Scientists solve 400-year-old mystery of Prince Rupert's drops

May 9, 2017 by Lisa Zyga feature
Prince Rupert’s drop.

(Phys.org)—Researchers have finally answered a question that has stumped scientists since the early 1600s: Why are the heads of tadpole-shaped pieces of glass called "Prince Rupert's drops" so strong?

In the 17th century, Prince Rupert from Germany brought some of these drops to England's King Charles II, who was intrigued by their unusual properties. While the head of the drop is so strong that it can withstand the impact of a hammer, the tail is so fragile that bending it with your fingers will not only break the tail, but cause the entire droplet to instantly disintegrate into a fine powder.

Prince Rupert's drops are easily made by dropping red hot blobs of molten glass into water. Although researchers have tried to understand what causes the unusual properties of these drops for many years, it was not until recently that modern technology has allowed researchers to thoroughly investigate them.

In 1994, S. Chandrasekar at Purdue University and M. M. Chaudhri at the University of Cambridge used high-speed framing photography to observe the drop-shattering process. From their experiments, they concluded that the surface of each drop experiences highly compressive stresses, while the interior experiences high tension forces. So the drop is in a state of unstable equilibrium, which can be easily disturbed by breaking the tail.

One open question, however, is how the stresses are distributed throughout a Prince Rupert's drop. Understanding the stress distribution would help to more fully explain why the heads of these drops are so strong.

To do this, Chandrasekar and Chaudhri began collaborating with Hillar Aben, a professor at Tallinn University of Technology in Estonia. Aben specializes in determining residual stresses in transparent three-dimensional objects, such as Prince Rupert's drops.

In the new study published in Applied Physics Letters, Aben, Chandrasekar, Chaudhri, and their coauthors have investigated the stress distribution in Prince Rupert's drops using a transmission polariscope, which is a type of microscope that measures the birefringence in an axi-symmetrical transparent object, such as a Prince Rupert's drop.

In their experiments, the researchers suspended a Prince Rupert's drop in a clear liquid, and then illuminated the drop with a red LED. Using the polariscope, the researchers measured the optical retardation of the light as it traveled through the glass drop, and then used the data to construct the throughout the entire drop.

Fringes throughout a Prince Rupert’s drop indicate residual stresses. Credit: Aben et al. ©2017 American Institute of Physics

The results showed that the heads of the drops have a much higher surface compressive stress than previously thought—up to 700 megapascals, which is nearly 7,000 times atmospheric pressure. This surface compressive layer is also thin, about 10% of the diameter of the head of a drop.

As the researchers explain, these values give the droplet heads a very high fracture strength. In order to break a droplet, it's necessary to create a crack that enters the interior tension zone in the drop. Since cracks on the surface tend to grow parallel to the surface, they cannot enter the tension zone. Instead, the easiest way to break a drop is to disturb the tail, since a disturbance in this location allows cracks to enter the tension zone.

Overall, the researchers believe that the results finally explain the great strength of Prince Rupert's .

"The work has fully explained why the head of a drop is so strong," Chaudhri told Phys.org. "I believe we have now solved most of the main aspects of this area. However, new questions may emerge unexpectedly."

Explore further: Why water splashes—new theory reveals secrets

More information: H. Aben et al. "On the extraordinary strength of Prince Rupert's drops." Applied Physics Letters. DOI: 10.1063/1.4971339

Related Stories

The dynamic surface tension of water

April 3, 2017

The surface tension of a liquid is a measure of the cohesive forces that hold the molecules together. It is responsible for a water drop assuming a spherical shape and for the effects of surfactants to produce bubbles and ...

Mathematicians defy gravity

October 3, 2007

Droplets of liquid have been shown to travel uphill, rather than sliding down as expected, when the surface they are on is vigorously shaken up and down.

Drop-to-drop variation seen with fingerprick blood

February 29, 2016

(HealthDay)—There is drop-to-drop variation in blood component measures from fingerprick blood that is greater than variation in drops of venous blood, according to a study published recently in the American Journal of ...

Measuring speed in flying inkjet drops

March 13, 2014

Physicists from the FOM workgroup Physics of Fluids (MESA+) at the University of Twente and from Océ-Technologies have developed a method to measure detailed speed data in flying inkjet drops. Their research was recently ...

Recommended for you

New technique promises tunable laser devices

September 19, 2017

Whispering gallery mode (WGM) resonators are used to make tiny micro-lasers, sensors, switches, routers and other devices. These tiny structures rely on a phenomenon similar to an effect observed in circular galleries, such ...

Nonlinear physics bridges thoughts to sounds in birdsong

September 19, 2017

The beautiful sound of birdsongs emerging from the trees is a wonderful example of how much nature can still teach us, even as much about their origins are still mysterious to us. About 40 percent of bird species learn to ...

4 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Homebrook
5 / 5 (4) May 09, 2017
The authors of the new article may have advanced the understanding of Prince Rupert's drops, but it isn't like most of their properties had not already been unraveled by 1920. The article implies that they just figured them all out, which isn't true. The title, "Scientists solve 400-year-old mystery of Prince Rupert's drops," is hyperbolic. See http://rsta.royal...-593/163
johnqsmith
5 / 5 (3) May 09, 2017
Hot, molten glass shrinks when cooled, though cannot support tensile nor compressive stresses. When it cools and solidifies, it can support stresses. Thus, when molten glass enters water, its outside surface cools rapidly, shrinks and solidifies. This shrinkage does not stress the inner glass portions that have not yet solidified. The solidification wave travels inward, and the center region solidifies last. As the inner portions cool further beyond solidification, shrinkage continues and this shrinkage pulls the previously solidified outer layer into compression, while the inner layers experience tension. With all the glass cooled, the outer layers are compression and the inner core is in tension. Glass is much stronger in compression than in tension, which explains why the inner layers are susceptible to additional tension and are the Achilles heel. It would be very difficult to put the outer layer in tension, because of the geometry and the fact that it is in compression.
Ojorf
5 / 5 (1) May 16, 2017
Nicely put johnqsmith, yes that is the way, as Homebrook said, that the strength of the head has been explained for many, many years, but the data to be more exact has been lacking.
The title is a bit misleading and the authors admit that this might not be the last word on the subject.
Dingbone
May 16, 2017
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.