There is little to fear from nanoparticles in food

June 8, 2016 by Ian Rae, The Conversation
Some companies have used nano-titanium dioxide to make powdered sugar on donuts whiter. Credit: Shutterstock

Nanomaterials, and especially nanoparticles, have been on some people's worry list for at least a decade.

The definition of a nanomaterial is rather loose, just specifying that it must have at least one dimension of 100 nanometres or less. This means that the material could be a sheet, fibre, wire or a particle.

For nanoparticles in particular, all three dimensions are likely to be tiny. This means they will often be about 100 times smaller than the particles in air pollution, which range in size from 10 micrometres (PM10) down to 2.5 micrometres (PM2.5).

The substances that make up the nanoparticles – most often the oxides of zinc, silicon and titanium – and are generally not regarded as toxic. But the particles are so small that their behaviour can be quite different from what we see on a large scale.

We know that nanoparticles in sunscreens and cosmetics can penetrate the skin, and this raises questions about what they can do in the body. Nanosilver is also used as a disinfectant, such as when it is included in clothing items like socks.

In terms of , nanoparticles can be present at levels of a few percent, often mixed with larger particles. Some foods have silicon dioxide (silica) as an anti-clumping agent to keep mixtures free-flowing, while others have to confer extra whiteness.

You may recall the news item from March last year about the use of titanium dioxide in the frosting of donuts. The application was withdrawn in the face of consumer resistance.

The use of nanosilver in food is restricted but there may be residues on fruit and vegetables that have been disinfected by washing with suspensions of nanosilver.

While there is no sign that nanomaterials are used in in Australia or New Zealand, they are being used overseas. Some applications are adding nanoparticles of clay to make packaging more robust, or adding nanosilver as a disinfectant.

Some future developments could involve nanoparticles that act as indicators, by changing colour for instance, if the contents deteriorate in quality over time.

Small risks

Keeping an eye on our food is the bi-national government agency Food Standards Australia and New Zealand (FSANZ), which has just released two long-awaited reports on the safety of nanoparticles in food, one on additives and one on packaging.

The reports were commissioned in 2015 and were written by one of Australia's leading toxicologists, Dr Roger Drew, and his colleague Tarah Hagen.

Both reports were based on comprehensive surveys of the scientific literature and relevant patents.

The upshot of both reports is that the most common nanoscale materials likely to be present in food or food packaging – , titanium dioxide and metallic silver – do not pose significant health risks.

In terms of food, many common foods already contain natural nanoparticles, but FSNAZ was specifically interested in "engineered" or manufactured nanoparticles and their effects.

In terms of packaging, studies where nanomaterials are used in packaging have shown that nanomaterials can migrate from the packaging into the food therein.

Ingested nanoparticles can, and do, get into the body in places where bulk materials cannot, but there is no evidence that mere size is responsible for the effects observed in laboratory studies.

Any impact is caused by soluble materials or colloids, such as gels, that are formed by interaction of the nanomaterials with aggressive components, such as food acids or body fluids.

Soluble materials bring the elements – silicon, titanium and silver – into contact with vital systems. The case of silver is especially interesting since silver is not bioactive until the metal is converted to silver ions, which is when it becomes harmful.

However, the authors noted that there have been few studies of the effects of nanoparticles on large populations of people. That said, nanomaterials have been used for many years, and there has been no evidence of harm.

Also, in order to make an accurate risk assessment, you need to look at both hazard (in this case, toxicity) and exposure. So a substance that is highly toxic might still be low risk if exposure is typically very low.

There have been few regulatory studies on nanoparticles in which hazard and exposure have been considered together, so it's difficult to provide a comprehensive risk assessment.

What it means for us

It's understandable that many people are wary of a new technology that has unknown effects on health.

However, these reports should reassure us that the scientific and empirical evidence to date suggests nanoparticles in food or food packaging pose low risk.

That doesn't mean there isn't more work to be done to learn more about and their biological effects. However, given the expense of mounting large-scale studies, and the likelihood that they will also find no significant health effects, the cost may not be justified.

Nonetheless, we should expect FSANZ to follow developments in the science and, most importantly, to learn more about just which are used in food and packaging applications in Australia. It would be good if this were also to lead to improved food labelling standards.

Explore further: Developing new methods to detect nanoparticles in food

Related Stories

Developing new methods to detect nanoparticles in food

July 8, 2015

The production and characterisation of reference materials to detect silver nanoparticles in meat is feasible, a recent experiment has found. Using methods developed through the NANOLYSE project, two concentrations of silver ...

The impact of anti-odor clothing on the environment

March 30, 2016

Anti-odor athletic clothes containing silver nanoparticles have gained a foothold among exercise buffs, but questions have arisen over how safe and effective they are. Now scientists report in ACS' journal Environmental Science ...

How nanoparticles flow through the environment

May 12, 2016

Carbon nanotubes remain attached to materials for years while titanium dioxide and nanozinc are rapidly washed out of cosmetics and accumulate in the ground. Within the National Research Program "Opportunities and Risks of ...

Nanosilver: A new name -- well-known effects

January 31, 2011

Nanosilver is not a new discovery by nanotechnologists -- it has been used in various products for over a hundred years, as is shown by a new Empa study. The antimicrobial effects of minute silver particles, which were then ...

Recommended for you

The microscopic origin of efficiency droop in LEDs

November 21, 2017

Light-emitting diodes—or LEDs, as they are commonly known—have been slowly replacing incandescent light bulbs in applications ranging from car taillights to indicators on electronics since their invention in the 1960s.

Borophene shines alone as 2-D plasmonic material

November 20, 2017

An atom-thick film of boron could be the first pure two-dimensional material able to emit visible and near-infrared light by activating its plasmons, according to Rice University scientists.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

julianpenrod
1 / 5 (1) Jun 08, 2016
It's not often that the essence of a situation is made overtly obvious.
Many who have placed comments may have been surprised that, when entered into the box, words like "color" or "humor" might have a red line as if misspelled. This website originates from areas where British spellings are more often used. And this is admitted in saying "our"food is monitored by Australian and New Zealand authorities.
So this is not originating from the U.S. But, note that many nations are seen as backward with respect to things like food safety, so, although this gives an imprimatur of safety to nanoparticles, that is not the opinion of American agencies, so people may be misled.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.