Water safety checks dangerously underestimate pathogen levels, study suggests

April 16, 2018 by Hayley Jarvis, Brunel University London, Brunel University
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Deadly bacteria lurking in drinking water storage tanks could be missed by standard health and safety tests, scientists have warned in a new report.

Cold water storage tanks supplying public drinking water are regularly checked for harmful pathogenic bacteria such as Legionnaires' disease and E.coli.

However, microbiological analysis by researchers from Brunel University London found that samples taken as standard from the top of the tank are 40% less likely to raise a red flag than samples taken from the opposite end.

One in five samples taken from the top of the tank didn't trigger the urgent action that samples from the bottom of the same tank showed was needed.

"These results call into question the reliability of present measures used to protect the public from waterborne pathogenic diseases, including Legionella," said Aji Peter, a Ph.D. student from Brunel's Institute of Environment, Health and Societies, who carried out the research.

Cold water storage tanks are often found on the roofs or in the basements of public buildings such as schools and hospitals, and can be a source of repeated bacterial contamination.

Current safety regulations require a of water be taken from under the ball valve at the top of the tank for regular microbiological monitoring, although scientists are now calling for the standard safety tests to be changed to look at samples taken from the far end of the tank, where is likely to be warmer and hold more bacteria-feeding sediment.

"Given the disparity between measurements taken at different ends of the tanks, monitoring at the far end would provide a much more accurate indication of microbiological contamination. This would allow appropriate precautions to be taken to protect the public from waterborne pathogenic diseases, including Legionnaires' disease," said Mr Peter.

Fact box

· Legionnaires' affects about 500 people a year in England alone and in about one in 10 cases, it's fatal.
· It is a severe form of pneumonia that causes lung inflammation
· It is caused by a bacterium called Legionella.
· It can cause life-threatening complications, including respiratory failure, kidney failure and septic shock

Explore further: Clean tanks reduce microbial risk

More information: Aji Peter et al. Present-day monitoring underestimates the risk of exposure to pathogenic bacteria from cold water storage tanks, PLOS ONE (2018). DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0195635

Related Stories

Clean tanks reduce microbial risk

March 27, 2018

Simple measures such as regular maintenance of backyard tanks and rooftops can help reduce microbial contamination of household rainwater, Flinders University experts say.

Hong Kong probes deadly bug at government offices

January 4, 2012

Hong Kong officials said Wednesday the discovery of a bacteria that cause Legionnaires' disease at the new government complex was "under control", while it was probing the source of the deadly bug.

Zinc link in safer roof catchment rain

July 26, 2017

A new study of Wellington roof catchment rainwater has found that zinc in galvanised steel roofs can kill some bugs. But households concerned about the safety of emergency roof catchment rainwater in the event of an earthquake ...

Recommended for you

Thawing permafrost microbiomes fuel climate change

July 16, 2018

A University of Queensland-led international study could lead to more accurate predictions or the rate of global warming from greenhouse gas emissions produced by thawing permafrost in the next 100 years.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.