Birds hit by cars are, well, bird-brained

March 29, 2017 by Marlowe Hood
Bird species with a larger brain have a tendency to adapt better to the dangers of vehicle traffic, according to a new study

What's the difference between birds that get killed by cars, and those that don't?

The dead ones tend to have smaller brains, scientists who performed 3,521 avian autopsies said Wednesday.

What might be called the "bird brain rule" applies to different species, depending on the ratio of grey matter to body mass, they reported in the journal Royal Society Open Science.

Crows, for example, have big brains relative to their size, and have shown a remarkable knack for navigating oncoming traffic.

While picking at road kill on Florida highways, earlier research showed, the scavengers learned to ignore cars and trucks whizzing by them within inches, but would fly away just in time when threatened by a vehicle in their lane.

"I don't know if we can say they are 'smarter,' but they do exhibit cognitive behaviour that makes them likely to survive," lead author Anders Pape Moller, an evolutionary biologist at the French National Centre for Scientific Research, told AFP.

Pigeons, by contrast, appear to be less adept at avoiding collisions, a deficiency visible in compressed form on most big-city streets.

Not coincidentally, they have teeny-weeny brains.

More surprisingly, the relation between size and traffic accidents also holds within the same species, the study found.

"Common European blackbirds, house sparrows and robins all show this difference in individuals that were hit by cars, and those that were not," Moller said by phone.

Undamaged brains from birds killed in accidents—weighed to within a hundredth of a gramme—were consistently smaller, he said.

Grim tally

At the same time, other organs—liver, heart and lungs—all had the same mass.

In total, the researchers examined 251 different species.

The finding raises the question of whether certain species, and certain populations within species, have evolved over the space of dozens of generations such that birds with car-dodging abilities have become more common.

Moller is sceptical.

Recent research has shown that evolutionary changes in many animals—fish and insects, in particular—are occurring in response to climate change and human encroachment on habitat far more quickly that scientists imagined possible.

But given that fast-moving cars have only been on the roads for less than a century, it is unlikely that birds have adapted—as a level—that fast.

"The other problem is that total mortality due to traffic is not big enough to cause evolutionary change," Moller said.

It would take a very high death toll, in other words, to exert a strong influence on the course of evolution.

Having said that, a lot of birds get killed by moving vehicles.

The State of the Birds annual report estimated in 2014 that 200 million birds perish on the road every year in the United States alone.

Estimates for Europe are lower, but worldwide the grim tally is certainly in the hundreds of millions.

But there are an estimated 300 billion birds in the world, so the death toll is still only a fraction of one percent.

There is one threat, however, to which our feathered friends almost certainly have evolved to avoid, though with limited success.

The same report estimates that 2.4 billion fall victim in cats every hear in the United States.

Explore further: Birds with bigger brains found to be less likely to get shot

More information: Brain size in birds is related to traffic accidents, Royal Society Open Science, rsos.royalsocietypublishing.or … /10.1098/rsos.161040

Related Stories

Birds with bigger brains found to be less likely to get shot

November 2, 2016

(—A pair of researchers has found that birds with bigger brains are less likely to get shot by hunters than birds with smaller brains. In their paper published in the journal Biology Letters, Anders Pape Møller, ...

Bigger brains outsmart harsh climates

December 22, 2016

It helps to have a larger brain if you're living in an extreme climate, according to a study of birds published in Nature Communications. The research suggests that birds have evolved larger brains to cope in harsh environments ...

Is Australia the birthplace of birds nests?

February 1, 2017

The most common birds nests found today had their birthplace in Australia, and these nests may be key to many of our birds' success, according to new research from Macquarie University, released today.

Experience with vehicles does not help birds avoid collisions

September 19, 2016

Researchers suspected that experience with passing vehicles may cause birds to adjust their avoidance responses-specifically, to increase their flight initiation distances-to keep from being hit. Instead, though, they recently ...

Big-brained birds survive better in nature

January 10, 2007

Birds with brains that are large in relation to their body size have a lower mortality rate than those with smaller brains, according to new research published in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological ...

Recommended for you

A new DNA editing toolkit for the alga Nannochloropsis

May 22, 2018

Eric Poliner and a team of MSU scientists in the Farre and Benning labs have released a new genetic engineering toolkit for the alga Nannochloropsis. The alga is of interest for the production of biofuels and other oil-based ...

Humans account for little next to plants, worms, bugs

May 21, 2018

When you weigh all life on Earth, billions of humans don't amount to much compared to trees, earthworms or even viruses. But we really know how to throw what little weight we have around, according to a first-of-its-kind ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) Mar 29, 2017
The cat statistics are b.s. What looks like a large number of cat kills are actually window kills or stunnings after which a lucky cat finds an immobilized meal or toy.
not rated yet Mar 29, 2017
Not always so-- Scavengers often push their luck & skill just too far.

FWIW, one of our cats found catching song-birds so easy, he'd ignore them and sit beneath the feeder until a raptor swooped. Then he'd jump and knock down the raptor. The song-birds had a local population boom...
5 / 5 (3) Mar 30, 2017
The cat statistics are b.s. What looks like a large number of cat kills are actually window kills or stunnings after which a lucky cat finds an immobilized meal or toy.

Since you cite no evidence to back up your statement, I suggest you also read "Cats kill more than one billion birds each year" in Science News, January 29, 2014 (https://www.scien...h-year), or "The impact of free-ranging domestic cats on wildlife of the United States" in Nature Communications, January 29, 2013 (http://www.nature...mms2380) and then rethink your claim.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.