Feds likely to let Google buy Motorola Mobility

August 16, 2011 By JOELLE TESSLER , AP Technology Writer
In this May 11, 2011 file photo, attendees chat at the Google IO Developers Conference in San Francisco. Google is buying cell phone maker Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc., for $12.5 billion in cash Monday, Aug. 15, 2011, in what is by far the company's biggest acquisition to date. (AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez, File)

(AP) -- Federal regulators are unlikely to block Google Inc. from buying cellphone maker Motorola Mobility since the acquisition could help drive competition in the fast growing mobile device market.

But the deal comes as faces scrutiny in the U.S. and overseas from antitrust regulators concerned that the Web search giant may be abusing its clout as a major gateway to the Internet to muscle its way into new businesses and stifling competition in the process. In response to complaints by rivals, the is ramping up a broad inquiry into possible by Google. The European Commission, the Texas attorney general and the are also investigating the company.

Google's plan to buy Motorola Mobility for roughly $12.5 billion marks the latest in a string of high-profile acquisitions as the company expands beyond its core online search business. Google is seeking to buy the device maker, which uses its Android operating system, at a time when more and more people are going online using mobile devices rather than desktop computers, and finding what they want online through apps rather than search engines.

Devices such as smartphones and tablet computers running Google's Android operating system are battling Apple's wildly popular and iPad, Research in Motion's BlackBerry and mobile devices using Microsoft operating systems for consumers' dollars. Android is considered to be "open" software, meaning that Google gives it to device makers free of charge and allows them to modify it for their products in whatever way they see fit.

The Motorola deal will be reviewed by the either the Justice Department or the FTC to determine whether the combined company could hurt competition in the mobile computing market. For antitrust regulators, the biggest concern is that once Google owns a device manufacturer, it will be in direct competition with other smartphone and makers that also use the Android operating system, explained John Mayo, a professor at Georgetown University's McDonough School of Business.

Google has pledged to operate Motorola Mobility and Android as separate businesses. But Mayo said the acquisition could give Google an incentive to provide Motorola with exclusive access to its latest innovations and newest Android features, and even to withhold software upgrades from rival device makers.

Still, four other big device makers that also use Android - Samsung, Sony Ericsson, HTC Corp. and LG Electronics - have all said they support the deal. That's because the Motorola acquisition gives Google a portfolio of more than 17,000 patents on phone technology that can be used to defend Android device makers from patent infringement litigation.

That support signals that other device makers believe Google wants to protect and grow its Android business - and see Android used on as many mobile devices as possible - rather than restrict access to the platform, said Ed Black, president and chief executive of the Computer & Communications Industry Association.

If anything, may see the deal as a boost to competition. Android is such a crucial competitor to the iPhone in particular, that allowing Google to buy Motorola Mobility will likely produce even more innovation in smartphones and other devices, said David Balto, a former FTC antitrust official who is now a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress.

Perhaps the biggest question is whether the Motorola Mobility deal could affect the broader Google antitrust inquiry recently launched by the FTC. That probe will focus on whether Google, which handles two out of every three online searches in the U.S., abuses that control by placing links to its own content and services at the top of search results and burying links to rivals. Google's search results already highlight some of its own specialized services, including online mapping, video and finance.

Although search rankings raise a very different set of issues than the proposed Motorola Mobility acquisition, the FTC inquiry is still in its early stages and could yet delve into many other parts of Google's business, including Android. Among other things, the investigation could look at whether Google restricts the use of rival services on devices.

Against that backdrop, Google's decision to buy Motorola Mobility is a "gutsy move," said Melissa Maxman, an antitrust attorney with Cozen O'Connor. Google, she said, "is doubling down."

Still, Maxman said, the acquisition could reveal a different side of Google to the FTC. That's because the agency will focus on whether the company is leveraging existing monopolies in markets such as Internet search to extend its dominance into new businesses. The Motorola Mobility acquisition, she said, does not fit that pattern.

Given the dominant position of Apple and other device makers in the handset market, Maxman added, the Motorola deal serves as a reminder that "Google doesn't control everything."

Explore further: Motorola Mobility buys mobile software firm 3LM


Related Stories

Motorola Mobility buys mobile software firm 3LM

February 14, 2011

Motorola Mobility has made its first acquisition since being spun off as a separate company, buying mobile software maker Three Laws Mobility in a bid to expand corporate use of Android phones.

Motorola buy a blow to Google's Android partners

August 15, 2011

Google's Android partners welcomed the Internet giant's $12.5 billion purchase of Motorola Mobility on Monday but the move may force the handset makers to rethink their strategies, analysts said.

Google to buy Motorola Mobility for $12.5 billion (Update 2)

August 15, 2011

Google Inc.'s $12.5 billion deal to buy cellphone maker Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc. is aimed at giving the Internet search leader more legal firepower as it battles Apple Inc. and Microsoft Corp. to gain the upper hand ...

Microsoft reaches licensing deal on HTC phones

April 28, 2010

(AP) -- Microsoft Corp. says it has patents covering phones that use Google Inc.'s Android software - but unlike Apple Inc., Microsoft has reached a licensing deal rather than suing over the software.

Google accused of unfair trade in S. Korea

April 15, 2011

South Korea's top two Internet companies filed complaints with the antitrust watchdog Friday over Google's alleged practice of stifling competition in the local mobile phone search market.

Recommended for you

New method analyzes corn kernel characteristics

November 17, 2017

An ear of corn averages about 800 kernels. A traditional field method to estimate the number of kernels on the ear is to manually count the number of rows and multiply by the number of kernels in one length of the ear. With ...

Optically tunable microwave antennas for 5G applications

November 16, 2017

Multiband tunable antennas are a critical part of many communication and radar systems. New research by engineers at the University of Bristol has shown significant advances in antennas by using optically induced plasmas ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.