What limits the size of birds?

June 16, 2009,

Why aren't birds larger? Fifteen-kilogram swans hold the current upper size record for flying birds, although the extinct Argentavis of the Miocene Epoch in Argentina is estimated to have weighed 70 kilograms, the size of an average human. In a forthcoming article in PLoS Biology, Sievert Rohwer, and his colleagues at the Burke Museum at the University of Washington, provide evidence that maximum body size in birds is constrained by the amount of time it takes to replace the flight feathers during molt. As bird size increases, feather growth rate fails to keep up with feather length until, eventually; feathers wear out before they can be replaced. This fundamental relationship requires basic changes in the molt strategy as size increases, ultimately limiting the size of flying birds.

Feathers deteriorate with continued exposure to ultra-violet light and bacterial decomposition, and must be replaced periodically to maintain adequate aerodynamic support for flight. Small accomplish this in an annual or twice-annual molt, during which the 9 or 10 primary flight feathers are replaced sequentially, taking about three weeks for each feather. Large species of birds need different approaches to feather replacement. These involve several alternative strategies: prolonging the total molt to two or even three years; simultaneously replacing multiple feathers from different molt-origination points in the feather sequence; and, in species that do not require flight to feed or escape enemies (ducks and geese, for example), replacing all feathers simultaneously.

With increasing body size, the length of the primary feathers increases as the one-third power of mass, approximately doubling with each 10-fold increase in mass. However, the rate of feather growth increases only as the one-sixth power of mass, meaning that the time required to replace each feather increases by a factor of about 1.5 for each 10-fold increase in mass, until 56 days are required to replace a single flight feather in a 10-kg bird. The cause of this discrepancy is not known, but the authors speculate that it probably depends on the geometry of producing a two-dimensional feather structure from a one-dimensional growing zone in the feather shaft.

The avian feather is one of the most striking adaptations in the animal world, and yet its growth dynamics are poorly understood. It might be possible to achieve more rapid feather growth with a larger growth zone, but this could also weaken the structure of the growing feather, resulting in frequent breakage in large birds. Understanding the engineering complexities of the growing feather will require further study of the dynamics and structure of the growing zone. And what about Argentavis? The authors speculate that this giant bird most likely molted all its feathers simultaneously during a long fast, fueled by accumulated fat deposits much in the same way as emperor penguins do today.

Source: Public Library of Science (news : web)

Explore further: Fossil feathers preserve evidence of color

Related Stories

Fossil feathers preserve evidence of color

July 9, 2008

The traces of organic material found in fossil feathers are remnants of pigments that once gave birds their color, according to Yale scientists whose paper in Biology Letters opens up the potential to depict the original ...

Ancient Birds Flew On All-Fours

September 26, 2006

The earliest known ancestor of modern-day birds took to the skies by gliding from trees using primitive feathered wings on their arms and legs, according to new research by a University of Calgary paleontologist. In a paper ...

Feather color is more than skin deep

April 15, 2009

Where do birds get their red feathers from? According to Esther del Val, from the National History Museum in Barcelona, Spain, and her team, the red carotenoids that give the common crossbill (Loxia curvirostra) its red coloration ...

Feather scientists have Christmas all wrapped up

December 22, 2008

(PhysOrg.com) -- Material scientists at The University of Manchester are causing a festive flap after developing a way of making Christmas wrapping paper – from TURKEY FEATHERS.

Long, sexy tails not a drag on male birds

March 12, 2009

The long tails sported by many male birds in the tropics look like they're a drag to carry around and a distinct disadvantage when fleeing predators, but experiments by University of California, Berkeley, biologists shows ...

Recommended for you

Why don't turtles still have tail spikes?

January 17, 2018

We're all familiar with those awesome armored giants of the Jurassic and Cretaceous periods - Stegosaurus and Ankylosaurus - and their amazing, weaponized tails. But why aren't similar weaponized tails found in animals living ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Jun 16, 2009
Pterodactyls, the onetime rivals of birds, instead had a wing membrane like bats, and thus had no need to molt. This made them able to reach gigantic size, but like bats, the thin membrane would have been vulnerable to injury.
Birds do not have this problem, since the feathers overlap, and have microscopic "hooks" that attach them to each other. If a feather is lost, the other feathers quickly close the gap. This inherent robustness means birds of prey dares take on prey of similar size as themselves. Bats only take on prey much smaller than themselves. Pterodactyls were mostly eaters of fish, but some species ate smaller pterodactyls.
Non-flying species of birds can reach greater size, but are handicapped by the lack of arms/forelegs relative mammals as their wings are to specialized to easily re-evolve into legs. Also, the vulnerability of eggs have put large flightless birds at a disadvantage relative mammals.
Despite the existence of many non-flying giant bird predators in South America, they could therefore not hold their own when modern mammalian predators arrived on their continent ca. 2-3 million years ago.
4 / 5 (1) Jun 16, 2009
The hook and loop design of the feathers also seems to allow an aerodynamic plus that membrane method can not compete with. It appears that when a bird lifts its wing the hooks and loops separate, allowing air to flow through the feathers. This implies a greater directional behavior to the wing. The membrane method, though stiff during downward thrust is limited on the upward motion.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.