Belief in free will predicts criminal punishment support, disapproval of unethical actions

Credit: CC0 Public Domain

In countries with transparent governments and low levels of corruption, the belief in free will—that is, believing that people's outcomes are tied to choices and personal responsibility—predicts someone's intolerance of unethical behavior along with a greater desire to see criminals harshly punished for their actions.

For residents of countries with weak governance or corrupt leaders, free will beliefs did not explain people's views on the acceptability of —yet free will beliefs still predicted wanting to see criminals punished.

"Your country's governance makes a difference in whether your beliefs about free will get applied to your views of unethical ," says Kathleen Vohs, the Distinguished McKnight University Professor and Land O'Lakes Chair in Marketing at the University of Minnesota's Carlson School of Management and co-author of the study.

Researchers at the University of Minnesota, Arizona State University, and Ghent University used data from the World Values Survey to analyze more than 65,000 residents in 46 countries. Their findings provide a comprehensive look at the influence of free will around the world and help explain differing moral attitudes and judgments around the world.

This global analysis suggests that for in free will to influence people's attitudes toward unethical actions, there needs to be an environment of honest and open governance. When people live in countries that do not support individual rights and where public officials are dishonest and self-interested, people's free will beliefs inform their desire to see criminals punished. But when it comes to whether behaving unethically is justifiable, free will beliefs are irrelevant.

"Free Will Beliefs Predict Attitudes toward Unethical Behavior and Criminal Punishment: A Global Analysis" is authored by Nathan D. Martin, Davide Rigoni, and Kathleen D. Vohs and published in the journal PNAS.

Explore further

Destined to cheat? New research finds free will can keep us honest

More information: Nathan D. Martin el al., "Free will beliefs predict attitudes toward unethical behavior and criminal punishment," PNAS (2017).
Citation: Belief in free will predicts criminal punishment support, disapproval of unethical actions (2017, June 26) retrieved 26 May 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jun 27, 2017
How about the idea that will is free, but not entirely yours?

The relationship between justice and free will is in the idea that a person makes a conscious and reasoned choice to do evil - not just by ignorance or temporary insanity, but committing to go against what is considered right.

However, the reasons why the person would do that are again subject to free will, and the question arises, can you freely choose to be evil? How do you will to will? Where does it come from?

The physical freedom of will always reduces down to some sort of coin flip or a throw of dice - a random event within the bounds of conservation of energy etc. - because it is not meaningful to say a choice is free if it was caused by something else, and the only thing that is meaningfully causeless is a random event. Therefore will being free cannot be in one's personal control, and as long as we consider the person to be only their higher brain functions and reasoning it cannot be their own will.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more