Climate change's heat—not cold—is the real killer

January 31, 2014 by H. Roger Segelken, Cornell University

( —Chill with impunity through this winter's extreme cold – and brace for the next summer heat wave, when fiery temperatures and air pollution conspire to fill hospitals and morgues.

That's the advice from a team of climate-change researchers who studied 170 million and 8 million deaths (season by season, day by day, for 10 years) in Germany before issuing a report with global implications.

"We show that extreme heat events have a highly significant and largely adverse impact on both hospitalizations and deaths, whereas extreme cold seems to have a negligible real-world impact on ," said Nicolas Ziebarth, assistant professor of policy analysis and management in Cornell's College of Human Ecology.

Ziebarth published "The Short-term Population Health Effects of Weather and Pollution: Implications of Climate Change" in the December 2013 Journal of Economic Literature with Maike Schmitt, Darmstadt Technical University, and Martin Karlsson, University of Duisburg-Essen. Ziebarth is also affiliated with the German Institute for Economic Research and the Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA).

The researchers gathered a decade's worth (1999-2008) of health, temperature and data from a variety of sources – including 1,044 weather stations and 1,314 air quality monitors across Germany and all 17 million hospital admissions and 800,000 deaths that occur in Germany per year. They were particularly interested in deaths from respiratory, infectious or metabolic causes that might be linked to heat stress and pollution.

An extreme "cold day," for study purposes, had temperatures below 14 degrees F, and a "cold wave" was four days of such temperatures. A "hot day" had temperatures above 86 degrees F, and a "heat wave" was four consecutive hot days.

Severe air pollution days had alert-level amounts of ozone, nitrate and particulate matter in the air (according to EU standards, which have much lower alert thresholds than the United States).

The analysis found temperature-and-pollution spikes tended to increase hospital admissions and deaths by 2 percent to 5 percent the first day. Adverse and mortality mounted with each day of a .

But extreme cold events typically had no effect on hospitalization and numbers. In some cases, hospital admissions actually decreased during extreme cold days – probably, researchers speculate, because people have trouble traveling to hospitals on icy roads.

Their analysis of heat waves (averaging about one per year in Germany between 1999 and 2006) took into account the grimly named "harvesting effect," when the gravely ill, whose deaths were imminent, died during the first day or two of extreme heat.

"We showed that extremely high temperatures do not lead to a permanent increase in hospitalizations and deaths – just an 'instantaneous heat-health relationship' in the short term," Ziebarth noted.

Distributed across the entire population of a country like Germany or the United States, Ziebarth estimated, the cost of a hot day is between 10 cents and 68 cents per resident in health care and lost productivity.

Looking ahead, other researchers link the melting arctic sea ice to colder winters (and occasional, atypically chilly summer days) in North America and Europe. Climate change is leading to more frequent, more severe heat and cold events in the mid-latitudes, and that trend is probably unstoppable, they say.

But, the researchers said, one factor in the heat/pollution/health connection could be controlled by national and municipal governments: air quality. "Lower pollution-alert levels would be beneficial for population health," they conclude in the report, "and would save lives."

Explore further: Heat waves pose asthma risk spike for babies

More information: The paper, "The Short-term Population Health Effects of Weather and Pollution: Implications of Climate Change," is available online:

Related Stories

Heat waves pose asthma risk spike for babies

October 14, 2013

(Medical Xpress)—Babies are at an increased risk of having an asthma attack during a heat wave, new research into the effects of weather events on the debilitating respiratory condition has uncovered.

Climate change increased the number of deaths

October 22, 2013

The increased temperatures caused by ongoing climate change in Stockholm, Sweden between 1980 and 2009 caused 300 more premature deaths than if the temperature increase did not take place. In Sweden as a whole, it would mean ...

Nighttime heat waves quadruple in Pacific Northwest

July 19, 2013

Nighttime heat waves are becoming more frequent in western Washington and Oregon. And if you don't sleep well in hot weather, this might be a good time to buy a fan, since records show that on average heat waves tend to strike ...

Death rates will rise because of global warming

July 2, 2007

Global warming will cause more deaths in summer because of higher temperatures but these will not be offset by fewer deaths in milder winters finds an analysis published online ahead of print in Occupational and Environment ...

Recommended for you

Earth's deep mantle flows dynamically

March 25, 2019

As ancient ocean floors plunge over 1,000 km into the Earth's deep interior, they cause hot rock in the lower mantle to flow much more dynamically than previously thought, finds a new UCL-led study.

Scientists solve mystery shrouding oldest animal fossils

March 25, 2019

Scientists from The Australian National University (ANU) have discovered that 558 million-year-old Dickinsonia fossils do not reveal all of the features of the earliest known animals, which potentially had mouths and guts.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.