Scientists propose creating Maxwell's demon with two quantum dots

February 1, 2013 by Lisa Zyga feature
In a minimalistic implementation of Maxwell’s demon, two interacting quantum dots are connected to thermal reservoirs, where one dot takes the role of the demon and the other that of the controlled system. Physicists have theoretically shown that the demon can modify the controlled system’s entropy production. Credit: Philipp Strasberg, et al. ©2013 American Physical Society

(—When you open your door on a cold winter day, the warm air from your home and the cold air from outside begin to mix and evolve toward thermal equilibrium, a state of complete entropy where the temperatures outside and inside are the same. This situation is a rough example of the second law of thermodynamics, which says that entropy in a closed system never decreases. If you could control the air flow in a way that uses a sufficiently small amount of energy, so that the entropy of the system actually decreases overall, you would have a hypothetical mechanism called Maxwell's demon.

Maxwell's demon is named after the physicist James Clerk Maxwell, who first considered the idea in the 1800s. He proposed that the demon would act as a doorman, allowing only hot (fast-moving) molecules to go one way and cold (slow-moving) molecules to go the other way. Theoretically, the demon would be able to heat a hot reservoir and cool down a cold reservoir. As long as the demon uses a sufficiently small amount of energy, the entropy that it creates will be less than the entropy of the system that it lowers. As a result, Maxwell's demon violates the .

So far, scientists have not been able to physically create Maxwell's demon, at least not without increasing more entropy elsewhere. However, they have been trying numerous approaches, especially in the last decade.

In a new study, Philipp Strasberg at the Institute of Technology in Berlin, and coauthors have proposed that Maxwell's demon can be physically implemented with two interacting connected to thermal , where one dot takes the role of the demon and the other that of the controlled system. The experiment doesn't violate the second , but it provides a very simple, minimalist implementation of the demon.

"To the best of our knowledge, our work provides for the first time a complete thermodynamic description of a minimalistic Maxwell demon," coauthor Massimiliano Esposito at the University of Luxembourg told "We rigorously quantify the action of the Maxwell demon on the system by identifying the information flux that he is generating. But we also clearly demonstrate that when the entropy production needed to implement the Maxwell demon mechanism is taken into account, the second law for the system together with the demon is recovered."

In other words, entropy does increase somewhere, but not in the first quantum dot alone.

"As a whole, the combined system (including the demon) is just a thermoelectric device where thermal gradients are used to generate an electric current," Esposito said. "As such, it does of course respect the thermodynamics, i.e., its total entropy is always increasing. However, if the part of the system implementing the demon is disregarded, everything looks as if the remaining part of the system was subjected to a Maxwell demon breaking the second law while keeping the first one intact."

In their proposed experiment, the scientists coupled one dot to two reservoirs, which acts as a single-electron transistor, and coupled the second dot to another reservoir. The showed that the second dot can be tuned to detect the transistor's state, which is either empty (0) or filled (1). In order to do this, the two dots must be perfectly correlated, so that when the first dot (transistor) gets filled up, the second dot (detector) gets emptied, and vice versa. When the detector performs an infinitely fast and precise feedback, then the system receives additional information during entropy production.

"Maxwell's demon is typically envisaged as an intelligent being performing feedback control operations on a monitored system and thereby modifying the entropy balance whilst keeping its energetics unaffected," coauthor Gernot Schaller at the Institute of Technology in Berlin said. "If it is just for the sake of sorting particles, the demon however need not be so smart such that it is possible to encode its function in a physical device.

"Due to the capacitive interaction, the demon changes its state and back-acts on the system. In its simplest operational mode, the system may thus transport electrons against a potential gradient. Since the measurement and control are performed with physical devices, our model includes an exchange of energy between demon and system. However, the modification of the system's energy balance can be made unobservably small whilst preserving a strong modification of the system's production."

In the future, the researchers hope that this experiment could be realized.

"Perspectives for performing this experiment are not bad," Schaller said. "A scanning tunneling microscope could be converted into a demon device, whereas the required tunneling rates could be engineered using a more sophisticated quantum dot structure."

Explore further: Maxwell's demon demonstration turns information into energy

More information: Philipp Strasberg, et al. "Thermodynamics of a Physical Model Implementing a Maxwell Demon." Physical Review Letters 110, 040601 (2013). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.110.040601

Journal reference: Physical Review Letters search and more info website


Related Stories

Could Maxwell's Demon Exist in Nanoscale Systems?

June 24, 2009

( -- Maxwell’s demon may be making a comeback. Physicists know that the demon, an imaginary creature that decreases the entropy of a system, cannot exist in macroscopic systems due to the energy it requires ...

Showcase UAV demonstrates 'Flapless Flight'

September 27, 2010

( -- A novel unmanned air vehicle (UAV) which showcases a wide range of new technologies has successfully demonstrated 'flapless flight' in the UK.

Holographic dark information energy

May 30, 2011

Holographic Dark Information Energy gets my vote for the best mix of arcane theoretical concepts expressed in the shortest number of words – and just to keep it interesting, it’s mostly about entropy.

Recommended for you

Modeling the rhythmic electrical activities of the brain

January 24, 2017

Researchers studying the brain have long been interested in its neural oscillations, the rhythmic electrical activity that plays an important role in the transmission of information within the brain's neural circuits. In ...

Sci-fi holograms a step closer with tiny invention

January 24, 2017

Australian National University physicists have invented a tiny device that creates the highest quality holographic images ever achieved, opening the door to imaging technologies seen in science fiction movies such as Star ...

Camera able to capture imagery of an optical Mach cone

January 23, 2017

(—A team of researchers at Washington University in St. Louis has built a camera apparatus capable of capturing moving imagery of an optical Mach cone. In their paper published in the journal Science Advances, ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Whydening Gyre
1 / 5 (3) Feb 03, 2013
Stupid article.
It's just a re-hash of Stirling Engine principles. WHere's the big, NEW ideas?
Makes that "wierd testosterone trick" advert look interesting, tho...
1 / 5 (1) Feb 03, 2013
IMO there it's an increasing experimental evidence, that the magnetic domains can actually play a role of Maxwell demon and to cool the material bellow room temperature, while gaining their energy from vacuum fluctuations. When they're arranged with magnetic field, they're rearranging spontaneously with vacuum fluctuations when this field it shutdown - even at the moment, when this process would connected with exerting of macroscopic energy into outside by doing mechanical work. It's essentially the principle of magnetic cooler, which is doing usable work at the room temperature. The silence of official physics about it just serves as an indicia, that this effect is real in similar way, like the cold fusion effects.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.