Mystery of electric fish genus solved, new species identified

June 1, 2017 by Krishna Ramanujan, Cornell University
Mystery of electric fish genus solved, new species identified
Comparisons of Paramormyrops ntotom and P. sphekodes specimens, showing how the body measurements and EOD waveforms differ. P. sphekodes has a slightly smaller body, shorter head and shorter EOD than P. ntotom. Credit: John Sullivan/Provided

Solving a 140-year old taxonomic puzzle, Cornell researchers have identified and described a new species of electric fish from the Ogooué River in Gabon, Africa.

The , named Paramormyrops ntotom, belongs to the family Mormyridae, and is part of a group called a " flock" – closely related species that are similar in appearance and all live in the same region.

The researchers, who published their results May 2017 in the Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society, identified the new species through anatomical measurements, genetics and analyses of the weak electric pulse the fish emit called an electric organ discharge, or EOD. These data helped distinguished P. ntotom from another previously described fish that belongs to the same genus and species flock, called Paramormyrops sphekodes, which was first described in 1879.

A French explorer first identified P. sphekodes after collecting two specimens in 1877 near the village of Doumé, which lies along the Ogooué River. Those specimens, which serve as a reference for the species, are preserved in the National Museum of Natural History in Paris, but are too degraded to properly analyze. Because other related species in the genus Paramormyrops so closely resembled P. sphekodes, they have been incorrectly classified as P. sphekodes since the late 1800s.

"P. sphekodes, described in 1879, was the first of what we now know are many species in this genus," said John Sullivan, a co-author on the paper and curatorial affiliate at the Cornell Museum of Vertebrates. "It being the first, when people collected other ones later they just applied the P. sphekodes name to those specimens, but a lot of them clearly are not the same thing. It was never very clear how to distinguish this one from the others. In this study, we do that for the first time."

In order to solve the mystery, Sullivan returned to the original site (called a type locality) near Doumé where the reference or type-specimens for P. sphekodes were caught in the 1800s. There, and in another location along the Ogooué River 45 kilometers away, Sullivan used fish traps to catch new specimens during two expeditions, in 2011 and another in 2014 sponsored by The Nature Conservancy.

Among the Paramormyrops fish Sullivan collected, one variety had a short EOD, while the other had a longer one, a difference revealed by an amplifier with two electrodes placed in the water.

From these fresh samples, Sullivan and his colleagues – co-author Carl Hopkins, professor emeritus of neurobiology and behavior, and first author Madeline Rich, an undergraduate in Hopkins' lab – used modern techniques to study the fish.

Rich made anatomical measurements from the bodies and also from X-rays of the newly caught fish at the Cornell University Museum of Vertebrates. The measurements showed that there were subtle differences in mean body size and head proportions. At the Fuller Evolutionary Biology Lab in the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Rich also obtained DNA sequences of the fish that offered evidence that the two fish varieties do not interbreed.

By comparing head measurements with the 1879 reference specimens, the researchers were able to distinguish P. sphekodes – which had a shorter EOD and a smaller body and shorter head – from a new species, P. ntotom (ntotom is a word from the Fang language of Gabon that means "mormyrid fish").

"This is a great example of bringing diverse kinds of data together to solve a difficult taxonomic question," said Hopkins. "It really demonstrates the usefulness of revisiting type localities and recording EODs for mormyrid fish taxonomy."

They were able to re-describe P. sphekodes, while also creating a framework for distinguishing species belonging to the Paramormyrops genus.

More than 200 known species of mormyrid fish live in fresh waters across Africa, and their EODs are unique to each species. The use them to communicate species identity, as well as sex identity in some species where males and females have different EODs. The pulses also help them electrolocate, or navigate, as special tail sensors pick up distortions caused by nearby objects within their self-produced electric fields.

Explore further: 'Hidden fish' genus described for two new weakly electric mormyrid species from Gabon

More information: Madeline Rich et al. Rediscovery and description of Paramormyrops sphekodes (Sauvage, 1879) and a new cryptic Paramormyrops (Mormyridae: Osteoglossiformes) from the Ogooué River of Gabon using morphometrics, DNA sequencing and electrophysiology, Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society (2017). DOI: 10.1093/zoolinnean/zlw004

Related Stories

How have European freshwater fish species changed over time?

May 17, 2017

Over time, humans have contributed to the loss of native species and have introduced non-native species throughout Europe. A new analysis shows how European freshwater fish have changed profoundly since 1840. At the continental ...

Exploring evolution via electric fish hybrid zone

July 21, 2015

Michigan State University is using a $700,000 National Science Foundation grant to study how electric fish signals evolve, research that could offer insights into the evolution of new species.

Recommended for you

Did last ice age affect breastfeeding in Native Americans?

April 23, 2018

The critical role that breast feeding plays in infant survival may have led, during the last ice age, to a common genetic mutation in East Asians and Native Americans that also, surprisingly, affects the shape of their teeth.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.