases, scientists can't tell from a fossil whether an animal was male or female.

Female (top) and male (below) of the ostracod Cypideis salebrosa. Note the male shell is more elongated than that of the female. This is thought to reflect the need to accommodate the large male genitalia (highlighted in blue). A team of researchers studied this specimen and others in the collections of the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History to better understand the role of sexual selection in extinction. Their findings were published in Nature on April 11. Credit: M. João Fernandes Martins, Smithsonian

Ostracods, tiny crustaceans that have been on the planet for nearly 500 million years, are an exception. The shrimp-like creatures, which live inside hinged shells smaller than a poppy seed, have distinctive sex-specific shapes that are preserved in the fossil record. Animals with elongated bodies and shells are males, whereas females are usually smaller with a squatter shape. An elongated shell shape accommodates the male's large sex organs—with larger organs presumably producing more sperm and improving individuals' opportunities for reproductive success, Hunt explains.

Hunt and his colleagues drew on large collections of ostracod fossils from the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History, the University of Southern Mississippi, and Louisiana State University, as well as additional fossils they collected themselves, to investigate whether species in which this male/female distinction was most prominent had been more vulnerable than others to changes in their environments.

The team pored over thousands of the specimens, noting when different species had lived based on the geological layer from which they were collected and assessing the shapes and sizes of more than 6,000 individuals. Their final analysis included 93 different species of ostracods that lived during the late Cretaceous period, between about 85 and 65 million years ago.

Dr. Gene Hunt, curator of Ostracoda for the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History, with a deep-sea ostracode specimen under the microscope. Hunt and a team of researchers drew on the museum's ostracode collection to understand the role of sexual selection in extinction. Their findings were published in Nature on April 11. Credit: Adrian James Testa, Smithsonian

Some species appeared over and over again in the fossil collections, and the team found that some had lived throughout almost the entire 20-million-year span. Others lasted just a few hundred thousand years. And the size and shape of the males did appear to have been a significant factor in species' longevity. "We showed that when males are larger and more elongated than the females, those species tend to not last as long in the . They have a higher risk of extinction," Hunt says.

If the same holds true for other species, Hunt says, conservation biologists may want to take sexual dimorphism into account when assessing species' vulnerability to current environmental threats. "If devoting so much energy to reproduction made it harder for species in the past to adapt to changing circumstances, perhaps that same should apply to we're concerned about conserving in the present day," he says.

Explore further: Male or female? Scientists challenge evidence of sex differences among dinosaurs

More information: High male sexual investment as a driver of extinction in fossil ostracodes, Nature (2018). nature.com/articles/doi:10.1038/s41586-018-0020-7

Related Stories

Can we easily distinguish male and female protoceratops?

May 27, 2015

Anatomical and behavioral differences distinguish males and females in many extant and extinct animals. For instance, male peacocks have a large and flashy tail, whereas females are smaller and less brightly colored. Male ...

Competitive males are a blessing and a curse, study reveals

November 14, 2016

Showy ornaments used by the male of the species in competition for mates, such as the long tail of a peacock or shaggy mane of a lion, could indicate a species' risk of decline in a changing climate, according to a new study ...

Biologist Shows Female Birds of a Feather Compete Together

December 15, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- With its flamboyantly decorated plumage, the peacock is a classic example of how males among many bird species are more visually eye-catching than their female partners. But new research, led by Columbia ...

In spiders, size matters: Small males are more often meals

September 10, 2008

Female spiders are voracious predators and consume a wide range of prey, which sometimes includes their mates. A number of hypotheses have been proposed for why females eat males before or after mating. Researchers Shawn ...

Stegosaurus plates may have differed between male, female

April 22, 2015

Stegosaurus, a large, herbivorous dinosaur with two staggered rows of bony plates along its back and two pairs of spikes at the end of its tail, lived roughly 150 million years ago during the Late Jurassic in the western ...

Recommended for you

Space-inspired speed breeding for crop improvement

November 16, 2018

Technology first used by NASA to grow plants extra-terrestrially is fast tracking improvements in a range of crops. Scientists at John Innes Centre and the University of Queensland have improved the technique, known as speed ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.