Cobalt-ligand catalyst successfully converts carboxylic acids and esters into alcohols

October 23, 2015 by Heather Zeiger, report

The hydroxyl (-OH) functional group with bond angle. Credit: Public Domain
(—Researchers report the discovery of a cobalt-ligand catalyst system that serves as a homogeneous catalyst for the hydrogenation of esters and carboxylic acids to alcohols. Ties J. Korstanje, Jarl Ivar van der Vlught, Cornelis J. Elsevier, and Bas de Bruin of Van't Hoff Institute for Molecular Sciences, University of Amsterdam demonstrate their catalyst's versatility in reducing a variety of bio-based carboxylic acids and esters under relatively mild conditions. Furthermore, their catalyst has a high turnover rate and has good selectivity. Their work appears in the recent issue of Science.

Biomass feedstock is an up-and-coming area of energy production that seeks to find an alternative to fossil fuels as a source of energy. Biomass, such as plants and algae, contain compounds that can be converted to energy bearing molecules, such as alcohols and hydrocarbons. One that is of interest is the reduction of esters and to alcohols. The traditional reagents for the hydrogenation of carboxylic acids and esters are aluminum hydride or borohydride, but these compounds are dangerous and tend to produce too much waste. Additional options for this reaction include heterogeneous catalysts that either require harsh reaction conditions or are not generally applicable to a variety of substrates, or homogenous catalysts that use expensive noble metals (e.g., ruthenium and iridium).

Hydrogenation reactions tend to be easier with esters than with carboxylic acids. Prior to the reported research, the best examples of homogenous catalysts for hydrogenating carboxylic acids were ruthenium/triphos and iridium/triphos systems. These metal-ligand systems, while successful, are prohibitively expensive for practical applications.

Korstanje, et al. developed a cobalt-ligand by first identifying which cobalt precursors would react with the triphos ligand system to form a stable complex that can reduce methyl benzoate to benzyl alcohol and methanol. They found that commercially available Co(BF4)2•6H2O (10 mol%) with triphos at 100oC and 80 bar of H2 successfully converted methyl benzoate within five hours. They also tested their catalytic system with benzoic acid (5 mol%) and achieved full conversion to benzyl alcohol in four hours. Typically carboxylic acids are more difficult to convert than their corresponding carboxylic esters, but the shorter reaction time for benzoic acid indicates that this catalyst favorably converts carboxylic acids.

They then tested the versatility of their Co/triphos catalytic system using several esters and carboxylic acid substrates that would be of interest in biomass feedstock or pharmaceuticals. They observed the successful hydrogenation of sterically hindered tert-butylbenzoate and biomass product γ-valerolacetone as well as levulinic acid and succinic acid. They successfully hydrogenated a long-chain fatty acid and a triglyceride. They also found that their catalyst system tolerates several functional groups, such as chlorides, fluorides, trifluoromethyls, and hydroxides.

In an effort to test and optimize their catalyst system, they tried replacing the triphos ligand with other comparable ligand structure, but it yielded no catalytic activity, indicating that the triphos ligand was the optimal choice for this system. They tested other cobalt compounds, but found that none of them were noticeably better compared to Co(BF4)2•6H2O.

They also tested the catalyst system in the presence of added reagents. Adding acid or base to the reaction mixture did not affect the outcome of the hydrogenation reaction. Adding an additional reducing agent, such as zinc dust, did not have an appreciable effect on the hydrogenation reaction. Notably, the addition of certain Lewis acids, tetraphenylborate, and other agents killed the reaction, indicating that the anion plays a role in the reaction mechanism.

Korstanje, et al. elucidated the reaction mechanism by conducting partial poisoning studies using TEMPO (2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperdine-1-oxyl) and TMTU (tetramethylthiourea). They conducted analyses using high resolution ESI-MS and in situ electron paramagnetic resonance studies to determine cobalt's oxidation state throughout the reaction. Their proposed reaction mechanism involves the key compound, Co(triphos)(κ2-alkanoate) as the lowest energy or resting state.

This research provides for a compelling catalytic system that is practically feasible compared to other catalysts because of the diversity of esters and carboxylic acid substrates that it successfully hydrogenates as well as its relatively mild reaction conditions. This Co/triphos catalyst has broad applications from biomass feedstock chemistry to pharmaceuticals.

Explore further: New synthetic route to potential medicines for type 2 diabetes

More information: T. J. Korstanje et al. Hydrogenation of carboxylic acids with a homogeneous cobalt catalyst, Science (2015). DOI: 10.1126/science.aaa8938

The reduction of esters and carboxylic acids to alcohols is a highly relevant conversion for the pharmaceutical and fine-chemical industries and for biomass conversion. It is commonly performed using stoichiometric reagents, and the catalytic hydrogenation of the acids previously required precious metals. Here we report the homogeneously catalyzed hydrogenation of carboxylic acids to alcohols using earth-abundant cobalt. This system, which pairs Co(BF4)2·6H2O with a tridentate phosphine ligand, can reduce a wide range of esters and carboxylic acids under relatively mild conditions (100°C, 80 bar H2) and reaches turnover numbers of up to 8000.

Related Stories

Aromatic couple makes new chemical bonds

June 29, 2015

Esters have been identified to act as a new and clean coupling partner for the carbon-carbon bond forming cross-coupling reaction to make useful compounds for pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals and organic materials.

From waste stream to sustainable fuel

October 6, 2015

Many industrial processes produce large quantities of waste water containing all kinds of chemicals. These contaminated water streams can be used to produce hydrogen gas with help of catalysts without vaporizing the water. ...

Recommended for you

Synthetic molecule invades double-stranded DNA

November 12, 2018

Carnegie Mellon University researchers have developed a synthetic molecule that can recognize and bind to double-stranded DNA or RNA under normal physiological conditions. The molecule could provide a new platform for developing ...

Scientists bring polymers into atomic-scale focus

November 12, 2018

From water bottles and food containers to toys and tubing, many modern materials are made of plastics. And while we produce about 110 million tons per year of synthetic polymers like polyethylene and polypropylene worldwide ...

New catalyst turns pollutant into fuel

November 12, 2018

Rather than allow power plants and industry to toss carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, incoming Rice University assistant professor Haotian Wang has a plan to convert the greenhouse gas into useful products in a green way.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Oct 24, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
not rated yet Oct 24, 2015
Patents only protect a device or a drug for 17 years. This is not really a long time when you consider how long it takes to ramp up production and make a profit. Sometimes pharmaceutical companies can make a small change to a formula and obtain another patent. Like most other big industries, big Pharma, pretty much owns the government and that is why drugs in the US cost more than any country in the world.
Oct 24, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.