Simple rule explains complex group swimming patterns

February 13, 2017, Champalimaud Centre for the Unknown
A simple rule gives rise to coordinated swimming in zebra-fish as they become adults. Credit: Shira Lottem

Watching the smooth movement generated by hundreds of fish as they swim in unison is truly mesmerising. But it's not only its sheer beauty that makes it so hard to look away, for scientists, it's also the fact that its emergence is so difficult to explain. In an article published today (February 13, 2017) in the scientific journal PNAS, researchers from Champalimaud Centre for the Unknown (CCU), in Lisbon, present a surprisingly simple rule that explains how complex patterns of collective movement emerge in zebrafish as they develop from recently hatched larvae into adults.

"There are many models that try to explain how collective swimming emerges in groups of fish, but many of them fall short of the mark because of two main challenges." Says Gonzalo de Polavieja, principal investigator of the Collective Behaviour lab at CCU. "The first is obtaining a rich dataset where you can reliably track each individual in the group. This is quite difficult since fish move in three dimensions and are physically very similar. The more animals you want to observe at the same time, the harder it becomes. And the second, which is even more challenging, is constructing a model that doesn't only mimic the group behaviour, but actually captures the rules that the animals themselves use."

In this study, together with Robert Hinz, a doctoral student in the lab, de Polavieja applied an original approach to overcome these challenges. "Most studies focus on adult animals, where patterns of collective movement are the most striking. Instead, we decided to observe how the emergence of collective swimming happens as the animal develops. Though young zebrafish do not swim together often, they gradually develop shoaling and schooling behaviour during the first month of development, eventually forming large schools as adults. By following the fish from a young age, we were able to obtain a rich dataset that led us to discover a strong behavioural rule."

What is the rule that gives rise to coordinated swimming in fish? In an article published in the scientific journal PNAS, researchers present a surprisingly simple rule that explains how this behavior emerges as zebrafish mature from larvae to adults. Robert Hinz and Gonzalo de Polavieja. (2017). Credit: Gonzalo de Polavieja

Using this extensive dataset and a sophisticated tracking method called idTracker, which was previously developed by this lab, the researchers tested a series of rules that might explain the behaviour, but to their surprise, the simplest rule was the one that prevailed - the rule of random attraction. "Theoretically, fish could use many different strategies to decide where to swim. They could choose swimming towards the fish closest to them, or the furthest, or towards a higher density of fish, we tested many options... But no, it turns out that they literally choose at random which fish to follow."

If the fish choose at random, why is it that young fish don't form schools, while the adults do? "We discovered that group patterns become more prominent in adults because, when compared with their younger selves, they spend less time swimming independently and more time following other fish." de Polavieja explains. "Though the rule of random attraction remains the same throughout development, younger fish spend only 1% of the time applying it. As they develop, that amount of time grows exponentially until it reaches 50% in the adult. Using this simple rule, adult animals are more likely to move towards high density of fish without lumping and group movement emerges."

According to de Polavieja, the model they developed doesn't only explains how the fish form collective movement, it also overcomes the second challenge, as it may be capturing the actual rule that the animals themselves are following. "It's easy to produce rules that make your models look like 'the real thing'. It's not cheating, but researchers often have to introduce extra parameters to their models so that they successfully mimic the data. The winner of the modeling world, however, is the model that has the fewest parameters but still successfully captures the data. The we found, though mathematically complex, has predictions that are independent of any fixed parameters, but only on the variables of the experiment, such as the number of in the tank, which makes it very strong indeed." He concludes.

Explore further: Fish follow the rules to school

More information: Ontogeny of collective behavior reveals a simple attraction rule, PNAS, www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1616926114

Related Stories

Fish follow the rules to school

November 7, 2011

The rules of school are simple: it is all about watching the kid nearest to you and making sure you do what they do. Researchers at the mathematics department at Uppsala University, together with biologists at Sydney University ...

Fish found to communicate with one another using urine

February 2, 2017

(Phys.org)—A trio of researchers with the University of Bern in Switzerland has found that at least one species of fish communicates with others of its kind using chemicals in its urine. In their paper published in the ...

Fish bond when they eat the same food

March 22, 2016

Similar-smelling chemical cues could explain why some animals choose to live together with other species, according to new research from scientists at the University of Lincoln, UK. 

Recommended for you

Breakthrough test screens for all known bacterial infections

October 23, 2018

Scientists at the Center for Infection and Immunity (CII) in the Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health have developed the first diagnostic platform that can simultaneously screen for all known human pathogenic ...

New technique promises more accurate genomes

October 23, 2018

University of Adelaide researchers have developed a new technique that will aid in a more accurate reconstruction of human genomes by determining the exact sections of the genome that come from each parent.

Studying the hotbed of horizontal gene transfers

October 23, 2018

For over 200,000 years, humans and their gut microbiomes have coevolved into some of the most complex collections of living organisms on the planet. But as human lifestyles vary from the urban to rural, so do the bacterial ...

Researchers have discovered a new cell structure

October 23, 2018

A new structure in human cells has been discovered by researchers at Karolinska Institutet in Sweden in collaboration with colleagues in the U.K. The structure is a new type of protein complex that the cell uses to attach ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.