New method distinguishes yellow perch females from males

June 3, 2014 by Sandra Avant, Agricultural Research Service
ARS scientists are studying yellow perch to determine ways to better select fish for faster growth and better disease resistance. Credit: Robert Colletta.

A plentiful supply of yellow perch was once available in the U.S. Great Lakes region, but that changed in the 1990s. Populations of this Midwest fish-fry favorite dropped dramatically due to the invasion of the zebra mussel, overfishing, and other factors.

Agricultural Research Service scientists are working closely with the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee School of Freshwater Sciences to ensure that the aquaculture industry produces enough to meet consumer demand. This high-value fish is very low in fat, high in protein and calcium, and has a mild, sweet flavor.

Using traditional breeding methods, scientists in the ARS Dairy Forage and Aquaculture Research Unit are developing genetically improved yellow perch by selecting for faster growth. One challenge has been the difference in growth rate between male and female yellow perch; tend to grow faster and larger than . But differences in growth rate alone are not sufficient to identify , says ARS fish physiologist Brian Shepherd. If only large fish are selected, there will be a strong bias toward females. The biggest males are also needed, but scientists had been unable to distinguish between smaller females and larger males.

To improve fish performance, scientists must also understand physiological differences between young female and male fish. But since gender identification is difficult until fish mature, it can be challenging to separate them for these kinds of studies.

"For example, if you're trying to genetically improve cattle, pigs, or sheep, imagine how difficult it would be to separate animals and manage them if you could not tell the sexes apart until they mature," Shepherd says. "It's problematic in yellow perch and other fish species."

Attention to Appearances

At the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee School of Freshwater Sciences, ARS fish physiologist Brian Shepherd (left), animal caretaker Timothy Paul (middle), and student Eric Vang collect data from male and female yellow perch as part of research to genetically improve the fish. Credit: Robert Colletta.

Shepherd and his colleagues developed criteria, based on the shape and color of the anal and reproductive openings, to identify the gender of yellow perch during early growth. The step-by-step procedure provides a systematic way to segregate males and females that are 3 inches or more in length. The process is fast, easy, and reliable. It involves an algorithm—a checklist that includes the size of the fish, the shape of specific parts, and other criteria.

The method is more than 97 percent accurate and provides a practical tool to cost-effectively sort females from males, Shepherd says. Gender separation can be used to develop yellow perch brood stocks, conduct gender-specific experiments, and identify the fastest growing females and males for growth performance.

"Because fish are unharmed, the algorithm can also be used to distinguish males from females during field surveys," Shepherd adds.

In the study, scientists examined different geographical strains of yellow perch and considered factors such as maturity and environmental conditions that may affect external characteristics related to gender. They examined yellow perch that were about 3 inches to 11 inches long and identified female and male characteristics that could be confirmed in four distinct geographical strains.

Scientists segregated the fish according to length within each strain and then determined gender based on external appearances. Fish have two openings—the anal and the urogenital—on their abdomen in front of their tails. The shape of the urogenital opening in males is round and generally larger in circumference than the anal opening, whereas females tend to have a V- or U-shaped opening that is smaller in circumference than the anal opening.

"Males usually have a more brownish-red coloration of that area than females do, especially when they're sexually immature," Shepherd says.

Brian Shepherd and Timothy Paul select yellow perch from a tank for traits desired in breeding. Credit: Robert Colletta.

Scientists confirmed gender by looking at the internal gonads of fish. "We had greater than 90 percent accuracy in correlating external gender with the true gender in females," Shepherd says. "Geographical locations of strains had significant effect on accuracy, so a stepwise checklist [algorithm] was developed to help producers determine whether the criteria would apply to their populations. With our algorithm, we were able to reliably identify the gender of yellow perch that were just 3.1 inches in length. That's a pretty small fish."

Without effective gender identification methods, scientists were retaining smaller females thinking they were males. The new system allows them to identify the biggest females and males for producing the next generation of yellow perch.

Determining Disease Resistance

In other research, Shepherd and his colleagues studied the yellow perch's immune response. Male and female were given a compound called "lipopolysaccharide," which mimics a bacterial infection. The female's immune response was lower than the male's, suggesting the females recovered faster or cleared the compound more effectively.

"Though more work is needed, this suggests that females may have a more robust immune system than males," Shepherd says. "Therefore, we aim to produce all-female yellow perch populations that will grow faster and have greater disease resistance. That should really be a tremendous advantage to producers."

Explore further: Researchers Find Genes Involved in Yellow Perch Growth

Related Stories

Researchers Find Genes Involved in Yellow Perch Growth

June 14, 2010

( -- Twenty-eight genes that are involved in bulking up yellow perch—an important aquaculture fish in the Great Lakes region—have been discovered by Agricultural Research Service (ARS) scientists and university ...

Males produce faster sperm for sisters

May 7, 2014

( —Mating with relatives, or inbreeding, can be costly to both sexes, and in many species males and females avoid mating with siblings.  However, the latest research adds a twist to this story by showing that ...

Recommended for you

Scientists create 'Evolutionwatch' for plants

February 21, 2018

Using a hitchhiking weed, scientists from the Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology reveal for the first time the mutation rate of a plant growing in the wild.

New tool tells bioengineers when to build microbial teams

February 21, 2018

Researchers at Duke University have created a framework for helping bioengineers determine when to use multiple lines of cells to manufacture a product. The work could help a variety of industries that use bacteria to produce ...

Triplefin fish found to have controlled iris radiance

February 21, 2018

A team of researchers with the University of Tübingen in Germany has found an example of a fish that is able to control light reflected from organs next to its pupils—a form of photolocation. In their paper published in ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 03, 2014
the zebra mussel had little to do with the drop in #s.

Pollution was the main cause and then overfishing.

It's amazing how often the zebra mussel is used as an excuse for any problem in that region.
1 / 5 (1) Jun 04, 2014
the zebra mussel had little to do with the drop in #s.

Pollution was the main cause and then overfishing.

It's amazing how often the zebra mussel is used as an excuse for any problem in that region.

Got any proof to back that statement up?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.