On quantum scales, there are many second laws of thermodynamics

February 9, 2015, University College London
In the microregime, when can a state ρS with Hamiltonian HS be transformed to a state ρS′ and Hamiltonian HS′? To do so, one can couple the system to a heat bath ρβ =e−βHR =Z with Hamiltonian HR and use any devices as long as they are returned back in their original state (thus we may think of them as a catalyst––σ)and we are allowed to perform any action as long as we preserve the overall energy (see below for a more detailed description of these operations, which we call catalytic thermal operations). Loosely speaking, our second law says that ρS can transit to ρS′ if and only if ρS′ is closer to the thermal state ρβ of the system at inverse temperature β with respect to all Rényi divergences. In the thermodynamic limit, all these quantities converge so that we recover the usual second law. Credit: PNAS[/i], doi/10.1073/pnas.1411728112

New research from UCL and the Universities of Gdansk, Singapore, and Delft has uncovered additional second laws of thermodynamics which complement the ordinary second law of thermodynamics, one of the most fundamental laws of nature. These new second laws are generally not noticeable except on very small scales, at which point, they become increasingly important.

The ordinary second law states that the universe is in a growing state of disorder. It tells us that a hot cup of tea in a cold room will cool down rather than heat up; that even the most efficient machines will lose some energy as heat; and more prosaically, that a house will gradually get messier over time rather than tidying itself.

The research, published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, reveals that on very small scales there is actually a whole family of 'second laws', which can lead to unexpected and counterintuitive phenomena.

"The traditional second law of thermodynamics is sometimes thought of as a statistical law that only holds when there is a vast numbers of particles that make up a system," said Professor Jonathan Oppenheim (UCL Physics & Astronomy), one of the authors of the study. "Even while individual parts of a system may become more ordered, the overall entropy of the total system (a measure of disorder) increases."

In a sense, the traditional second law only holds on average.

More recently, physicists have begun wondering whether the second law holds not just on average, for very large systems, but whether it holds for small individual systems, such as those with only a small number of particles. Surprisingly, the researchers found that not only does the second law hold at such small scales, but there are actually many other second laws at work. In other words, just like larger systems, small systems also tend to become more disordered. But there are additional second laws which constrain the way in which disorder can increase.

"These additional second laws, can be thought of as saying that there are many different kinds of disorder at small scales, and they all tend to increase as time goes on," said co-author Professor Michal Horodecki (Gdansk).

The researchers found additional measures of disorder, all different to the standard entropy, which quantify different types of disorder. They showed that not only does entropy increase, but other types of disorder also have to increase.

"Statistical laws apply when we consider large numbers. For example, imagine we toss a coin thousands of times. In this case, we expect to see roughly equal numbers of heads as tails. However, this is not true when tossing the coin just a few times. It's possible we will find all the coins landing tails. Similar phenomena occur when considering systems made out of very few particles, instead of very many particles," said co-author Professor Stephanie Wehner (Delft). "We can use tools from quantum information theory to understand the case when we don't have a large number of particles."

Professor Oppenheim added: "While a quantum house will get messier rather than tidier, like a normal house, our research shows that the ways in which it can get messier are constrained by a range of extra laws. Stranger still, the way these second laws interact with each other can even make it look like the traditional second law has been violated. For instance, a small system can spontaneously become more ordered when it interacts with another system which barely seems to change. That means some rooms in the quantum house may spontaneously become much tidier, while others only become messier but only imperceptibly."

The results of the study give an improved understanding of how heat and energy is transformed on very small scales. This is expected to have wide applications in the design of small systems, including nanoscale devices, biological motors, and quantum technologies such as quantum computers.

Explore further: Quantum engines must break down

More information: The second laws of quantum thermodynamics, PNAS, www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1411728112

Related Stories

Quantum engines must break down

June 26, 2013

Our present understanding of thermodynamics is fundamentally incorrect if applied to small systems and needs to be modified, according to new research from University College London (UCL) and the University of Gdańsk. The ...

Black hole thermodynamics

September 10, 2014

In the 1800s scientists studying things like heat and the behavior of low density gases developed a theory known as thermodynamics. As the name suggests, this theory describes the dynamic behavior of heat (or more generally ...

Quantum mechanical behaviour at the macroscale

February 6, 2015

Most quantum physics research to date has used particles such as atoms and electrons to observe quantum mechanical behaviour. Professor Mika Sillanpää of Aalto University is now working in the relatively new field of using ...

Physicists design zero-friction quantum engine

September 16, 2014

(Phys.org) —In real physical processes, some energy is always lost any time work is produced. The lost energy almost always occurs due to friction, especially in processes that involve mechanical motion. But in a new study, ...

Recommended for you

Team takes a deep look at memristors

January 19, 2018

In the race to build a computer that mimics the massive computational power of the human brain, researchers are increasingly turning to memristors, which can vary their electrical resistance based on the memory of past activity. ...

Information engine operates with nearly perfect efficiency

January 19, 2018

Physicists have experimentally demonstrated an information engine—a device that converts information into work—with an efficiency that exceeds the conventional second law of thermodynamics. Instead, the engine's efficiency ...

Artificial agent designs quantum experiments

January 19, 2018

On the way to an intelligent laboratory, physicists from Innsbruck and Vienna present an artificial agent that autonomously designs quantum experiments. In initial experiments, the system has independently (re)discovered ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Feb 09, 2015
The devil in the details!
1 / 5 (2) Feb 10, 2015
Quantum Theory is a statistical one the same as in Classical Mechanics. The seize of objects in experiment is only different. Therefore; one cannot deal just with 'few" quantum objects. One always deals (in experiments) with "streams" (or sets) of these objects. Sure, there could be new orders (laws) governing such sets of micro objects
ps.so called paradoxes (ex.Schrodinger cat) are for philsophical fools (here: most of scientists)
1 / 5 (1) Feb 10, 2015
The advancing technologies produced by the human mind, taken over their history and viewed as a unity, disprove the 2nd law of thermodynamics holds for society. Progress is open ended and increasingly more orderly and coherent.
1 / 5 (1) Feb 10, 2015
Of course. What was that not evident?
1 / 5 (1) Feb 10, 2015
Offered is a 'shape' to all possible laws.

Applications pending.

Feb 10, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Feb 10, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Feb 10, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Feb 10, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Feb 10, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
5 / 5 (1) Feb 11, 2015
These sorts of extrapolations are amusing but often not as useful as it seems. The Rényi entropy is not thermodynamical (physical) entropy, but apparently a measure of entanglement. [ http://en.wikiped..._entropy ]

So they entangle heat baths. But confusingly, not sinks but separate systems called "catalysts". I'm sure the paper explains why, but it seems a messy way to handle a messy situation. =D

Re speculations on thermodynamics vs quantum systems, of course quantum physics applies everywhere (already by not allowing hidden variables, but more generally by being basic) and of course it can't break its own classical behavior where it applies (such as thermodynamics).
Steve 200mph Cruiz
not rated yet Feb 14, 2015

Entropy refers to the disorder of particles, the heat energy of atoms is carried away by infared photos and is wasted. That's what efficiency is a measure of in the context of a lightbulb or electric motor.

A tv is much more entropic than a watch, feel that heat baby. But it also took a supply chain around the world to build that tv, which took a lot of energy, which means a lot of energy was wasted. I mean there's mines all around the world processing those materials which are then shipped to manufacturers all over the which are then sold in stores all over the world. All that travel is brought to us by the motor engine which literally works by exploding things and creating entropy.
not rated yet Feb 15, 2015
And so the question beckons "how many demons does it really take to change Maxwell's lightbulb"?
Feb 15, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Feb 15, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
not rated yet Feb 16, 2015
Nothing new about this. A bit of re-discovery.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.